Skip to main content

Full text of "Permanent Revolution"

See other formats


GUPTA RAHMAN & GUPTA 
CALCUTTA 



First Indian Edition 
March 7947 



Price Rs. 5/8 



Published by Atawar Rahman 
Lower Circular Road, Calcutta 

* And 
Printed by Bhupal C. Dutt 

at the Art Press, 
20, British Indian Street , Calcutta 

Jacket by Satyajit Roy 
Bound by Basanti Binding Works 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 



PREFACE: AMERICAN EDITION 



As THIS book goes to press in the English language, the 
whole thinking part of the international working class, and 
in a sense, the whole of " civilized" humanity, listens with 
particularly keen interest to the reverberations of the 
economic turn taking place on the part of the former czarist 
empire. The greatest attention in this connection is aroused 
by the problem of collectivizing the peasant hold- 
ings. And no wonder : in this sphere the break with 
the past assumes a particularly clear-cut character. But a 
correct evaluation of collectivization is unthinkable without 
a general conception of the socialist revolution. And here 
on an even higher plane, we are again convinced that 
everything in the field of Marxian theory is bound up with 
practical activity. The most remote, and it would seem, 
"abstract" disagreements, if they are thought out to the 
end, will sooner or later be expressed in practise, and the 
latter allows not a single theoretical mistake to be made 
with impunity. 

The collectivization of peasant holdings is, it is under- 
stood, the most necessary and fundamental part of the 
socialist transformation of society. The volume and tempo 
of collectivization, however, are not only determined by 
the government's will but, in the final analysis, by the 
economic factors : by the height of the country's economic 
level, the relationship between industry and agriculture 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

and consequently by the technical resources of agriculture 
itself. 

Industrialization is the motive force of the whole newer 
culture and, by that, the only conceivable basis of 
socialism. In the conditions of the Soviet Union, indus- 
trialization means first of all the strengthening of the base 
of the proletariat as a ruling class. Simultaneously, it 
creates the material and technical premises for the collec- 
tivization of agriculture. The tempos of both these pro- 
cesses are interdependent. The proletariat is interested in 
the highest tempos for these processes, in so far as the new 
society that is to be created is thus best protected from 
external danger, and at the same time creates a source for 
systematically improving the material level of the toiling 
masses. 

However, the tempo that can be accomplished is limited 
by the whole material and cultural position of the country, 
by the mutual relationship between the city and village 
and by the most urgent needs of the masses, who can sacri- 
fice their today for the sake of tomorrow only up to a 
certain point. The best and most advantageous tempos 
are those which not only produce the most rapid develop- 
ment of industry and collectivization at the given moment, 
but secure the necessary resistance -of the social regime, 
that is, first of all the strengthening of the alliance of the 
workers and peasants, which alone prepares the possibility 
of further successes. 

From this point of view, the general historical criterion 
by which the party and state leadership directs the 
development of industry as planned economy assumes 
decisive significance. Here two principal variants are 
possible : (a) the course described above towards the 
economic entrenchment of the proletarian dictatorship in 
one country until further victories of the international 
proletariat revolution (the viewpoint of the Left Opposi- 
tion) ; (b) the course towards the construction of an isolated 
national socialist society and at that "in the shortest 



PREFACE, 

historical time" (the present official viewpoint). 

These are two distinct, and in the final analysis, directly 
opposed theoretical conceptions of socialism. Out of these 
flow basically different strategy and tactics. 

In the limits of this foreword we cannot consider anew 
the question of the cofcstruction of socialism in one country, 
Other of our works are devoted to this, particularly 
The Criticism of the Draft Program of the Comintern. 
Here we limit ourselves to the fundamental elements of the 
question. Let us recall, first of all, that the theory of 
socialism in one country was first formulated by Stalin in 
the fall of 1924, in complete contradiction not only to all 
the traditions of Marxism and the school of Lenin, but 
even to what Stalin wrote in the spring of the same year. 
From the standpoint of principle, the departure from 
Marxism by the Stalinist 'schobl' in the question of socialist 
construction is no less significant than, for example, the 
break of the German social democracy with Marxism in the 
question of war and patriotism, in the fall of 1914, that is, 
exactly ten years before the Stalinist turn. This comparison 
has no accidental character. Stalin's 'mistake', as well as 
the 'mistake' of the German social democracy, is national 
socialism. 

Marxism proceeds from world economy, not as a sum of 
national parts, but as a mighty, independent reality, which 
is created by the international division of labour and the 
world market, and, in the present epoch, predominates over 
the national markets. The productive forces of capitalist 
society have long ago grown beyond the national frontier. 
The imperialist war was an expression of this fact. In the 
productive-technical respect, socialist society must represent 
a higher stage compared to capitalism. To aim at the 
construction of a nationally isolated socialist society means, 
in spite of all temporary successes, to pull the productive 
forces backward ^even as compared to capitalism. To 
attempt, regardless of the geographic, cultural and histori- 
cal conditions of the country's development, which con- 

8 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

stitutes a part of the world whole, to realize a fenced-in 
proportionality of all the branches of economy within 
national limits, means /to pursue a reactionary Utopia. If 
the heralds and supporters of this theory nevertheless 
participate in the international revolutionary struggle (with 
what success is a different question) it is because as hopeless 
eclectics, they mechanically combine abstract interna- 
tionalism with reactionary Utopian national socialism. The 
consummate expression of this eclecticism is the program 
of the Comintern adopted by the Sixth Congress. 

To expose completely one of the main theoretical 
mistakes, lying at the base of the national socialist con- 
ception, we can do nothing better than to quote the recently 
published speech of Stalin, devoted to the internal questions 
of (American Communism. 1 "It would be wrong," says 
Stalin against one of the American factions, "not to take 
into consideration the specific peculiarities of American 
capitalism. The Communist party must consider them in 
its work. But it would be still more wrong to base the 
activity of the Communist party on these specific features, 
for the foundation of the activity of every Communist 
party, the American included, on which it must base itself, 
are the general features of capitalism, which are essentially 
the same for all countries, but not the specific features of 
one country. It is precisely on this that the internationalism 
of the Communist parties rests. The specific features are 
merely supplementary to the general features." (Bolshevik, 
No. 1, 1980, page 8.) 

These lines leave nothing to be desired in the way of 
clarity. Under the guise of an economic motivation for 
internationalism, Stalin in reality presents a motivation for 
national socialism. It is false that world economy is simply 
a sum of similar national parts. It is false that the specific 
features are "merely supplementary to the general features", 
like warts on the face. In reality, the national peculiarities 
are a unique combination of the basic features of the world 
process. This originality can be of decisive significance for 



PREFACE 

revolutionary strategy for a number of years. It is sufficient 
to recall the fact that the proletariat of a backward country 
has come to power many years before the proletariat of the 
advanced countries. This historic lesson alone shows that 
in spite of Stalin, it is absolutely wrong to base the activity 
of the Communist parties on some "general features", that 
is, on an abstract type of national capitalism. It is radic- 
ally wrong to contend that this is what the "internationalism 
of the Communist parties rests upon". In reality, it rests 
on the inconsistency of a national state, which has long ago 
outlived itself and acts as a brake on the development of 
the productive forces. National capitalism cannot be 
conceived of, let alone reconstructed, except as a part of 
world economy. 

The economic peculiarities of different countries are in 
no way of a subordinate character : It is enough to compare 
England and India, the United States and Brazil. But the 
specific features of national economy, no matter how great, 
enter as component parts, and in increasing measure into 
the higher reality, which is called world economy, and on 
which alone, in the final analysis, the internationalism of 
the Communist parties rests. 

Stalin's characterization of the national peculiarities as 
a simple "supplement" to the general type, is in crying and 
yet not accidental contradiction to Stalin's understanding 
(that is, his lack of understanding) of the law of the uneven 
development of capitalism. This law, as is known, is pro- 
claimed by Stalin as the most fundamental, most important 
and universal. With the help of the law of uneven 
development, which he has converted into an abstraction, 
Stalin attempts to solve all the riddles of existence. But 
it is astounding : He does not notice that national peculiarity 
is the most general product of unevenness of historical 
development, its final result, so to say. It is only necessary 
to understand this unevenness correctly, to consider it to 
its full extent, and also to extend it to the pre-capitalist 
past. A faster or slower development of productive forces ; 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

the expanded, or on the contrary, the contracted character 
of whole historical epochs for example, of the middle 
ages, the guild system, enlightened absolutism, parlia- 
mentarism; the uneven development of the different 
branches of economy, different classes, different social 
institutions, different fields of culture all these lie at the 
base of these national "peculiarities". Originality of a 
national social type is the crystallization of the unevenness 
of its formation. The October revolution is the grandest 
manifestation of the unevenness of the historic process. 
The theory of the permanent revolution, which gave the 
prognosis of the October overthrow, supported itself, by 
that alone, on the law of uneven historical development, 
not in its abstract form, but in the material crystallization 
of the social and political peculiarity of Russia. 

Stalin resorted to the law of uneven development not in 
order to foresee in time the seizure of power by the 
proletariat of a backward country, but in order, after the 
fact, in 1924, to foist upon the already victorious proletariat 
the task of constructing a national socialist society. But 
it is precisely here that the law of uneven development has 
nothing to do with the matter, for it does not replace nor 
does it abolish the laws of world economy ; on the contrary, 
it is subordinated to them. 

By making a fetish of the law of uneven development, 
Stalin proclaims it a sufficient basis for national socialism, 
not as a type, common to all countries, but exceptional, 
Messianic, purely Russian. To construct an independent 
socialist society is possible, according to Stalin, only in 
Russia. By this alone he raises the national peculiarities 
of Russia not only above the "general features" of every 
capitalist nation, but also above world economy as a whole. 
This is just where the fatal flaw begins in the whole Stalin 
conception. The peculiarity of the 17. S. S. R. is so im- 
mense that it makes possible the construction of its own 
socialism within its limits, regardless of what happens with 
the rest of humanity. As for other countries to which the 

6 



PREFACE 

Messianic seal has not been affixed, their peculiarities are 
only "supplementary" to the general features, only a wart 
on the face. "It would be wrong", Stalin teaches, "to 
base the activities of the Communist parties on these 
specific features." This moral holds good for the American 
Communist Party, the British, South African and Serbian, 
but . . . not for the Russian, whose activity is based not on 
the "general features" but precisely on the "peculiarities". 
From this flows the thoroughly discordant strategy of the 
Comintern : while the U. S. S. R. "liquidates the classes" 
and builds national socialism, the proletariat of all the 
other countries, completely independent of actual national 
conditions, is obligated to uniform action according to the 
calendar (August 1, March 6, etc.). Messianic nationalism 
is complemented by bureaucratically abstract interna- 
tionalism. This discordance runs through the whole 
program of the Comintern, and deprives it of any principled 
significance. 

If we take England and India as the opposite poles of 
capitalist types, we must state that the internationalism of 
the British and Indian proletariat does not at all rest on 
the similarity of conditions, tasks and methods, but on 
their inseparable interdependence. The successes of the 
liberation movement in India presuppose a revolutionary 
movement in England, and the other way around. Neither 
in India, nor in England is it possible to construct an 
independent socialist society. Both of them will have to 
enter as parts into a higher entity. In this and only in 
this rests the unshakable foundation of Marxian inter- 
nationalism. 

Only recently, on March 8, 1930, Pravda expounded 
Stalin's unhappy theory anew, in the sense that "socialism, 
as a social-economic formation", that is, as a definite form 
of productive relations, can be absolutely realized "on the 
national scale of the U. S. S. R.". "The complete victory 
of socialism in the sense of a guarantee against the inter- 
vention of capitalist encirclement", is quite another 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

matter such a complete victory of socialism "actually 
demands the triumph of the proletarian revolution in several 
advanced countries". What abysmal decline of theoretical 
thought was required for such sorry scholasticism to be 
expounded in a learned guise on the pages of the central 
organ of Lenin's party ! If we should assume for a minute 
the possibility of realizing socialism as a finished social 
system in the isolated framework of the U. S. S. R., then 
what would be the "complete victory" what intervention 
could even be talked of then ? The socialist order of society 
presupposes high levels of technique, culture and solidarity 
of the population. Since the U. S. S. R., at the moment of 
complete construction of socialism, will have, it must be 
assumed, a population of from 200,000,000 to 250,000,000, 
then we ask : What intervention could be talked of then ? 
What capitalist country, or coalition of countries would 
dare think of intervention under these circumstances ? The 
only conceivable intervention could be on the part of the 
U. S. S. R. But would it be needed? Hardly. The 
example of a backward country, which, in the course of 
several "five year plans" constructed a mighty socialist 
society with its own forces would mean a death blow to 
world capitalism, and would reduce to a minimum, if not 
to zero, the costs of*the world proletarian revolution. This 
is why the whole Stalinist conception actually leads to the 
liquidation of the Communist International. And really, 
what could its historical significance be, if the fate of 
socialism is to be decided in the last resort ... by the 
Gosplan (State Planning Commission) of the U. S. S. R. ? 
In such a case, the task of the Comintern, along with the 
illustrious "Friends of the Soviet Union", would be to 
protect the construction of socialism from intervention, 
that is, in essence, to* play the r&le of a frontier guard. 

The article already mentioned above attempts to streng- 
then the correctness of the Stalinist conception with the very 
newest economic arguments : "... precisely now," 
Pravda says, "when productive relations on a socialist 



PREFACE 

basis take deeder root not only in industry but also in agri- 
culture, through the growth of the Soviet farms, through 
the gigantic rise in quantity and quality of the collective 
farms movement and the liquidation of the kulak as a class 
pn the basis of complete collectivization, it shows more 
clearly the sorry bankruptcy of Trotskv^Zinoviev defeatism, 
which has meant in essence 4 the Menshevik denial of the 
legitimacy of the October revolution' Stalin.' 5 (Pravda, 
March 8, 1930.) 

These lines are really remarkable, and not merely for 
their glib tone which covers the complete confusion of 
thought. Together with Stalin, the author of the Pravda 
article accuses the "Trotskyist" conception of "denying 
the legitimacy of the October revolution". But it was 
precisely on the basis of this conception, that is, of theory 
of the permanent revolution, that the writer of these lines 
foretold the inevitability of the October revolution, thirteen 
years before it took place. And Stalin? Even after the 
February revolution, that is, from seven to eight months 
prior to the October overthrow, he came forward as a 
vulgar revolutionary democrat. It was necessary for Lenin 
to arrive in Petrograd (April 8, 1917) with his merciless 
struggle and ridicule of the conceited "old Bolsheviks" 
for Stalin carefully and unostentatiously to glide over from 
the democratic to the socialist position. This inner 
"regrowth" of Stalin, which by the way was never com- 
pleted, took place, at any rate, not earlier than twelve 
years after the "legitimacy" of the seizure of power by the 
working class of Russia, before the beginning of the 
proletarian revolution in the West had been indicated. 

But, in elaborating the theoretical prognosis of the 
October revolution, we did not at all believe that, by con- 
quering state power, the Russian proletariat would exclude 
the former czarist empire from the sphere of world economy. 
We Marxists know the role and significance of state power. 
It is not at all a passive reflection of economic processes, 
as the social democratic servants of the bourgeois state 

9 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

fatalistically describe it. Power can have a gigantic 
significance, reactionary, as well as progressive, depending 
upon which class holds it in his hands. But the state power 
is nevertheless a weapon of superstructural order. The 
passing of power from the hands of czarism and the 
bourgeoisie into the hands of the proletariat, abolishes 
neither the processes, nor the laws of world economy. It 
is true that for a certain time after the October revolution, 
the economic ties between the Soviet Union and the world 
market were weakened. But it would be a monstrous 
mistake to generalize a phenomenon which was merely a 
short stage in the dialectical process. The international 
division of labor and the supra-national character of modern 
productive forces, not only retain, but will increase twofold 
and tenfold their significance for the Soviet Union, depend- 
ing upon the degree of its economic ascent. 

Every backward country that has become a part of 
capitalism has gone through various stages of decreasing or 
increasing dependence upon the other capitalist countries, 
but in general the tendency of capitalist development leads 
towards a colossal growth of world ties, which is expressed 
in the growth of foreign trade, including, of course, capital 
export as well. The dependence of England upon India 
naturally bears a qualitatively different character than the 
dependence of India upon England. But this difference is 
basically determined by the difference in the degree of 
development of their productive forces and not at all by 
the degree of their economic self-sufficiency. India is a 
colony, England a metropolis. But if England were sub- 
jected today to an economic blockade, it would perish 
sooner than India. This, by the way, is one of the most 
convincing illustrations of the reality of world economy. 

Capitalist development not in the abstract formulae of 
the second volume of Capital, which retain all their 
significance as a stage in analysis, but in historic reality 
took place and could only take place by the systematic 
expansion of its base. In the process of its development, 

10 



PREFACE 

and consequently in the struggle with its internal contra- 
dictions, every national capitalism turns in ever increasing 
measure to the reserves of the "external market", that is, 
of world economy. The uncontrollable expansion growing 
out of the permanent internal crisis of capitalism, constitutes 
its progressive force until it becomes fatal. 

The October revolution inherited from old Russia, besides 
the internal contradictions of capitalism, no less profound 
contradictions between capitalism as a whole and the 
pre-capitalist forms of production. These contradictions 
had and still have, a material character, that is, they are 
contained in the material relations between the city and 
country in definite proportions or disproportions of various 
branches of industry and national economy in general, etc. 
Some of the roots of these contradictions lie directly in the 
geographic and demographic conditions of the country, that 
is, they are nurtured by the surplus or the shortage of one 
or the other natural resource, and the historically created 
distribution of the masses of the people, etc. The strength 
of Soviet economy lies in the nationalization of the means 
of production and in their planned direction. The weakness 
of Soviet economy, on the other hand, besides the back- 
wardness inherited from the past, lies in its present post- 
revolutionary isolation, that is, in its inability to gain 
access to the resources of world economy, not only on a 
socialist but even on a capitalist basis, that is, in the form 
of normal international credits, and "financing" in general, 
which plays such a decisive r&le for backward countries. 
However, the contradictions of its capitalist and pre- 
capitalist past not only do not disappear of themselves, but 
on the contrary, rise out of the twilight of the years of 
decline and destruction, revive and are accentuated 
simultaneously with the growth of Soviet economy, and in 
order to be overcome or even mitigated, demand at every 
step contact with the resources of the world market. 

To understand what is happening now in the vast 
territory which the October revolution awakened to new 

11 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

life, we must always clearly picture to ourselves that to 
the old contradictions recently revived by the economic 
successes, there has been added a new and enormous con- 
tradiction between the concentrated character of Soviet 
industry, which opens up the possibility of an unprecedented 
tempo of development, and the isolation of Soviet economy, 
which excludes the possibility of a normal utilization of 
the reserves of world economy. The new contradiction, 
bearing down upon the old ones, leads to the fact that 
alongside of the exceptional successes, painful difficulties 
arise. The latter find their most immediate and strongest 
expression, felt daily by every worker and peasant, in the 
fact that the conditions of the toiling masses do not keep 
step with the general rise of economy, but even grow worse 
at present as a result of the food difficulties. The sharp 
crises of Soviet economy are a reminder that the productive 
forces created by capitalism are not adapted to a national 
framework and can be socialistically coordinated and 
harmonized only on an international scale. In other words, 
the crises of Soviet economy are not merely the maladies 
of growth, a sort of infantile sickness, but something im- 
measurably more significant precisely that severe. check of 
the world market, the very one "to which," in Lenin's 
words, "we are subordinated, with which we are bound up, 
and from which we cannot escape" (at the Eleventh Con- 
gress of the party, March 27, 1922). 

From this, however, there in no way follows the denial 
of the historical "legitimacy" of the October revolution, 
a conclusion which smells of shameful philistinism. The 
seizure of power by the international proletariat cannot 
be a single, simultaneous act. The political superstructure 
and a revolution is part of "superstructure" has its own 
dialectic, which peremptorily interrupts the process of world 
economy, but does not abolish its deep-seated laws. The 
October revolution is "legitimate" as the first stage in the 
world revolution, which inevitably extends over decades. 
The interval between the first and the second stage has 

12 



PREFACE 

turned out to be considerably longer than we had expected. 
Nevertheless, it remains an interval, without being con- 
verted into an epoch of the self-sufficient construction of a 
national socialist society. 

Out of the two conceptions of the revolution have come 
two principal lines on economic questions. The first rapid 
economic successes, which were completely unexpected by 
him, inspired Stalin in the fall of 1924 with the theory of 
socialism in one country as the culmination of a practical 
perspective for an isolated national economy. It was 
precisely in this period that Bucharin advanced his famous 
formula that in fencing ourselves off from world economy 
by the monopoly of foreign trade, we would be in a position 
to build up socialism "even at a snail's pace". This was 
the common formula of the bloc of the Centrists (Stalin) 
with the Rights (Bucharin). Already at that time, Stalin 
tirelessly propounded the idea that the tempo of our 
industrialization is our "own affair", having no relation to 
world economy. Such a national self-contentment, how- 
ever, could not last long, for it reflected the first, very 
brief stage of economic revival, which inevitably revived 
our dependence upon the world market. The first shocks 
of intra-state dependence, unexpected by the national 
socialists, created an alarm, which in the next stage turned 
into panic. To gain economic "independence" speedily 
with the aid of the fastest possible tempos of industrializa- 
tion and collectivization ! this is the transformation that 
has taken place in the economic policy of national socialism 
in the past two years. Crawling was replaced all along the 
Ijine by adventurism. The theoretical base under both is 
the same : a national socialist conception. 

The basic difficulties, as was shown above, result from 
the objective situation, primarily from the isolation of the 
Soviet Union. We shall not stop here to consider to what 
degree this objective situation is itself a result of the 
subjective mistakes of the leadership (the false policy in 
Germany in 1928, in Bulgaria and Esthonia in 1924, in 

18 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

England and Poland in 1926, in China in 1925-1927; the 
present false strategy of the "third period", etc., etc.)- 
But the sharpest convulsions in the U. S. S. R. are created 
by the fact that the present leadership tries to make a 
virtue out of a necessity, and out of the political isolation 
of the wokers' state, constructs a program of an economi- 
cally isolated socialist society. From this has resulted the 
attempt at complete socialist collectivization of peasant 
holdings on the basis of the pre-capitalist inventory a 
most dangerous adventure which threatens to undermine 
the very possibility of collaboration between the proletariat 
and the peasantry. 

And it is remarkable : just at the moment when this 
began to appear in all its sharpness, Bucharin, yesterday's 
theoretician of the "snail's pace" composed a pathetic 
hymn to the present "mad gallop" of industrialization and 
collectivization. It is to be feared that this hymn will 
soon be declared the greatest heresy. For there are al- 
ready new melodies in the air. Under the influence of the 
resistance of economic reality, Stalin has been compelled 
to beat a retreat. Now the danger is that the adventur- 
ous offensive dictated by the panic of yesterday will turn 
into a panic-stricken retreat. Such an alternation of 
stages results inevitably from the nature of national 
socialism. 

A realistic program of an isolated workers' state cannot 
set itself the aim of achieving "independence" from world 
economy, much less of constructing a national socialist 
society in the "shortest time". The task is not to accom- 
plish the abstract maximum, but the most favourable 
tempo under the circumstances, that is, those that 
flow from internal and world economic conditions, 
strengthen the positions of the proletariat, pre- 
pare the national elements of the future international 
socialist society, and at the same time, and above all, 
systematically improve the living level of the proletariat, 
strengthening its union with the non-exploiting masses of 

14 



PREFACE 

the village. This perspective remains in force for the whole 
preparatory period, that is, until the victorious revolution 
in the advanced countries liberates the Soviet Union out of 
its present isolated position. 

Some of the thoughts expressed here are developed in 
greater detail in other works of the author, particularly in 
the Draft Program of the Comintern : A Criticism of Funda- 
mentals. The considerations brought out above are suffi- 
cient, let us hope, to reveal the whole significance of the 
struggle of principles that was carried on in recent years, 
and is carried on now in the form of contrasting two 
theories : socialism in one country and the permanent re- 
volution* Only this timely significance of the question 
justifies the fact that we present here to foreign readers a 
book which is largely devoted to a critical re-establish- 
ment of the pre-revolutionary prognoses and theoretical 
disputes among the Russian Marxists. We could, of 
course, have selected a different form of expounding the 
questions that interest us. But this form was never creat- 
ed by the author, and was not selected by him of his own 
accord. It was imposed upon him partly by opponents 
and partly by the very course of political development. 
Even the truths of mathematics, the most abstract of the 
sciences, can best of all be learned in connection with the 
history of their discovery. This applies even more to the 
more concrete, that is, to the historically conditioned 
truths of Marxist policy. The history of the origin and 
development of the prognoses of the revolution in the con- 
ditions of pre-revolutionary Russia will, we think, bring 
the reader much closer and far more concretely to the- 
essence of the revolutionary tasks of the world proletariat 
than a sophomoric and pedantic exposition of these poli- 
tical ideas, torn out of the conditions of struggle which 
gave birth to them. 

March 29, 1930 L. Trotskjr 

15 



INTRODUCTION 



THE PRESENT book is dedicated to the question which is 
intimately linked with the history of the three Russian 
revolutions. But not with that alone. This question has 
, played an enormous role in recent years in the internal' 
struggle of the C.P.S.U., it was carried into the C.L., 
played a decisive role in the development of the Chinese 
revolution and determined a whole series of most impor- 
tant decisions which are bound up with the revolutionary 
struggle of the countries of the East. It concerns the theory 
of the "permanent revolution" which, after the teaching of 
the epigones of Leninism (Zinoviev, Stalin, Bucharin, etc.) 
represents the original sin of "Trotskyism". 

The question of the permanent revolution was once more 
raised in 1924 after a long interval, apparently quite un- 
expectedly. Political . grounds for it, there were none : 
for it was a question of differences of opinion which long 
ago belonged to the past. Psychological grounds, on the 
contrary, there were many. The group of so-called "old 
Bolsheviks" which had opened up the fight against me first 
of all counterposed this title to me. But a great obstacle 
in the path of this group was the year 1917. Important as 
had been the preceding history of ideological struggle and 
of preparation with regard to the party as a whole, as well 
as with regard to single individuals, this period found its 
highest and irrevocable test in the October revolution. 

16 



INTRODUCTION 

Not a single one of the epigones stood up under this test. 
Without exception, they all adopted the vulgar position ol 
the democratic Left wingers at the time of the February 
1917 revolution. Not a single one of them raised the 
slogan of the struggle of the proletariat for power. They 
all regarded the course towards a socialist revolution as 
absurd or still worse as "Trotskyism". In this spirit 
they directed the party up till the arrival of Lenin from 
abroad and up till the appearance of his famous theses of 
April 4. Thereafter Kamenev endeavoured, already in 
direct struggle against Lenin, openly to form a democratic 
wing of Bolshevism. Later, he was joined by Zinoviev, 
who had arrived with Lenin. Stalin, heavily compromised 
by his social patriotic position, stepped aside. He let the 
party forget his miserable articles and speeches of the deci- 
sive March weeks and gradually edged over to Lenin's 
standpoint. That is why the question rose by itself, so to 
speak : What did Leninism give to any one of these lead- 
ing "old Bolshevik^" when not a single one of them show- 
ed himself capable of applying independently the theoreti- 
cal and practical experiences of the party at the most im- 
portant and most responsible historical moment ? Atten- 
tion had to be diverted from this question at all costs and 
another question substituted for it. To this end, it was 
decided to open fire on the permanent revolution. My 
adversaries did not, of course, foresee that by the creation 
of an artificial axis of struggle they would be compelled, 
without noticing it, to revolve around it themselves and 
manufacture a new world outlook for themselves. 

In its essential features, the theory of the permanent 
revolution was formulated by me even before the decisive 
events of 1905. Russia was approaching the bourgeois re- 
volution. Nobody in the ranks of the Russian social 
democracy (we all called ourselves social democrats then) 
had any doubts that we were approaching a bourgeois re- 
volution, that is, a revolution produced by the contradic- 
tions between the development of the productive forces of 

17 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

capitalist society and the outlived caste and state relation- 
ships of the period of serfdom and the Middle Ages. In 
the struggle against the Narodniki and the anarchists, I 
had to devote not a few speeches and articles in those 
days to the Marxian analysis of the bourgeois character of 
the impending revolution. 

The bourgeois character of the revolution could not, 
however, answer in advance the question as to which 
classes would solve the tasks of the democratic revolution 
and what the mutual relations of these classes would be. 
It was precisely at this point that the fundamental 
strategical problems began. 

Plechanov, Axelrod, Zasulitch, Martov, and following 
them, all the Russian Mensheviks, took as their premise 
that to the liberal bourgeoisie, as the natural claimant for 
power, belonged the leading role in the bourgeois revolu- 
tion. According to this schema, there was assigned to the 
party of the proletariat the role of the Left wing of the 
democratic front. The social democracy was to support 
the liberal bourgeoisie against the reaction and at the same 
time to defend the interests of the proletariat against the 
liberal bourgeoisie. In other words, the Mensheviks under- 
stood the bourgeois revolution principally as a liberal-con- 
stitutional form. 

Lenin posed the question differently. The liberation of 
the productive forces of bourgeois society from the fetters 
of serfdom signified for Lenin primarily a radical solution 
of the agrarian question in the sense of the complete liqui- 
dation of the landowning class and the revolutionary re- 
distribution of land ownership. Inseparably connected 
with this, was the destruction of the monarchy. Lenin 
set to work on the agrarian problem, which affected the 
life interests of the overwhelming majority of the popula- 
tion and at the same time constituted the basic problem of 
the capitalist market, with a truly revolutionary boldness. 
Since the liberal bourgeoisie, which confronts the workers 
as an enemy, is intimately bound by innumerable ties to 

18 



INTRODUCTION 

large land ownership, the genuine democratic liberation of 
the peasantry can only be realized by the revolutionary co- 
operation of the workers and peasants. Their joint up- 
rising against the old society, must, according to Lenin, 
in case of victory, lead to the establishment of the "demo- 
cratic dictatorship of the proletariat and peasantry". 

This formula is now repeated in the Communist Inter- 
national as a sort of supra-historical dogma, without the 
attempt at an analysis of the living historical experiences 
of the last quarter of a century, as though we had not been 
witnesses and participants in the revolution of 1905, the 
February revolution of 1917, and finally, of the October 
overturn. Such an historical analysis, however, is all the 
more necessary because there never has been in history a 
regime of the "democratic dictatorship of the proletariat 
and peasantry". 

In 1905, it was a question with Lenin of a strategical 
hypothesis which required a test in the reality of the class 
struggle. The formula of the democratic dictatorship of 
the proletariat and peasantry in large measure bore an 
intentionally algebraic 2 character. Lenin did not answer 
in advance the question of what the political relations 
would be between the two participants ^n the proposed 
democratic dictatorship, that is, of the proletariat and the 
peasantry. He did not exclude the possibility that the 
peasantry would be represented in the revolution by an in- 
dependent party, independent in the double sense : that is, 
not only with regard to the bourgeoisie but also with 
regard to the proletariat, and at the same time, capable of 
realizing the democratic revolution in alliance with the 
party of the proletariat in struggle against the liberal bour- 
geoisie. Lenin even reckoned, as we shall soon see, with 
the possibility that the revolutionary peasants' party 
might constitute the majority in the government of the 
democratic dictatorship. 

In the question of the decisive significance of the agra- 
rian Devolution for the fate of our bourgeois revolution, I 

19 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

was, at least since the autumn of 1902, that is, from the 
moment of my first flight abroad, a pupil of Lenin. That 
the agrarian revolution, and consequently also the general 
democratic revolution, could be realized only by the united 
forces of the workers and peasants in struggle against the 
liberal bourgeoisie, was for me, contrary to all the sense- 
less fairy tales of recent years, beyond any doubt. Yet I 
came out against the formula : "democratic dictatorship 
of the proletariat and peasantry", because I saw its short- 
coming in the fact that it left open the question of what 
class the real dictatorship would belong to. 

I endeavored to show that in spite of its enormous social 
and revolutionary weightiness, the peasantry was incapable 
of creating a really independent party and still more in- 
capable of concentrating the revolutionary power in its 
hands. Just as the peasantry in the old revolutions since 
the German Reformation of the 16th century, and even 
before that, supported one of the fractions of the city 
bourgeois by its uprisings, and not infrequently insured its 
victory, so it could show a similar support in our belated 
bourgeois revolution at the highest swing of the struggle of 
the proletariat, and help it seize power. From this I drew 
the conclusion th^t our bourgeois revolution could solve its 
task radically only in the event that the proletariat, with 
the aid of the many-millioned peasantry, were capable of 
concentrating the revolutionary dictatorship in its hands. 

What would be the social content of this dictatorship ? 
First of all, it would have to carry out thoroughly the agra- 
rian revolution and the democratic transformation of the 
state. In other words, the dictatorship of the proletariat 
would be a means of solving the tasks of the historically 
belated bourgeois revolution. But the matter could not 
be confined to this. Having reached power, the proleta- 
riat would be compelled to encroach ever more deeply upon 
the relationships of private property in general, that is, to 
take the road of socialist measures. 

"Do you perhaps believe", the Stalins, Rykovs and all 

20 



INTRODUCTION 

the other Molotovs rejoined dozens of times from 1905 to 
1917, "that Russia is ripe for the socialist revolution ?" 
To that I always answered : No, I do not. But world 
economy as a whole, and European economy in the first, 
place, ip completely ripe for the socialist revolution. 
Whether the dictatorship of the proletariat in Russia leads 
to socialism or not, and at what rate and over what stages, 
will depend upon the further fate of European and inter- 
national capitalism. 

These were the essential features of the theory of the 
permanent revolution at its origin in the early months of 
1905. Since then, three revolutions have taken place. 
The Russian proletariat ascended to power on the mighty 
wave of the peasant insurrection. The dictatorship of the 
proletariat became a fact in Russia earlier than in any 
other of the immeasurably more developed countries of the 
world. In 1924, that is, seven years aftei* the historical 
prognosis of the theory of the permanent revolution was 
confirmed with rare forces, the epigones opened up a wild 
attack against this theory, and plucked isolated sentences 
and polemical rejoinders out of my old works, which I had 
since completely forgotten. 

It is appropriate to call to mind here that the first 
Russian revolution broke out more than half a century 
after the wave of bourgeois revolutions in Europe and 
thirty-five years after the episodic uprising of the Paris 
Commune. Europe had had time to disaccustom itself 
from revolutions. Russia had not experienced any. All 
the problems of the revolution had to be posed anew. It 
is not difficult to conceive how many unknown and puta- 
tive quantities the future revolution held up for us in those 
days. The slogans of all the groupings were to a, certain 
extent based upon hypotheses. A complete incapacity for 
historical prognoses and utter lack of understanding of 
their methods is required in order now, after the event, to 
consider analyses and evaluations of 1905 as though they 
were written yesterday. I have often said to myself and 

21 



PEBMANENT REVOLUTION 

to my friends : I do not doubt that my prognoses of 1905 
contained many defects which are not hard to disclose now, 
after the event. But did my critics see better and fur- 
ther ? I had considered the defects in my old works, 
which I had not perused for a long time, more serious and 
important than they really are. I convinced myself of 
that in 1928, when the political leisure imposed upon me 
in the banishment at Alma-Ata, afforded me the possibility 
to scrutinize with pencil in hand the old works on the per- 
manent revolution. I hope that the reader too will be 
thoroughly convinced of this by what follows. 

It is nevertheless necessary, within the limits of this in- 
troduction, to present as exact as possible, a characteriza- 
tion of the elements of the theory of the permanent revolu- 
tion and of the most important objections to it. The 
differences of opinion have become so broadened and 
deepened that they now actually embrace all the most im- 
portant questions of the revolutionary world movement. 

The permanent revolution, in the sense which Marx 
attached to the conception, means a revolution which 
makes no compromise with any form of class rule, which 
does not stop at the democratic stage, which goes over to 
socialist measures and to war against the reaction from 
without, that is, a revolution whose every next stage is 
anchored in the preceding one and Which can only end in 
the complete liquidation of all class society. 

To dispel the chaos that has been created around the 
theory of the permanent revolution, it is necessary to dis- 
tinguish three lines of thought that are united in this 
theory. 

First, it embraces the problem of the transition of the 
democratic revolution into the socialist. This is really the 
historical origin of the theory. 

The conception of the permanent revolution was set up 
by the great Communists of the middle of the 19th 
century, by Marx and his adherents, in opposition to that 
democratic ideology which, as is known, presumed that all 

22 



INTRODUCTION 

questions should be settled peacefully, in a reformist or 
evolutionary way, by the erection of the "rational" or 
democratic state. Marx regarded the bourgeois revolution 
of ? 48 as the direct introduction to the proletarian revolu- 
tion. Marx "erred". Yet his error has a factual and not 
a methodological character. The revolution of 1848 did 
not turn into the socialist revolution. But that is just 
why it also did not achieve democracy. As to the German 
revolution of 1918, it is no democratic completion of the 
bourgeois revolution : it is a proletarian revolution de- 
capitated by the social democracy ; more correctly, it is 
the bourgeois counter-revolution^ which is compelled to 
preserve pseudo-democratic forms after the victory over 
the proletariat. 

Vulgar "Marxism" has worked out a schema of historical 
development, according to which every bourgeois society 
sooner or later secures a democratic regime, and after which 
it gradually organizes and raises the proletariat, under the 
conditions of democracy, to socialism. As to the transition 
to socialism itself, there have been various notions : the 
avowed reformists imagined this transition as the reformist 
cramming of democracy with a socialist content (Jaures). 
The formal revolutionists acknowledged the inevitability of 
applying revolutionary violence in the transition to socialism 
(Guesde). But both of them regarded democracy and 
socialism with regard to all peoples and countries as two 
not only entirely separated stages in the development of 
society, but also lying at great distances from each other. 
This view was predominant also among those Russian Marx- 
ists who, in the period of 1905, belonged to the Left wing of 
the Second International. Plechanov, the brilliant pro- 
genitor of Russian Marxism, considered the idea of the dic- 
tatorship of the proletariat a delusion in contemporary 
Russia. The same standpoint was defended not only by the 
Mensheviks, but also by the overwhelming majority of the 
leading Bolsheviks, among them all the present party leaders 
without exception, who at that time were resolute revolu- 

28 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

tionary democrats, for whom the problem of the socialist 
revolution, not only in 1905 but also on the eve of 1917, still 
signified the vague music of a distant future. 

These ideas and moods declared war upon the theory of 
the permanent revolution, risen anew in 1905. It pointed 
out that the democratic tasks of the backward bourgeois 
nations in our epoch led to the dictatorship of the proleta- 
riat and that the dictatorship of the proletariat puts the 
socialist tasks on the order of the day. In that lay the 
central idea of the theory. If the traditional view was that 
the road to the dictatorship of the proletariat led through a 
long period of democracy, the theory of the permanent revo- 
lution established the fact that for backward countries the 
road to democracy passed through the dictatorship of the 
proletariat. By that alone, democracy does not become a 
regime anchored within itself for decades, but rather a 
direct introduction to the socialist revolution. Each is 
bound to the other by an unbroken chain. In this way, 
there arises between the democratic revolution and the 
socialist transformation of society a permanency of revolu- 
tionary development. 

The second aspect of the "permanent" theory already 
characterizes the socialist revolution as such. For an in- 
definitely long time and in constant internal struggle, all 
social relations are transformed. The process necessarily 
retains a political character, that is, it develops through 
collisions of various groups of society in transformation. 
Outbreaks of civil war and foreign wars alternate with 
periods of "peaceful" reforms. Revolutions in economy, 
technique, science, the family, morals and usages develop 
in complicated reciprocal action and do not allow society 
to reach equilibrium. Therein lies the permanent charac- 
ter of the socialist revolution as such. 

The international character of the socialist revolution, 
which constitutes the third aspect of the theory of the per- 
manent revolution, results from the present state of economy 
and the social structure of humanity. Internationalism is 

24 



INTRODUCTION 

no abstract principle, but a theoretical and political 
reflection of the character of world economy, of the world 
development of productive forces, and the world scale of 
the class struggle. The socialist revolution begins on 
national grounds. But it cannot be completed on these 
grounds. The maintenance of the proletarian revolution 
within a national framework can only be a provisional state 
of affairs, even though, as the experience of the Soviet Union 
shows, one of long duration. In an isolated proletarian 
dictatorship, the internal and external contradictions grow 
inevitably together with the growing successes. Remaining 
isolated, the proletarian state must finally become a victim 
of these contradictions. The way out for it lies only in 
the victory of the proletariat of the advanced countries. 
Viewed from this standpoint, a national revolution is not 
a self-sufficient whole : it is only a link in the international 
chain. The international revolution presents a permanent 
process, in spite of all. fleeting rises and falls. 

The struggle of the epigones is directed, even if not 
always with the same distinctness, against all three aspects 
of the theory of the permanent revolution. And how could 
it be otherwise when it is a question of three inseparably 
connected parts of a whole. The epigones mechanically 
separate the democratic and the socialist dictatorships. 
They separate the national socialist revolution from the 
international. The conquest of power within national limits 
is considered by them in essence not as the initial act but 
as the final act of the revolution : after that follows the 
period of reforms which leads to the national socialist 
society. In 1905, they did not even grant the idea that 
the proletariat could conquer power in Russia earlier than 
in Western Europe. In 1917, they preached the self- 
sufficing democratic revolution in Russia and spurned the 
dictatorship of the proletariat. In 1925-1927, they steered 
a course towards the national revolution in China under the 
leadership of the bourgeoisie. Subsequently, they raised 
the slogan for China of the democratic dictatorship of the 

25 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

workers and peasants in opposition to the dictatorship of 
the proletariat. They proclaimed the possibility of the 
construction of an isolated and self-sufficient socialist society 
in the Soviet Union. The world revolution became for 
them, instead of an indispensable pre-condition for victory, 
only a favourable circumstance. This profound breach 
with Marxism was reached by the epigones in the process 
of the permanent struggle against the theory of the perma- 
nent revolution. 

The struggle, which began with an artificial revival of 
historical reminiscences and the falsification of the distant 
past, led to the complete transformation of the world 
outlook of the ruling stratum of the revolution. We have 
already repeatedly set forth that this transvaluation of 
values was accomplished under the influence of the social 
requirements of the Soviet bureaucracy, which became ever 
more conservative, strove for national order, and demanded 
that the already achieved revolution, .which insured the 
privileged positions to the bureaucracy, now be considered 
adequate for the peaceful construction of socialism. We do 
not wish to return to this theme here. Let it simply be 
observed that the bureaucracy is deeply conscious of the 
connection of its material and ideological positions with the 
theory of national socialism. This is being expressed most 
crassly right now, in spite of or rather because of the fact 
that the Stalinist apparatus, under the pressure of contra- 
dictions which it did not foresee, is driving to the Left with 
all its might and inflicting quite severe blows upon its Right 
wing inspirers of yesterday. The hostility of the bureau- 
crats towards the Marxist Opposition, whose slogans and 
arguments they have borrowed in great haste, does not, as 
is known, diminish in the least. The condemnation of the 
theory of the permanent revolution above all, and an 
acknowledgment, even if only indirect, of the theory of 
socialism in one country, is demanded of the Oppositionists 
who raise the question of their re-admission into the party 
for the purpose of supporting the course towards indus- 

26 



INTRODUCTION 

totalization, and so forth. By this, the Stalinist bureau- 
cracy reveals the purely tactical character of its swing to 
the Left with the retention of the national reformist 
strategical foundations. It is superfluous to explain what 
this means ; in politics as in the military affairs, tactics are 
subordinated in the long run, to strategy. 

The question has long ago grown out of the specific 
sphere of the struggle against "Trotskyism". Gradually 
extending itself, it has today literally embraced all the 
problems of the revolutionary world outlook. Permanent 
revolution or socialism in one country this alternative 
embraces at the same time the internal problems of the 
Soviet Union, the perspectives of the revolution in the East, 
and finally, the fate of the whole Communist International. 

The present work does not examine this question from 
all sides : It is not necessary to repeat what has already 
been said in other works. In the Criticism of the Program 
of the Communist International, I have endeavored to 
disclose theoretically the economic and political untenability 
of national socialism. The theoreticians of the Comintern 
were as silent about it as though their mouths were filled 
with water. That is perhaps the only thing left for them 
to do. In this booklet, I above all restore the theory of 
the permanent revolution as it was formulated in 1905 with 
regard to the internal problems of the Russian revolution. 
I show wherein my position actually differed from Lenin's, 
and how and why it coincided with Lenin's position in 
every^ decisive situation. Finally, I endeavor to reveal 
the decisive significance of the question that interests us 
here for the proletariat of the backward countries, and 
thereby, for the Communist International as a whole. 



What accusations have been raised against the theory 
of the permanent revolution by the epigones? Disregard 
the innumerable contradictions of my critics, and their 

27 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

whole, veritably immense, literature can be reproduced in 
the following sentences : 

(i) Trotsky ignored the difference between the bour- 
geois revolution and the socialist; already in 1905 he 
represented the standpoint that the proletariat of Russia 
stands before the tasks of a directly socialist revolution. 

(tt) Trotsky completely forgot the agrarian question. 
The peasantry did not exist for him. He depicted the 
revolution as a duel between the proletariat and czarism. 

(in) Trotsky did not believe that the world bourgeoisie 
would stand for a somewhat lengthy existence of the 
dictatorship of the Russian proletariat and regarded its fall 
as inevitable in the event that the proletariat of the West 
did not seize power within the briefest period and provide 
assistance. By this Trotsky under-evaluated the pressure 
of the Western European proletariat upon its own 
bourgeoisie. 

(iv) Trotsky does not believe altogether in the power 
of the Russian proletariat, nor in its ability to construct 
socialism independently, and that is why he has put and 
still puts all his hopes in the international revolution. 

These motifs run through not only the numberless 
writings and speeches of Zinoviev, Stalin, Bucharin and 
others, but they are also formulated in the most autho- 
ritative resolutions of the Communist Party of the Soviet 
Union and the Communist International. And in spite of 
that, one is compelled to say that they are based upon a 
mixture of ignorance and dishonesty. 

The first two contentions of the critics are, as will be 
shown later on, false to the roots. No, I proceeded precisely 
from the bourgeois-democratic character of the revolution 
and arrived at the conclusion that the .profundity of the 
agrarian crisis can raise to power the proletariat of back- 
ward Russia. Yes, these are just the ideas that I defended 
on the eve of the 1905 revolution. These are just the ideas 
that alone expressed the characterization of the revolution 
as a "permanent" one, that is, an uninterrupted one, that 

28 



INTRODUCTION 

is, a revolution that passes over directly from the bourgeois, 
stage into the socialist. To express the same ideas, Lenin 
later used the excellent expression of the bourgeois revolu- 
tion "growing into" the socialist. The conception of the 
growing into was contrasted by Stalin, after the event 
(in 1924), to the permanent revolution as a direct leap from 
the realm of autocracy into the realm of socialism. The 
unfortunate "theoretician" did not even take the trouble 
to reflect, if it is simply a matter of a leap, what the 
permanency of the revolution means! 

As for the third accusation, it was dictated by the 
short-lived belief of the epigones in the possibility of 
neutralizing the imperialist bourgeoisie for an unlimited 
time with the aid of the "shrewdly" organized pressure of 
the proletariat. In the years 1924-1927 this was the central 
idea of Stalin. The Anglo-Russian Committee then became 
its fruit. The disappointment of the possibility of binding 
the world bourgeoisie hand and foot with the help of 
Purcell, Raditch, La Follette and Chiang Kai-Shek, led to 
an acute paroxysm of fear of an immediate war danger. 
The Comintern is still passing through this period. 

The fourth objection to the theory of the permanent 
revolution simply amounts to saying that I did not defend 
the standpoint of the theory of socialism in one country in 
1905, which Stalin first manufactured in 1924 for the Soviet 
bureaucracy. This accusation should be appreciated only 
as a historical curiosity. One might actually believe that 
my critics in so far as they thought of anything at all in 
1905, were of the opinion then that Russia was prepared 
for an independent socialist revolution. As a matter of 
fact, however, they accused me tirelessly in the period of 
1905 to 1917 of Utopianism, because I counted upon the 
probability that the Russian proletariat could come to 
power before the proletariat of Western Europe. Kamenev 
and Rykov accused Lenin of Utopianism in April 1917, 
using against him the vulgar argument that the socialist 
revolution must first be achieved in England and in the 

29 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

other advanced countries before it could be Russia's turn. 
The same standpoint was defended by Stalin too, up to 
April 4, 1917* Only gradually and with difficulty, did he 
adopt the Leninist formula of the dictatorship of the pro- 
letariat in contradistinction to the democratic dictatorship. 
In the spring of 1924, Stalin was still repeating what the 
others had said before him : isolated, Russia is not mature 
for the construction of a socialist society. In the autumn 
of 1924, Stalin, in his struggle against the theory of the 
permanent revolution, for the first time discovered the 
possibility of building up an isolated socialism in Russia. 
Only then did the Red professors collect quotations for 
Stalin which convict Trotsky of having believed in 1905 
how terrible ! that Russia could reach socialism only with 
the aid of the proletariat of Western Europe. 

Were one to take the history of an ideological struggle 
over a period of a quarter of a century, cut it into little 
pieces, mix them up in a mortar, and then command a 
blind man to paste the pieces together again, a greater 
theoretical and historical absurdity could hardly result than 
the one with which the epigones feed their readers and 
hearers. 



For the connection of yesterday's problems with today's 
to stand out more clearly one must recall here, even if only 
quite generally, what the leadership of the Comintern, that 
is, Stalin and Bucharin, carried out in China. 

Under the pretext that China stands before a national 
revolution, the leading r61e was allotted to the Chinese 
bourgeoisie in 1924. The party of the national bourgeoisie, 
the Kuo Min Tang, was officially recognized as the leading 
party. Not even the Russian Mensheviks went that far in 
1905 in relation to the Cadets (the party of the liberal 
bourgeoisie). 

But the leadership of the Comintern did not stop at 

80 



INTRODUCTION 

this. It obligated the Chinese Communist Party to go into 
the Kuo Min Tang and subordinate itself to its discipline. 
Through special telegrams of Stalin, the Chinese Communists 
were urged to curb the agrarian movement. The mutinous 
workers and peasants were prohibited from forming their 
own Soviets in order not to alienate Chiang Kai-Shek, whom 
Stalin defended against the Oppositionists as a "reliable 
ally" at a party meeting in Moscow at the beginning of 
April 1927, that is, a few days before the counter-revolu- 
tionary coup d'ttat in Shanghai. 

The official subjugation of the Communist party to the 
bourgeois leadership and the official prohibition to form 
Soviets (Stalin and Bucharin taught that the Kuo Min Tang 
"substituted" for Soviets), was a grosser and more crying 
betrayal of Marxism than all the deeds of the Mensheviks 
in the years 1905-1917. 

After Chiang Kai-Shek's coup d'ttat in April 1927, a 
Left wing, under the leadership of Wang Chin Wei split 
off temporarily from the Kuo Min Tang. Wang Chin Wei 
was immediately hailed in Pravda as a reliable ally. In 
essence, Wang Chin Wei bore the same relation to Chiang 
Kai-Shek as Kerensky to Miliukov, with the difference that, 
in China, Miliukov and Kornilov were united in the person 
of Chiang Kai-Shek. 

After April 1927, the Chinese party was ordered to go 
into the "Left" Kuo Min Tang and to subordinate itself to 
the discipline of the Chinese Kerensky instead of preparing 
open warfare against him. The "reliable" Wang Chin Wei 
crushed the Communist party together with the workers' 
and peasants' movement no less criminally than Chiang 
Kai-Shek, whom Stalin had declared as his reliable ally. 

When the Mensheviks supported Miliukov in 1905 and 
afterwards, they nevertheless did not enter the liberal 
party. When the Mensheviks went hand in hand with 
Kerensky in 1917, they still retained their own organization. 
The policy of Stalin in China was a wretched caricature 
even of Menshevism. That is what the first and most 

31 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

important period looked like. 

After its inevitable fruits had appeared : complete 
decline of the workers' and peasants' movements, demoral- 
ization and decay of the Communist party, the leadership 
of the Comintern gave the command: "Left about face!" 
and demanded the immediate armed uprising of the workers 
and peasants. In this way, the young, oppressed and 
mutilated Communist party, which only yesterday was the 
fifth wheel in the wagon of. Chiang Kai-Shek and Wang 
Chin Wei, and consequently did not possess the slightest 
political experience of its own, was handed the order to 
lead the workers and peasants whom the Comintern had 
held back up to yesterday in the name of the Kuo Min 
Tang in an armed insurrection against the same Kuo 
Min Tang, which had in the meanwhile found time to con- 
centrate the 'power and the army in its hands. In the 
course of twenty-four hours a fictitious Soviet was im- 
provised in Canton. The armed insurrection, timed in 
advance for the opening of the Fifteenth Congress of the 
Communist party of the Soviet Union, constituted simul- 
taneously an expression of the heroism of the vanguard of 
the Chinese proletariat as well as of the crime of the 
Comintern. Lesser adventures preceded the Canton uprising 
and followed it. That is what the second chapter of the 
Chinese strategy of the Comintern looked like, a strategy 
that can be characterized as the most malicious caricature 
of Bolshevism. 

The liberal-opportunist, as well as the adventurist 
chapter, delivered a blow to the Chinese Communist Party 
from which, even with a correct policy, it can recover only 
after a long period. 

The Sixth Congress of the Comintern drew the balance 
to this work. It approved it entirely, which is not very 
astonishing : it was for this purpose that it was convoked. 
For the future, the Congress set up the slogan "democratic 
dictatorship of the proletariat and peasantry". By what 
this dictatorship is to be distinguished from the dictatorship 

82 



INTRODUCTION 

qf the Right and Left Kuo Min Tang on the one side, and 
the dictatorship of the proletariat on the other, was not 
explained to the Chinese Communists. Nor is it possible 
to explain it. 

Issuing the slogan of the democratic dictatorship, the 
Sixth Congress at the same time declared the slogans of 
democracy inadmissible (constituent assembly, universal 
suffrage, freedom of press and assembly, etc., etc.), and it 
thereby completely disarmed the Chinese Communist Party 
in the face of the dictatorship of the military oligarchy. 
For a long number of years, the Russian Bolsheviks 
mobilized he workers and peasants around the slogans of 
democracy. The slogans of democracy also played a big 
role in 1917. Only after the already really existing Soviet 
power had arrived at an irreconcilable political antagonism 
to the Constituent Assembly before the eyes of the entire 
people, did our party liquidate the institutions and slogans 
of formal, that is, of bourgeois democracy, in favor of real 
Soviet, that is, of proletarian democracy. 

The Sixth Congress of the Comintern, under the direc- 
tion of Stalin and Bucharin, turned all this on its head. 
While, on the one hand, it prescribed "democratic" and 
not "proletarian" dictatorship for the party, it simul- 
taneously forbade it the democratic slogans for preparing 
this dictatorship. The Chinese Communist Party was not 
only disarmed, but stripped naked. But for that, it was 
finally handed as consolation, in the period of unlimited 
domination of the counter-revolution, the slogan of Soviets, 
which had been prohibited at the time of the revolutionary 
ascent. A very popular hero of a Russian folk tale sings 
wedding songs at funerals and funeral hymns at weddings. 
He gets a sound thrashing in both places. If the thing 
were limited to a sound thrashing for the present leaders 
of the Comintern, one might let it go at that. But the 
stakes are far greater. It is the fate of the proletariat that 
is involved. The tactics of the Comintern was an uncon- 
sciously, but all the more surely, organized sabotage of the 

88 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

Chinese revolution. This sabotage was accomplished 
without any hindrance, for the Right Menshevik policy of 
the Comintern in the years 1924-1927 was clothed in all the 
authority of Bolshevism and protected by the Soviet power 
through the immense machinery of reprisals against the 
criticism of the Left Opposition. 

As a result, we received a perfect example of Stalinist 
strategy, which stood from beginning to end under the 
insignia of the struggle against the permanent revolution. 
It is therefore quite in place for the principal Stalinist 
theoretician of the subordination of the Chinese Communist 
Party to the national bourgeois Kuo Min Tang to have been 
Martinov, that is, the principal Menshevik critic of the 
theory of the permanent revolution from 1905 to 1923, when 
he already began to fulfill his historic mission in the ranks 
of Bolshevism. 



The essentials on the origin of the present work have 
been dealt with in the first chapter. In Alma-Ata, I was 
very calmly preparing a theoretical polemic against the 
epigones. The theory of the permanent revolution was to 
occupy a large place in the book. While at work, I received 
a manuscript of Radek's, which occupied itself with con- 
trasting the permanent revolution with the strategic line of 
Lenin. Radek needed this apparently sudden sortie because 
he was himself submerged up to his ears in Stalin's Chinese 
politics : Radek (together with Zinoviev) preached the 
subordination of the Communist party to the Kuo Min Tang 
not only before Chiang Kai-Shek's coup d'tat but even 
after it. 

In support of the enslavement of the proletariat to the 
bourgeoisie, Radek naturally referred to the necessity of an 
alliance with the peasantry and to the "underestimation" 
of this necessity by me. After Stalin, he too defended the 
Menshevik policy with Bolshevik phraseology. With the 



I NTR ODUCTION 

formula of the democratic dictatorship of the proletariat 
and the peasantry, Radek, following Stalin in this, cloaked 
the diversion of the Chinese proletariat from leading the 
independent struggle for power at the head of the peasant 
masses. When I exposed this ideological masquerade, there 
arose in Radek the urgent need to prove, painted up with 
quotations from Lenin, that my struggle against oppor- 
tunism resulted in reality from the antagonism between the 
theory of the permanent revolution and Leninism. Radek 
converted the lawyer-like defense of his own offense into a 
prosecutor's speech against the permanent revolution. This 
appearance was only a bridge to capitulation for him. I 
might have surmised this with all the more justice since 
Radek, years before, had planned to write a brochure in 
defense of the permanent revolution. Still I did not hasten 
to make a cross over Radek. I undertook the attempt to 
answer his article in all frankness and resolution, without 
cutting off his retreat. I print my reply to Radek just as 
it was written, and confine myself to a few explanatory 
supplements and stylistic corrections. 

Radek's article was not published in the press, and 
I believe it will not be published, for in the form in which 
it was written in 1928 it could not pass the sieve of the 
Stalinist censor. But even for Radek himself this article 
would be downright annihilating today, for it would give a 
glaring picture of Radek's ideological evolution which very 
strongly recalls the "evolution" of a man who throws 
himself out of the sixth storey. 

The origin of this work explains sufficiently why Radek 
probably occupies a larger place in it than it is his right 
to claim. Radek himself did not think up a single argument 
against the theory of the permanent revolution. He only 
came forward as an epigone of the epigones. The reader 
is therefore reconimended to see in Radek not simply Radek 
but the representative of a certain corporation, a not fully 
qualified membership in which he purchased at the price of 
a renunciation of Marxism. Should Radek personally feel, 

85 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

in spite of this, that too many digs have fallen to his share, 
then he should turn them over to the right address at his 
own discretion. That is a private affair of the firm. On 
my part, I raise no objections. 

Prinkipo, November 80, 1930 L. Trotsky 



CHAPTER ONE 



THE ENFORCED CHARACTER 

OF THIS WORK AND 

ITS AIM 



THE THEORETICAL needs of the party led by the 
Right-Centrist bloc were covered for six successive 
years by anti-Trotskyism : the only product present 
in an unlimited amount and available for free distribution. 
Stalin associated himself with a "theory" for the first time 
in 1924, with his immortal articles against the permanent 
revolution. Even Molotov was baptized as a "leader" in 
this basin. The falsification is in full swing. A few days 
ago I happened across an announcement of the publication 
of Lenin's works of 1917 in the German language. This is 
an invaluable gift to the advanced German working class. 
One can, however, just picture from the very outset how 
many falsifications there will be in the text, and especially 
in the annotations. It is enough to point out that the first 
place in the table of contents is assigned to Lenin's letters 
to Kollontai (in New York). Why ? Because these 
letters contain harsh remarks about me, based on com- 
pletely false information of Kollontai, who gave her 
organic Menshevism a hysterical ultra-Left inoculation in 
those days. In the Russian edition, the epigones were 
compelled to indicate, at least ambiguously, that Lenin 
had been falsely informed. It may be assumed without 
further ado that the German edition will not present even 
this evasive reservation. It must still be added that in the 
same letters of Lenin to Kollontai there are furious assaults 

87 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

upon Bucharin, with whom Kollontai was then in solida- 
rity. This part of the letter, at any rate, has been sup- 
pressed for the time being. We will not have to wait very 
long for it. 3 On the other hand, valuable documents, 
articles and speeches of Lenin, as well as minutes, letters, 
and so forth, remain concealed only because they are 
directed against Stalin and Co., and undermine the legend 
of Trotskyism. Of the history of the three Russian re- 
volutions, as well as the history of the party, literally not 
a single shred has been left intact : theory, facts, tradi- 
tions, the heritage of Lenin, all this has been sacrificed to 
the "struggle against Trotskyism", which, since Lenin was 
taken ill, was invented and organized as a personal 
struggle against Trotsky, and developed into struggle 
against Marxism. 

It has again been confirmed that what might appear as 
the most useless raking up of long extinct disputes usually 
satisfies some unconscious social requirement of the day, 
a requirement which, by itself, does not follow the line of 
the old disputes. The campaign against "old Trotskyism" 
was in reality the campaign against the October traditions, 
which are felt as obstructive and unbearable by the new 
bureaucracy. They began to characterize as 
"Trotskyism" everything they wanted to be rid of. Thus 
the struggle against Trotskyism gradually became the 
expression of the theoretical and political reaction in the 
broadest non-proletarian, and partly also in the proleta- 
rian, circles, as well as the expression of this reaction in- 
side the party. An especially caricatured, historically 
falsified contrast of the permanent revolution with Lenin's 
line with regard to the "alliance with the peasants" arose 
in 1928, together with the period of the general reaction as 
well as the internal party reaction, as the consummate 
expression and the most organized renunciation by the 
bureaucrat and the petty bourgeois of the international re- 
volution with its "permanent" convulsions, as the expres- 
sion of the petty bourgeois and bureaucratic propensity for 

88 



ENFORCED CHARACTER OF WORK 

peace and order. The vicious baiting of the permanent 
revolution, in turn, came up only as the preparation of the 
ground for the theory of the revolution in one country, 
that is, for national-socialism of the latest type. It is 
understood that by themselves these new social roots of the 
struggle against "Trotskyism" do not prove anything 
either for or against the correctness of the permanent 
revolution. Yet, without an understanding of these 
hidden roots the struggle must always bear a barren 
academic character. 

I was not in a position to compel myself in recent years 
to put aside the new problems and turn my attention to 
the old questions that are bound up with the period of the 
revolution of 1905, mainly in so far as they concern my 
past and are artificially directed against it. As analysis of 
the old differences of opinion, among others, my old 
mistakes in connection with the situation out of which they 
arose, an analysis so thorough that it becomes comprehen- 
sible to the young generation, not to speak of the old one 
that has fallen into political childhood, is only possible 
within the limits of a more voluminous book. It seemed 
monstrous to me to waste my own and others' time upon 
it, where constantly new tasks of gigantic stature were 
arising : the tasks of the German revolution, the question 
of the future fate of England, the question of the mutual 
relations between America and Europe, the problems made 
acute by the strikes of the British proletariat, the tasks 
of the Chinese revolution and, lastly and mainly, our own 
internal economic and socio-political antagonisms and 
tasks all this, I believe, amply justifies putting aside my 
historico-polemical work on the permanent revolution. 
But the social consciousness tolerates no omissions. In 
recent years, as has been said, this theoretical omission 
was filled up with the rubbish of anti-Trotskyism. The 
epigones, the philosophers and the henchmen of party re- 
action slipped down ever lower, went to school to the dull- 
witted Menshevik, Martinov, trampled Lenin under foot f 

39 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

floundered around in the swamp, and called it all the 
struggle against. Trotskyism. (All these years they have 
been incapable of producing even a single work, serious 
and important enough to be pronounced without shame a 
political examination of lasting significance, a prognosis 
that has been confirmed, an independent slogan that has 
advanced us ideologically. Everywhere only decay and 
nonsense. 

Stalin's Problems of Leninism constitute a modification 
of mental refuse, an official manual of narrow-mindedness, 
a collection of enumerated banalities (I am doing my best 
to find the most moderate designations). Leninism by 
Zinoviev is ... Zinovievist Leninism, no more and no 
less. The occupation with all these theoretical fruits of 
epigonism is equally unbearable, with one distinction : a 
reading of Zinoviev's Leninism is like choking on fluffy 
cotton, while Stalin's Problems arouses the physical feeling 
of a throat filled with chopped up bristles. These two 
books are, each in its own way, the image and crown of 
the epoch of ideological reaction. 

Applying every question whether from the Right or 
the Left, from above or below, from before or behind to 
Trotskyism, the epigones have finally understood how to 
make every world event directly or indirectly dependent 
upon how the permanent revolution looked to Trotsky in 
1905. The legend of Trotskyism, chock full of falsifica- 
tions, became to a certain extent a factor in contemporary 
history. And while the Right-Centrist line of recent years 
has compromised itself in every continent by bankruptcies 
of 'historical dimensions, the struggle against the Centrist 
ideology in the Comintern is today already unthinkable, 
or at least made very difficult, without a correct evaluation 
of the old disputed questions and prognoses that originated 
in the beginning of 1905. 

The resurrection of Marxian, and consequently Leninist, 
thought in the party is unthinkable without a polemical 
annihilation of the scribblings of the epigones, without a 

40 



ENFORCED C H A R A'C T E K OF WOEK 

merciless theoretical execution of the apparatus-execu- 
tioners. It is really not difficult to write such a book. 
All its ingredients are at hand. Nevertheless, it is hard to 
write such a book, because in doing it one must, in the 
words of the great satirist, Saltykov, descend into the 
domain of "A B C effluvia" and dwell for a while in this 
scarcely ambrosial atmosphere. But the work is absolute- 
ly unpostponable, for it is precisely upon the struggle 
against the permanent revolution that the defense of the 
opportunist line in the problems of the East, that is, the 
larger half of humanity, is directly constructed. 

I was already on the point of entering into the hardly 
alluring work of a theoretical polemic with Zinoviev and 
Stalin, and of laying by the books of our classicists for 
recreation hours (even divers must rise to the surface now 
and then to breathe a draught of fresh air) when, quite 
unexpectedly for me, an article by Radek appeared and 
began to circulate, devoted to the "more profound" 
contrast of the theory of the permanent revolution with 
the views of Lenin on this subject. At the beginning, I 
wanted to ignore Radek 's work, so as not to avoid the 
portion of fluffy cotton and chopped up bristles intended 
for me by destiny. But a number of letters from friends 
induced me to read Radek's work more attentively, and 
I came to the following conclusion : for a more intimate 
circle of persons who are capable of thinking independently, 
and not upon command, and have conscientiously studied 
Marxism, Radek 's work is more dangerous than the official 
literature just as opportunism in politics is all the more 
dangerous the more veiled it appears and the greater the 
personal prominence that covers it. Radek is one of my 
closest political friends. This has been amply witnessed by 
the events of the^atest period. In recent months, however, 
various comrades have followed with misgivings the evolu- 
tion of Radek, which has shifted him from the extreme 
Left wing- of the Opposition to the tip of its Right wing. 
We, the intimate friends of Radek, know that his brilliant 

41 



PERMANENT* REVOLUTION 

political and literary capacities, which are united with a 
rare impulsiveness and sensitiveness, are qualities which 
constitute a valuable source of initiative and criticism under 
the conditions of isolation. Radek's latest work in con- 
nection with his actions preceding it leads to the judgment 
that Radek has lost the compass, or rather that his compass 
is under the influence of a steady magnetic disturbance. 
Radek's work is in no sense an episodic excursion into the 
past ; no, it is an insufficiently thought out, but because of 
that, a no less harmful support of the official course, with 
all its theoretical mythology. 

The above-characterized political function of the present 
struggle against "Trotskyism" naturally does not in any 
way signify that within the Opposition, which has developed 
as the Marxian point of support against the ideological 
and political reaction, a criticism is inadmissible, especially 
a criticism of my old differences of opinion with Lenin. 
On the contrary, such a work of clarification could only be 
fruitful. But herewith, a scrupulous preservation of the 
historical perspective, a serious investigation of the source 
, and an illumination of the past differences in the light of 
the present struggle would be absolutely necessary. There 
is not a trace of all this in Radek. Assuming an unsuspect- 
ing air, he joins in the chain fighting against "Trotskyism'% 
utilizing not only the one-sidedly selected quotations, but 
also their radically false official interpretations. Where he 
seemingly separates himself from the official campaign, he 
does it in so ambiguous a manner that he really provides 
it with the two-fold aid of an "impartial" witness. 'As 
always happens in a case of spiritual decay, the latest work 
of Radek does not contain a single trace of his political 
penetration and his literary skill. It is a work without 
perspectives, without the three dimensions, a work on the 
level of the quotations, and therefore a superficial work. 
Out of what political requirements was it born ? Out of 
the differences of opinion that arose between Radek and 
the overwhelming majority of the Opposition in the ques- 

42 



ENFORCED CHARACTER OF WORK 

tions of the Chinese revolution. A few voices are heard, 
it is true, that the differences of opinion on China are 
"not timely" (Preobrazhensky). But these voices do not 
even deserve serious consideration. The whole of 
Bolshevism grew and eventually gathered strength on the 
criticism and the assimilation of the experience of 1905, in 
all their freshness, while these experiences were still an 
immediate experience of the first generation of Bolsheviks. 
How could it be otherwise, for out of what other event 
could the new generations of the proletarian revolutionists 
learn if not from the fresh, warm experiences of the Chinese 
revolution, still reeking with blood ? Only lifeless pedants 
are capable of "postponing" the questions of the Chinese 
revolution, in order to "study" them later on in all peace, 
in their leisure hours. It becomes Bolshevik-Leninists all 
the less since the revolutions in the countries of the East 
have in no sense been removed from the order of the day 
and the periods between are not yet known to anybody. 

Adopting a false position in the problems of the Chinese 
revolution, Radek endeavours, after the event, to establish 
this position by a one-sided and distorted presentation of 
my old differences of opinion with Lenin. And this is where 
Radek is compelled to borrow his weapons from strange 
arsenals and to swim without a compass in strange waters. 

Radek is my friend, but the truth is dearer to me. I 
feel myself obliged to set aside the more extensive work 
on the problems of the revolution in order to refute Radek. 
It involves too important questions, raised with extreme 
sharpness. I have a threefold difficulty to overcome here : 
the number and multiplicity of the errors in Radek's work ; 
the profusion of literary and historical facts out of the 
twenty-three years (1905-1928) that refute Radek; and 
thirdly, the brevity of the time that I can devote to this 
work, for the economic problems of the U. S. S. R. are 
pressing to the foreground. 

These circumstances determine the character and scope 
of the present work. It does not exhaust the question. 

48 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

There is much in it that remains unexpressed in part, at 
any rate, also because it is connected with preceding works, 
primarily The Criticism of the Program of the Communist 
International. Mountains of factual material which I have 
assembled on this question remain unused up to the 
writing of the contemplated book against the epigones, that 
is, against the ideology of the period of reaction. 



Radek 's work on the permanent revolution culminates 
with the conclusion : 

"The new section of the party (Opposition) is threatened 
with the danger of the rise of tendencies which, in the 
course of time, will tear the proletarian revolution away 
from its allies the peasantry." 

It is dumbfounding at first sight that this conclusion 
should be issued in the second half of 1928 as a new con- 
clusion with regard to the "new" section of the party. 
We have been aware of it without interruption since the 
spring of 1923. But how does Radek motivate his turn to 
the official principal thesis ? Again, not in a new way : 
he turns back to the theory of the permanent revolution. 
In 1924-1925, Radek more than once intended to write a 
pamphlet which was to be dedicated to the idea of demon- 
strating that the theory of the permanent revolution and 
the Leninist slogan of the democratic dictatorship of the 
proletariat and peasantry, regarded on an historical scale, 
that is, in the light of the three revolutions passed through 
by us, could in no case be contrasted to each other, 
but were, on the contrary, identical in essence. Now, after 
having thoroughly examined the question as he writes one 
of his friends "anew", Radek has reached the conclusion 
that the old theory of permanency threatens the "new" 
section of the party with nothing more nor less than the 
danger of separation from the peasantry. 

But how did Radek thoroughly examine this ques- 

44 



ENFORCED CHARACTER OF WORK 

tion? He gives us some information on this point: 

"We do not have at hand the formulations which Trotsky 
presented in 1905 in a preface to Marx's Civil War in France 
and in 1905 in Our Revolution." 

The years are not correctly quoted here, it is true, yet 
it is not worth while to dwell upon it. It is a matter of 
fact that the only work in which I presented my views more 
or less systematically on the development of the revolution 
at that time, is a rather extensive essay : Results and per- 
spectives (Our Revolution Petersburg, 1906, pages 224-286). 
The article in the Polish organ of Rosa Luxemburg and 
Tyschko (1909), to which Radek refers, unfortunately 
interprets Kamenev's sense, lays no claim to completeness 
and comprehensiveness. Theoretically, this work is based 
upon the above-mentioned book Our Revolution. Nobody 
is obligated to read this book now. Since that time, such 
events have taken place and we have learned so much from 
these events that, truth to tell, I feel an aversion to the 
manner of the epigones of considering new historical 
problems not in the light of living experiences of the revo- 
lutions already carried out by us, but mainly in the light 
of quotations that refer to our prognoses on future 
revolutions. Naturally, by this I do not want to deprive 
Radek of the right to take up the question from the 
historico-literary side also. But in that case, it must be 
done in the right way. Radek undertakes the attempt to 
illuminate the fate of the theory of the permanent revolu- 
tion in the course of a quarter of a century, and remarks 
by the by that he "has not at hand precisely those words 
in which I set down this theory. 

I want to point out right here that Lenin, as has become 
particularly clear to me now by reading his old works did 
not read the above-mentioned fundamental article. This 
is probaby not to be explained only by the fact that Our 
Revolution, which appeared in 1906, was immediately con- 
fiscated, and that we went into emigration, but also by 
the fact that two-thirds of the book consisted of reprints of 

45 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

old articles* I heard later from many comrades that they 
had not read* this book because they thought it consisted 
exclusively of reprints of old works. In any case, the few 
scattered polemical remarks of Lenin against the permanent 
revolution rest exclusively upon the foreword of Parvus to 
my pamphlet, Until the Ninth of January further, upon 
Parvus' proclamation No Czars ! , which remained completely 
unknown to me, and upon inner-party differences of Lenin 
with Bucharin and others. Never did Lenin anywhere 
analyze, be it even in passing, Results and Perspectives, 
and a few replies of Lenin to the permanent revolution, 
obviously referring to me, directly prove that he did not 
read this work. 4 

It would be wrong to believe, however, that this is just 
what Lenin's "Leninism" consists of. But this seems to 
be the opinion of Radek. In any case, Radek's article 
which I have to examine here shows not only that he did 
"not have at hand" my fundamental works, but also that 
he never even read them. If he did, then it was long ago, - 
before the October revolution. In any case he did not 
retain much of it in his memory. 

But the matter does not end there. Even though it was 
admissible and even unavoidable in 1905 or 1909 to polemi- 
cize over a few article that were timely then and even over 
single sentences in single articles taken together, especially 
under the conditions of the split, then a revolutionary 
Marxist today, should he want to look back over an enor- 
mous historical period, must put the question : How were 
the formulae in question applied in practise, how were they 
construed in application ? How were the tactics ? Had 
Radek taken the trouble to glance through only the two 
volumes of Our First Revolution (Collected Works) he would 
not have found the courage to write his present work, at 
all events, he would have struck out a whole series of his 
impetuous contentions. At least, I hope he would. 

From these two books, Radek would have learned, in the 
first place, that in my political activity the permanent 

46 



ENFORCED CHARACTER OF WORK 

( 

revolution in no case signified for me a jumping over the 
democratic stage of the revolution or its specific steps. He 
could have convinced himself that, though I lived in Russia 
illegally throughout 1905 without connections with the 
emigration, I formulated the successive stages of the revo- 
lution in the same manner as Lenin : he could have learned 
that the fundamental appeals to the peasants that were 
issued by the central press of the Bolsheviks in 1905 were 
written by me; that the Novaia Zhizn (New Life) edited 
by Lenin in an editorial note resolutely defended my 
articles on the permanent revolution which appeared in 
Natchalo (The Beginning); that Lenin's Novaia Zhizn and 
now and then Lenin himself supported and defended ,the 
political decisions of the Soviets of Deputies whose author 
I was and which I represented as reporter nine times out 
of ten ; that, after the December defeat, I wrote a pamphlet 
on tactics in prison in which I pointed out the connection 
of the proletarian offensive with the agrarian revolution 
of the peasants as the central strategical problem; that 
Lenin published this pamphlet in the Bolshevik publishing 
house Novaia Volna (New Wave) and had me informed of 
his hearty accord through Knunianz; that Lenin spoke at 
the London congress in 1907 of my "solidarity" with 
Bolshevism in the viewpoint on the peasantry and the 
liberal bourgeoisie. None of them exists for Radek : 
probably he did not have this "at hand" either. 

How does the matter stand with Radek in relation to the 
works of Lenin? No better, or not much better. Radek 
confines himself to those quotations which Lenin did indeed 
direct against me but meant for others (for example, 
Bucharin and Radek : an open reference to this is found in 
Radek himself). Radek was unable to adduce a single new 
quotation : he simply made use of the finished quotation 
material that almost every citizen of the U. S. S. R. has 
"at hand". Radek only added a few quotations in which 
Lenin elucidated the elementary truths to the anarchists 
anil Social Revolutionists on the difference between a 

47 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

bourgeois republic and socialism where it looks as though 
these lines were directed against me. Hardly credible, but 
it is true. 

Radek entirely avoids those old declarations in which 
Lenin, very cautiously and very sparingly, but with all the 
greater emphasis, established my solidarity with Bolshevism 
in questions of revolutionary principle. Here it must not 
be forgotten for an instant that Lenin did this at a time 
when I did not belong to the Bolshevik faction and that 
Lenin attacked me mercilessly (and rightly so) for my con- 
ciliationism not for the permanent revolution, where he 
confined himself to occasional rejoinders but for my con- 
ciliationism, for my readiness to hope for an evolution of 
the Mensheviks to the Left. Lenin was much more con- 
cerned with the struggle against conciliationism than with 
"justifying" single polemical blows against the "conciliator" 
Trotsky. 

In 1924, defending before me Zinoviev's conduct in 
October 1917, Stalin wrote : 

"Comrade Trotsky has not understood the letters of Lenin 
(on Zinoviev L. T.); their significance and their destina- 
tion. Lenin frequently used to rush ahead deliberately in 
his letters and to shove to the foreground the possible errors 
that might be made. He criticized them in advance with 
the aim of warning the party and insuring it against 
mistakes, or he often exaggerated a 'trifle' and, with the 
same pedagogical aim, made 'an elephant out of a 
gnat* . . . But to draw from these letters of Lenin (and 
there are no few such letters of his) the conclusion of 'tragic' 
differences of opinion and to trumpet this abroad means 
not to understand Lenin's letters, not to know Lenin." 
(J. Stalin Trotskyism or Leninism, 1924.) 

However clumsy the formulation "the style is the 
man" the ideas are nevertheless essentially correct, even 
if they apply least of all precisely to the differences of 
opinion on October 1917, which do not quite resemble a 
"gnat". But if Lenin used to resort to "pedagogical" 

48 



ENFORCED CHAEACTEE OF WOEK 

exaggerations and to preventive policies towards the closest 
members ot his own faction, then surely all the more so 
towards one who stood outside the Bolshevik faction at the 
same time and preached conciliationism. It never occurred 
to Radek to allow for this corrective coefficient in the old 
quotations. 

In 1922, I wrote in the foreword to my book 1905 that 
my prognosis that the dictatorship of the proletariat is 
likely and possible in Russia sooner than in the advanced 
countries, had been confirmed after twelve years, Radek, 
following a not very seductive example, describes it as 
though I had contrasted this prognosis with Lenin*s 
strategical line. From the foreword, however, it can be ' 
clearly seen that I considered the prognosis in those of its 
basic features in which it coincided with the strategic line 
of Bolshevism. When I speak in a footnote of the "re- 
armament" of the party at the beginning of 1917, then it 
is certainly not in the sense that Lenin recognized the 
previous road of the party as "erroneous" but rather that 
Lenin, even though after a delay, yet opportunely enough 
for the success of the revolution, came to Russia to teach 
the party to liberate itself from the outlived slogans of the 
"democratic dictatorship" to which the Stalins, Kamenevs, 
Rykovs, Molotovs and others were still clinging. When the 
Kamenevs grow indignant at the mention of the "re-arma- 
ment", it is comprehensible, for it was undertaken against 
them. But Radek? He first began to grow indignant in 
1928, that is, only after he himself had begun to fight 
against the necessary "re-armament" of the Chinese Com- 
munist Party. 

We would like to remind Radek that my books 1905 
(with the indicated foreword) and The October Revolution 
played the role, while Lenin was alive, of the fundamental 
historical textbooks of the two revolutions. At that time, 
they went through innumerable editions in the Russian as 
well as in foreign languages. Never did anybody tell me 
that my books contain a contrast of two lines, .because at 

49 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

that time, before the revisionist change of course by the 
epigones, every normal-thinking party member did not 
consider the October experiences in the light of the old 
quotations, but the old quotations in the light of the 
October revolution. 

In connection with this there is still another point which 
Radek misuses in an impermissible manners Trotsky did 
acknowledge he says that Lenin was right against him. 
True, he did acknowledge that. And in this acknowledg- 
ment there was not one iota of diplomacy. But I had in 
mind the whole historical road of Lenin, his whole 
theoretical position, his strategy, his way of building the 
party. This does not, however, relate to every single one 
of the polemical quotations which are moreover misused 
today for purposes alien to Leninism. In 1926, in the 
period of the bloc with Zinoviev, Radek warned me : 
Zinoviev needs my declaration that Lenin was right in 
order to. excuse a little his, Zinoviev's, wrong against me. 
Naturally, I understood this well. And that is why I said 
at the Seventh Plenum of the E. C. C. I. that I meant the 
historical right of Lenin and his party, but in no case the 
right of my present critics who strive to cover themselves 
with quotations plucked out of Lenin. 

Today, I am unfortunately compelled to extend these 
words to Radek. With regard to the permanent revolution, 
I spoke only of the defects of the theory, which were 
inevitable in so far as it was a question of a prognosis. At 
the Seventh Plenum of the E. C. C. I., Bucharin rightly 
emphasized that Trotsky did not renounce the conception 
in its entirety. On the "defects", I shall speak in another, 
more extensive work, in which I shall endeavour to present 
the experiences of the three revolutions and their applica- 
tion to the further course of the Comintern, especially in 
the East. But in order to leave no room for ambiguities, 
I wish to say here briefly : despite all its defects, the theory 
of the permanent revolution, even in the presentation of 
my earliest works, primarily in Results and Perspectives 

50 



ENFORCED CHARACTER OF WORK 

(1906) is permeated to an incomparably greater degree with 
the spirit of Marxism and consequently stands infinitely 
closer to the . historical line of Lenin and the Bolshevik 
party, than not only the present Stalinist and Bucharinist 
retrospective wisdom but also than the latest work of 
Radek. By this, however, I do not at all want to say that 
the conception of the revolution presents the same 
immovable line in all my writings. I have not occupied 
myself with the collection of old quotations I am forced 
to do it now by the period of party reaction and epigonism 
but I have plainly and honestly sought to analyze the real 
processes of life. In the twelve years (1905-1917) of my 
revolutionary journalistic activity, there are also articles in 
which the conjunctural relations and even the conjunctural 
polemical exaggerations inevitable in struggle, stand out in 
violation of the strategic line. Thus, for example, articles 
can be found in which I expressed doubts about the future 
revolutionary role of the peasantry as a whole, as a group, 
and in connection with this refused to characterize, 
especially during the imperialist war, the future Russian 
revolution as "national", for I felt this characterization to 
be ambiguous. But it must not be forgotten here that the 
historical processes that interest us, also in the peasantry, 
are far more obvious now that they 'have been accomplished 
than in those days when they were first developing. I 
would observe in passing that Lenin, who never for a 
moment lost sight of the peasant question in all its gigantic, 
historical magnitude and from whom we all learned this 
considered it uncertain even after the February revolution 
that we would succeed in tearing the peasantry away from 
the bourgeoisie and linking it with the proletariat. I might, 
moreover, say quite in general to my harsh critics that it 
is far easier to dig out in one hour the formal contradictions 
in a quarter of a century of another's newspaper articles, 
than it is to preserve, oneself, if even for a year, the unity 
of principled line. 
There remains but to mention in these introductory lines, 

51 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

an especially noteworthy supplement: had the theory of 
the permanent revolution been correct says Radek 
Trotsky would have assembled a large faction on that basis. 
But that did not happen. Consequently . . . the theory 
was false. 

The argument of Radek, taken as a whole, does not 
contain a trace of dialectics. One could conclude from it 
that the standpoint of the Opposition on the Chinese 
revolution, or the attitude of Marx in British affairs, was 
false; that the position of the Comintern with regard to 
the reformists in America, in Austria and if you wish 
in all countries, is false. If Radek's argument is taken not 
in its general "historico-philosophical" form, but only as 
applied to the question that interests us, then it hits Radek 
himself; the argument might have meaning had I been of 
the opinion or, what is still more important, had events 
shown, that the line of Bolshevism is in conflict with it, and 
deviates from it ever further : only then would there be 
the ground for two factions. But that is just what Radek 
wants to prove. I prove, on the contrary, that in spite 
of all the factional polemical exaggerations and conjunctural 
accentuations of the question, the basic strategical lines 
were alike. Where should a second faction have come 
from? In reality, it turned out that I worked hand in 
hand with the Bolsheviks in the first revolution and later 
defended this common work in the international press 
against the renegades 5 criticism of the Mensheviks. In the 
1917 revolution, I fought together with Lenin against the 
democratic opportunism of those "old Bolsheviks" who 
have today been elevated by the reactionary wave and 
fitted for the hunt against the permanent revolution. 

Finally, I never endeavoured to create a grouping on 
the basis of the theory of the permanent revolution. My 
inner-party stand was a conciliatory one and when at 
certain moments I strove for groupings, then it was 
precisely on this basis. My conciliationism was derived 
from a certain Social Revolutionary fatalism. I believed 

52 



E N F On CED CHARACTER- OF 'WORK 

that the logic of the class struggle would compel both 
factions to pursue the same revolutionary line. The great 
historical significance of Lenin's stand was still unclear to 
me at that time, his policy of irreconcilable ideological 
demarcation and, when necessary, split, for the purpose of 
uniting and steeling the backbone of the truly revolutionary 
party. In 1911, Lenin wrote on this subject : 

"Conciliationism is the result of moods, endeavours and 
opinions which are inseparably bound up with the nature 
of the historical task put before the Russian Social Demo- 
cratic Party in the counter-revolutionary epochs of 
1908-1911. That is why a whole series of social democrats 
deteriorated into conciliationism in this epoch, proceeding 
from the most variegated premises. Conciliationism was 
represented most consistently by Trotsky who, almost 
alone, endeavored to lay a theoretical foundation for this 
current." (Volume X7, part 2, page 371.) 

By striving for unity at all costs, I involuntarily and 
unavoidably had to idealize the Centrist tendencies in 
Menshevism. Despite the threefold episodic attempts, I 
arrived at no common work with the Mensheviks, and 
I could not arrive at it. Simultaneously, however, the 
conciliatory line brought me into an all the harsher position 
towards Bolshevism, since Lenin, in contrast to the 
Mensheviks, mercilessly rejected conciliationism, and could 
do no different. It is obvious that no faction could be 
created on the platform of conciliationism. Thence the 
lesson : it is inadmissible and harmful to bend back or 
weaken a political line in favour of vulgar conciliationism; 
it is inadmissible to gloss over Centrism zig-zagging to the 
Left; it is inadmissible, in the hunt after the will-o'-the- 
wisps of Centrism, to exaggerate differences of opinion with 
genuine revolutionary co-thinkers. These are the real 
lessons of Trotsky's mistakes. These lessons are very 
significant. They preserve their full force even today and 
it is precisely Radek who should meditate well upon them. 

With the cynicism that marks him out, Stalin once said : 

58 



PERMANENT BBV OLUTIO.N 

"Trotsky must know that Lenin fought to the end of 
his life against the ffieory of the permanent revolution. 
But this does not disturb him." (Pravda, No. 261. 
November 12, 1926.) 

This is a rude, disloyal, that is, a purely Stalinist 
caricature of reality. In an appeal to the foreign Com- 
munists, Lenin declared that differences of opinion among 
the Communists are something quite different from differ- 
ences of opinion with the social democrats. Such differences 
of opinion, he wrote, Bolshevism had already gone through 
before. But "... at the moment of the capture 
of power and the creation of the Soviet republic, Bolshevism 
was united and drew to it the best of the currents of 
socialist thought closest to it." (Vol. XVI, page 888.) 

What closest currents of socialist thought did Lenin 
have in mind when he wrote these lines ? Martinov or 
Kuusinen ? Or Cachin, Thalmann and Smeral ? Did they 
perhap^ appear to him as the "best" of the closest currents ? 
What other tendency was closer to Bolshevism than the 
one which I represented in all the questions of principle, 
including the peasant question ? Even Rosa Luxemburg 
shrank back at first from the agrarian policy of the 
Bolshevik government. For me, however, there was no 
question about it at all. We were together at the table 
when Lenin, pencil in hand, wrote down the draft of his 
agrarian law. And the interchange of opinions hardly 
consisted of more than a dozen brief rejoinders, the sense 
of which was about the following : a contradictory, but 
historically quite unavoidable step; under the regime of 
the proletarian dictatorship and in the extension of the 
world revolution, the contradictions will be adjusted we 
only need time. If a diametrical antagonism existed in the 
peasant question between the theory of the permanent 
revolution and Lenin's dialectics, how then does Radek 
want to explain the fact that, without renouncing my 
fundamental views on the course of development of the 
revolution, I did not stumble for an instant over the peasant 

54 



ENFORCED CHARACTER OF WORK 

question in 1917, as did the majority of the Bolshevik heads 
at that time ? How does Eadek explain the fact that after 
the February revolution the present theoreticians and 
politicians of anti-Trotskyism the Zinovievs, Kamenevs, 
Stalins, Molotovs, etc., etc. adopted, to the last man, the 
vulgar-democratic but not proletarian -position ? And once 
more : of whom and of what could Lenin have spoken when 
he referred to the fusion of Bolshevism with the best 
elements of the Marxist currents closest to it ? And does 
not Lenin's conclusive judgment on the past differences of 
opinion show that in any case he saw no two irreconcilable 
strategical lines? 

Still more noteworthy in this respect is Lenin's speech 
in the session of the Petrograd Committee of November 1-14, 
1917. 5 There the question was considered of an agreement 
with the Mensheviks and Social Revolutionists. The 
supporters at that time of a coalition endeavoured, even 
there, very timidly, to be sure, to hint at "Trotskyism". 
What did Lenin reply ? 

"Agreement ? I cannot even speak seriously about 
that. Trotsky has long ago said that unity is impossible. 
Trotsky has understood this since then there has been no 
better Bolshevik." 

Not the permanent revolution, but conciliationism was 
what separated me, according to Lenin's views, from 
Bolshevism. In order to become the "best Bolshevik", I 
only needed, as we see, to understand the impossibility of 
an agreement with the Mensheviks. 

But how is the abrupt character of Radek's turn 
precisely in the question of the permanent revolution to 
be explained? I believe I have one element of the 
explanation. In 1916, as we learn from his writings, Radek 
was in agreement with the permanent revolution, but in 
the Bucharinist interpretation, according to which the 
bourgeois revolution in Russia is terminated not only the 
revolutionary r61e of the bourgeoisie, and not even the 
historical role of the slogan of the "democratic" dictator- 

55 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

ship, but the bourgeois revolution as such and that the 
proletariat must therefore proceed to the capture of power 
under a purely socialist banner. Radek manifestly also 
interpreted my position at that time in the Bucharinist 
manner : otherwise he could not declare his solidarity with 
Bucharin and me at one and the same time. This also 
explains why Lenin polemicized against Bucharin and 
Radek, with whom he did work together, having them 
appear under the pseudonym of Trotsky. (Radek admits 
this also in his article). I remember that also 
M. N. Pokrovsky, a co-worker of Bucharin, and a tireless 
constructor of historical schemata, Marxistically colored 
with great skill, alarmed me in Paris, in conversation on 
this question, with his dubious "solidarity". (In politics, 
Pokrovsky was and remains an anti-Cadet, which he 
honestly believes to be Bolshevism.) 

In 1924-1925, Radek apparently still lived upon 
spiritual recollections of the Bucharinist position of 
1916, which he continued to identify with mine. Rightly 
disillusioned by the hopelessness of his pisition on the 
basis of a fleeting study of Lenin's writings, Radek, as 
frequently used to happen in such cases, described 
an arc of 180 degrees right over my head. This is 
very probable because it is typical. Thus Bucharin, who 
in 1923-1925 turned a complete somersault himself, that 
is, transformed himself from an ultra-Leftist into an 
opportunist, constantly attributes to me his own ideologi- 
cal past, which he palms off as "Trotskyism". In the 
first period of the campaign against me, when I often 
still managed to look over Bucharin 's articles, I would 
frequently ask myself: where did he get this from? but 
soon guessed that he had glanced into his diary of yester- 
day. And now I wonder if the same psychological 
foundation does not lie at the bottom of Radek's con- 
version from a Paul of the permanent revolution into its 
Saul. I do not presume to insist upon this hypothesis. 
But I can find no other explanation. 

56 



ENFORCED CHARACTEE OF WORK 

One way or the other, according to a French expression : 
the flask is uncorked, the wine must be drunk. We are 
compelled to undertake a pretty far excursion into the 
realm of old quotations. I have reduced their number 
as much as was feasible. Yet there are many of them. 
Let this fact serve as justification : that I strive through- 
out to find in the enforced rummaging among old 
quotations the threads to the burning questions of the 
present. 



57 



CHAPTER TWO 



THE PERMANENT REVOLUTION IS 
NOT A "LEAP" OF THE PROLETARIAT, 
BUT THE TRANSFORMATION OF THE 
NATION UNDER THE LEADERSHIP 
OF THE PROLETARIAT 



RADEK WRITES : "The essential feature that distinguishes 
the train of thought which is called the theory and 
tactic [observe: tactic too L. T.] of the 'permanent 
revolution' from Lenin's theory lies in mixing up the stage 
of the bourgeois revolution with the stage oj the socialist 
revolution." 

I Intimately connected with this fundamental reproach, 
or resulting from it, there are other, no less serious accu- 
sations: Trotsky did not understand that "under Russian 
conditions, a socialist revolution which does not grow out 
of the democratic revolution is impossible". From which 
results of itself the "skipping of the stage of the 
democratic dictatorship." Trotsky "denies" the r61e of 
the peasantry which is where "the community of views of 
Trotsky and the Mensheviks" lay. As already said, all 
this is to prove by the system of circumstantial evidence 
the incorrectness of my position in the fundamental ques- 
tions of the Chinese revoution. 

To be sure, in the formal literary respect, Radek can 
refer here and there to Lenin. And he does that : every- 
body has "at "hand" this part of the quotations. But as 
I shall soon demonstrate, these contentions of Lenin in 
regard to me had a purely episodic character and 
were incorrect, that is, in no sense did they characterize 
my real position in 1905. In Lenin himself there are quite 

58 



NOT A "LEAP" BUT A "GROWING-OVER" 

different, directly contrary and far better grounded remarks 
on my attitude in the principled questions oi the revolution. 
Radek did not even make the attempt to unite the various 
and directly antithetical remarks of Lenin, and to elucidate 
these polemical contradictions by a comparison with my 
actual views 

In 1906, Lenin published, with his own foreword, an 
article by Kautsky on the motive forces of the Russian 
revolution. Without knowing anything about this, I also 
translated Kautsky's article in prison, provided it with 
a foreword and included it in my book On the defense of 
the Party. Both Lenin and I expressed our thorough 
accord with Kautsky 's analysis. To Plechanov's question : 
Is our revolution bourgeois or socialist? Kautsky had 
answered that it is no longer bourgeois, but not yet 
socialist, that is, it presents the transitional form from the 
one to the other. To this, Lenin wrote in his foreword : 

"Are we confronted by a bourgeois or a socialist revolu- 
tion, in its whole character ? That is the old schema, says 
Kautsky. That is not how the question should be put, 
that is not Marxism. The revolution in Russia 
that is not bourgeois, for the bourgeoisie is not a driving 
force of the present revolutionary movement of Russia. 
But neither is the revolution in Russia socialist." (Volume 
F//7, page 82.) 

Yet not a few passages can be found in Lenin, written 
before and after this foreword, where he categorically calls 
the Russian revolution bourgeois. Is that a contradic- 
tion? If Lenin is approached with the methods of the 
present critics of "Trotskyism", then dozens and 
hundreds of such "contradictions" can be found, which are 
clarified for the serious and conscientious reader by the 
difference in the posing of the question at different 
moments, which in no way violates the unity of Lenin's 
conception. 

On the other hand, I never disputed the bourgeois 
character of the revolution in the sense of its actual 

59 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

historical tasks, but only in the sense of its motive 
forces and its perspective. My fundamental work of 
those days (1905-1906) on the permanent revolution, 
begins with the following sentences : 

"The Russian revolution came unexpectedly to every- 
body but the social democracy. Marxism long ago foretold 
the inevitability of the Russian revolution which had to 
come as a result of the collision of the forces of capitalist 
development with the forces of inflexible absolutism. 
By characterizing it as bourgeois, it pointed out that the 
immediate objective tasks of the revolution consisted of 
the creation of 'normal' conditions for the development 
of bourgeois society as a whole. Marxism was right. This 
can no longer be disputed today, nor need it be demon- 
strated. The Marxists are confronted with a quite differ- 
ent task: by an analysis of the internal mechanics of the 
developing revolution to disclose its 'possibilities.' 

"The Russian revolution had a quite peculiar character 
which is the result of the peculiarities of our whole socio- 
historical evolution and which, in regard to it, opens up 
quite new historical perspectives." (Our Revolution, 
1906, article Results and Perspectives, page 221>.) 

"The general sociological characterization bourgeois 
revolution in no way settles the politico-tactical problems, 
contradictions and difficulties which are raised by this 
given bourgeois revolution''. (Ibid, page 2J+9.) 

In this way, I did not dispute the bourgeois character 
of the revolution that stood on the order of the day and 
mix up democracy and socialism. But I endeavored to 
show that with us the class dialectics of the bourgeois 
revolution would bring the proletariat to power and that 
without its dictatorship not even the democratic tasks 
could be solved. In the same article (1905-1906) it says : 

"The proletariat grows and consolidates itself with 
the growth of capitalism. In this sense, the develop- 
ment of capitalism signifies the development of the 
proletariat toward the dictatorship. But the day and 

60 



NOT A "LEAP" BUT A "G BOWING-OVER 

hour when the power passes into the hands of the pro- 
letariat do not depend directly upon the state of the 
productive forces, but upon the conditions of the class 
struggle, upon the international situation, and finally, upon 
a series of objective factors : tradition, initiative, readiness 
for struggle. . . . 

"In an economically backward country, the proletariat 
can come to power sooner than in the economically 
advanced countries. The conception of some sort of 
automatic dependence of the proletarian dictatorship upon 
the technical forces and resources of the country constitutes 
An extremely over-simplified 'economic' materialism. This 
view has nothing in common with Marxism. 

"The Russian revolution, in our opinion, creates such 
conditions under which the power can pass over to the 
proletariat (and with a victorious revolution it must) even 
before the policy of bourgeois liberalism acquires the 
possibility to bring its state genius to a full unfolding". 
(Ibid, page 245.) 

These lines contain a polemic against that* vulgar 
"Marxism" which not only prevailed in 1905-1906 but also 
gave the tone to the conference of the Bolsheviks in March 
1917 before Lenin's arrival, and found its crassest expression 
in Rykov at the April conference. At the Sixth Congress 
of the Comintern, this pseudo-Marxism, that is, "common 
sense" debauched by scholasticism, constituted the 
"scientific" basis of the speeches of Kuusinen and many 
others. And this, ten years after the October revolution! 

Since I have not the possibility of describing here the 
whole train of thought of Results and Perspectives, I should 
like to adduce one more clearly expressed quotation from 
my article in Natchalo (1905) : 

"Our liberal bourgeoisie comes forward as counter- 
revolutionary even before the revolutionary climax. In 
every critical moment, our intellectual democracy only 
demonstrates its impotence. The peasantry in its entirety 
represents an elementary rebellion. It can be put at the 

61 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

service of the revolution only by the force that takes over 
state power. The vanguard position of the working class 
in the revolution, the direct connection between it and the 
revolutionary village, the spell by which it conquers the 
army all this pushes it inevitably to power. The complete 
victory of the revolution means the victory of the 
proletariat. This in turn means the further uninterrupted 
advance of the revolution." (Our Revolution, page 179.) 

The perspective of the dictatorship of the proletariat 
consequently grows here, precisely out of the bourgeois- 
democratic revolution in contradiction to all that Radek 
writes. That is just why the revolution is called permanent 
(uninterrupted). But the dictatorship of the proletariat 
does not come after the completion of the democratic 
revolution, as Radek would have it in such a case, it would 
simply be impossible in Russia, for in a backward country 
the numerically weak proletariat cannot attain power if the 
tasks of the peasantry have been solved during the preced- 
ing stage. No, the dictatorship of the proletariat appeared 
probable and even inevitable on the basis of the bourgeois 
revolution precisely because there was no other power and 
no other way to solve the tasks of the agrarian revolution. 
But this alone opens up the perspective of the democratic 
revolution growing over into a socialist revolution. 

"Entering the government not as impotent hostages, but 
as the leading power, the representatives of the proletariat 
already destroy by that alone the boundaries between the 
minimum and maximum programs, that is, they put 
collectivism on the order of the day. At what point on 
this road the proletariat will be halted depends upon the 
relation of forces, but not upon the original designs of the 
party of the proletariat. That is why there can also be 
no question of some sort of special form of the proletarian 
dictatorship in the bourgeois revolution, namely, the demo- 
cratic dictatorship of the proletariat (or of the proletariat 
and peasantry). The working class cannot assure the 
democratic character of its dictatorship without over- 

62 



NOT A "LEAP 5 ' BUT A "G E O W I N G - O V B 

stepping the boundaries of its democratic program. 

"If the party of the proletariat takes over power, it 
will fight (for this power to the end. If one of the means 
of this struggle for the maintenance and consolidation of 
the power is agitation and organization especially in the 
village, then the other means will consist of the collectivist 
program. Collectivism will not only be the inevitable 
consequence of the fact that the party is in power but also 
the means of insuring this situation based on the pro- 
letariat." (Results and Perspectives, page %59.) 

Let us go further : 

"We know the classic example (I wrote in 1908 against 
the Menshevik, Tcherevanin) of a revolution in which the 
conditions for the rule of the capitalist bourgeoisie were 
prepared by the terrorist dictatorship of the victorious 
sansculottes. That was in an epoch when the principal 
mass of the urban population was composed of artisans and 
tradesmen, that is, of the petty bourgeoisie. It followed 
the leadership of the Jacobins. The principal mass of the 
urban population in Russia is composed today of the 
industrial proletariat. This analogy alone points to the 
possibility of such an historical situation in which the 
victory of the 6 bourgeois' revolution is granted only by the 
conquest of revolutionary power by the proletariat. Does 
the revolution thereby cease to be bourgeois ? Yes and no. 
This does not depend upon the formal designation, but 
upon the further development of events. If the proletariat 
is overthrown by the coalition parties, among them also the 
peasantry it liberated, then the revolution retains its limited 
bourgeois character. Should the proletariat, IJiowever, find it 
possible to set in motion all the means of its political 
rule in order to break through the national limits of the 
Russian revolution, then it can become the prologue to 
the socialist world era. The question : What stage will 
the Russian revolution attain? permits naturally only a 
conditioned reply. Only one thing is absolutely and in- 
dubitably correct: the naked characterization of the 

63 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

Russian revolution as bourgeois tells us nothing about the 
type of its internal development and in no case signifies 
that the proletariat must adopt its tactic to the conduct 
of the bourgeois democracy as the only legal claimant to 
state power. " (L. Trotsky, 1905 page 263, Russian edition). 

From the same article: 

"Our revolution, which is a bourgeois revolution ac- 
cording to the immediate tasks it grew out of, knows, as a 
consequence of the extreme class differentiation of the in- 
dustrial population, of no bourgeois class which could place 
itself at the head of the popular masses by combining its 
social weight and political experience with revolutionary 
energy. The suppressed worker and peasant masses 9 left to 
their own resources, must take it upon themselves to 
create, in the hard school of implicable conflict and cruel 
defeat, the necessary political and organizational pre- 
conditions for their triumph. No other road is open to 
them." (L. Trotsky, 1905, pages 267-S.) 

One more quotation from Results and Perspectives 
on the most violently assailed point on the peasantry 
must be adduced. In the special chapter The Proletariat in 
Power and the Peasantry , the following is said : 

"The proletariat will not be able to insure its power 
without broadening the base of its revolution. 

"Many sections of the toiling masses, especially in the 
village, will be drawn into the revolution and embraced by 
a political organization for the first time, only after the 
vanguard of the revolution, the city proletariat, has 
placed itself at the helm of state power. Revolutionary 
agitation and organization will be carried out with the 
help of state resources. Finally, the legislative power 
itself will become a mighty instrument for revolutionizing 
the masses of the people. . . . 

"The fate of the most elementary interests of the 
peasantry even of the whole peasantry as a class is 
knit together with the fate of the revolution, i.e., with the 
fate of the proletariat. 

64 



NOT A "LEAP" BUT A "GROWING-OVEB" 

"The proletariat in power will appear to the peasan- 
try as the liberating class." 

"The rule of the proletariat will not only mean: 
democratic equality, free self-administration, transference 
of the tax burden to the possessing classes, transforma- 
tion of the standing army into the armed people, aboli- 
tion of compulsory church taxes, but also recognition of 
all the revolutionary redivisions (seizures) of landed pro- 
perty undertaken by the peasantry. The proletariat will 
make this redivision the point of departure for further 
state measures in the field of agriculture. Under these condi- 
tions, the Russian peasantry in the first, most difficult 
period will be no less interested in supporting the proleta- 
rian regime than the French peasantry in sup- 
porting the military regime of Napoleon Bonaparte, which 
guaranteed the new possessors the inviolability of their land 
tracts by virtue of the bayonet. . . ." 

"But perhaps the peasantry will dislodge the proleta- 
riat and itself occupy its place ?" 

"This is impossible. All historical experience pro- 
tests against such an assumption. This experience proves 
that the peasantry is entirely incapable of an independent 
political role. 9 ' (Page 251). 

All this was written not in 1929, nor yet in 1924, but 
in 1905. Does this look like "ignoring the peasantry", 
I should like to know? Where is the "jumping over" 
the agrarian question here? Is it not time, friends, to 
show somewhat more of a sense of propriety? 

Now let us see in what condition this "sense of 
propriety" is with Stalin. Referring to my New York 
articles on the February 1917 revolution, which agree in 
every essential with Lenin's Geneva articles, the theoreti- 
cian of party reaction writes : 

"The letters of comrade Trotsky, both in spirit and 
in conclusions, are entirely dissimilar from Lenin's letters, 
for they repeat entirely the anti-Bolshevik slogan of 
Trotsky : 'No czar and a labor government', a slogan 

65 



PBBMANENT REVOLUTION 

which means: Revolution without the peasantry." 
(Speech to the fraction of the Central Committee of the 
Trade Unions, November 19%.) 

Exquisite is the sound of these words on the "anti- 
Bolshevik slogan" (allegedly Trotsky's) : "No czar and a 
labor government." According to Stalin, the Bolshevik 
slogan should have read : "No labor government, but a 
czar." We will still speak of the alleged "slogan" of 
Trotsky. But we would first like to hear from another of 
the notables of the ruling spirit of the day, less illiterate 
perhaps, but one who has, however, taken leave forever 
from any theoretical scruples : I speak of Lunatcharsky : 

"In 1905, Leo Davidovitch Trotsky inclined to the 
idea: the proletariat must remain isolated (!) and must 
not support the bourgeoisie, for that would be opportu- 
nism; for the proletariat alone, however, it would be very 
difficult to carry through the revolution, because the pro- 
letariat at that time amounted to only seven-eighths of a 
percent of the total population and no great war could be 
conducted with so small a cadre. Thus, Leo Davidovitch 
decided that the proletariat in Russia must support the 
permanent revolution, that is, fight for the greatest possi- 
ble success, until the fiery sparks of this conflagration 
blew the powder deposits of the world into the air." (The 
Power of the Soviets, No. 7. On the Characteristics O/ 
the October Revolution: A. Lunatcharsky, page 10.) 

The proletariat "must remain isolated" until the fiery 
sparks blow up the powder deposits .... How beautifully 
many People's Commissars write who are for the moment 
not yet "isolated" in spite of the threatened position of 
their own mental power 7 . But we do not want to be so 
severe with Lunatcharsky : from each according to his 
abilities. His slovenly absurdities are no more senseless 
than those of many others. 

But how, according to Trotsky, must "the proletariat 
remain isolated" ? Let us adduce one quotation from my 
polemic against Strfcve (1906). At the time, Lunatchar- 

66 



NOT A "LEAP" BUT A " GROWING-OVER " 

jsky chanted immoderate hymns of praise for this work. 
While the bourgeois parties the reference is to the Soviet 
of Deputies "remained entirely aloof" from the awaken- 
ing masses. 

"... political life became concentrated around the 
workers 5 Soviet. The attitude of the city masses to the 
Soviet (1905) was manifestly sympathetic, even if not 
clear. All the oppressed and offended sought its protec- 
tion. The popularity of the Soviet grew far beyond the 
city. It received 'petitions' from peasants who suffered 
injustices, peasants' resolutions poured into the Soviet, 
delegations from village communities came to it. Here, 
right here, is where were concentrated the thoughts and 
sympathies of the nation, of the real and not the falsified 
democratic nation." (Our Revolution, page 199.) 

In all these quotations their number can easily be 
increased two, three, and tenfold the permanent revolu- 
tion is described as a revolution which welds together the 
oppressed masses of city and village around the proletariat 
organized in Soviets; as a national revolution that raises 
the proletariat to power and by that alone affords the 
possibility of the democratic revolution growing into a 
socialist revolution. 

The permanent revolution is no isolated leap of the 
proletariat, rather it is the rebuilding of the whole nation 
under the leadership of the proletariat. That is how I 
pictured the perspective of the permanent revolution since 
1905, and so I construed it. 



Radek is also wrong with regard to Parvus 5 whose 
views on the Russian revolution in 1905 bordered closely 
on mine, without, however, being identical with them 
when he repeats the stereotyped phrase about Parvus' 
"leap" from the czarist to the social democratic govern- 
ment. Radek actually refutes himself when, in another 

67 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

part of his article, he indicates in passing but quite cor 7 
rectly, wherein my views on the revolution actually differ- 
ed from those of Parvus. Parvus was not of the opinion 
that the labor government in Russia has a way out in the 
direction of the socialist revolution, that is, that in the 
process of fulfilling the tasks of democracy it can emerge 
into the socialist dictatorship. As is proved by the quo- 
tation from 1905 adduced by Radek himself, Parvus con- 
fined the tasks of the labor government to the tasks of 
democracy. Then where is the leap to socialism? As a 
result of the revolutionary overthrow, the erection of a 
labor government on the "Australian" model already then 
hovered before Parvus. Parvus also made the compari- 
son between Russia and Australia after the October revo- 
lution, when he himself already stood at the extreme 
Right wing of social reformism. Bucharin said about this 
that Parvus had "discovered" Australia after the fact in 
order to cover up his old sins with regard to the perma- 
nent revolution. But that is wrong. In 1905, Parvus saw 
in the conquest of power by the proletariat the road to 
democracy and not to socialism, that is, he assigned to the 
proletariat only that role which it actually played in 
Russia in the first eight to ten months of the October re- 
volution. As a further perspective, Parvus even then 
pointed to the Australian democracy of that time, that is, 
to *a regime in which the labour party does indeed govern 
but does not rule, and carries out its reformist demands 
only as the supplement to the program of the bourgeoisie. 
Irony of fate : the fundamental tendency of the Right- 
Centrist bloc of 1923-1928 consisted precisely of drawing 
the dictatorship of the proletariat closer to the labor de- 
mocracy of the Australian model, that is, of the prognosis 
of Parvus. This becomes all the clearer when it is recall- 
ed that the Russian philistine "socialists" of two or three 
decades ago continually depicted Australia in the Rus- 
sian press as a workers' 'and peasants' country which, 
shut off from the outer world by high tariffs, was de- 

68 



NOT A "LEAP" BUT A "GROWING-OVEB" 

veloping "socialist" legislation and in that way was 
building socialism in one country. Radek would have 
acted correctly had he pushed this side of the question to 
the foreground instead of repeating the fairy tales of the 
fantastic skipping over of democracy. 



CHAPTER THREE 



THREE ELEMENTS OF THE 

"DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP": 

CLASSES, TASKS AND POLITICAL 

MECHANICS 



THE DIFFERENCE between the *' permanent" stand-point 
and that of Lenin, expressed itself politically in the con- 
trast of the slogan of the dictatorship of the proletariat 
which supports itself upon the peasantry and the slogan of 
the democratic dictatorship of the proletariat and the 
peasantry. The dispute was not concerned with whether 
the bourgeois-democratic stage could be skipped and 
whether an alliance between the workers and the peasants 
was necessary it concerned the political mechanics of the 
collaboration of the proletariat and the peasantry in the 
democratic revolution. 

Far too presumptive, not to say light-minded, is 
Radek's contention that only people "who have not thought 
out the complexity of the methods of Marxism and 
Leninism to the end" could push to the foreground the 
question of the party-political expression of the democratic 
dictatorship, when Lenin saw the whole question only in 
the collaboration of the two classes in the objective histo- 
rical task. No, that is not how it stood. 

If the subjective factor of the revolution, the parties and 
their programs in this case, the political and organizational 
form of the collaboration of proletariat and peasantry is 
abandoned, then there vanish all the differences of opinion, 
not only between Lenin and me, which marked two shades 
of the same revolutionary wing, but what is certainly 

70 



CLASSES, TASKS & POLITICAL MECHANICS 

worse, also the differences of opinion between Bolshevism 
and Menshevism, and finally, the differences between the 
Russian revolution of 1905 and the revolutions of 1848 and 
even of 1789, in so far as the proletariat can at all be 
spoken of in relation to the latter. All bourgeois revolu- 
tions have rested on the cooperation of the oppressed 
classes of city and country. That is just what invested 
the revolutions to a lesser or greater degree with a national 
character, that is, one embracing the whole people. 

The theoretical as well as the political dispute among us 
was not over the collaboration of the worker and peasant as 
such, but over the program of this collaboration, its party 
forms and political methods. In the old revolutions, 
workers and peasants "collaborated" under the leadership 
of the liberal bourgeoisie or its petty bourgeois democratic 
wing. The Communist International repeated the experi- 
ment of the old revolutions in a new historical situation by 
doing everything it could to subject the Chinese workers 
and peasants to the political leadership of the national 
liberal Chiang Kai-Shek and later, of the "democrat" Wang 
Chin Wei. Lenin put the question of an alliance of the 
workers and peasants in irreconcilable antagonism to the 
liberal bourgeoisie. Such an alliance had never existed in 
history before. It was a matter, so far as its method went, 
of a new experiment in the collaboration of the oppressed 
class of city and village. By this, the question of the 
political forms of the collaboration was posed for the first 
time. Radek has simply overlooked this. This is why 
he leads us back not only from the formula of the perma- 
nent revolution, but also from Lenin's "democratic 
dictatorship" into the vacuum of historical abstractions. 
Yes, Lenin refused for a number of years to answer in 
advance the question of what the political party 
and state organization of the democratic dictator- 
ship of the proletariat and the peasantry would 
look like and he pushed into the foreground the 
collaboration of these two classes in contrast to the coali- 

71 



' PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

tion with the liberal bourgeoisie. Lenin said : At a certain 
historical stage, there inevitably results from the whole 
objective situation the revolutionary alliance of the .work- 
ing class with the peasantry for the solution of the tasks of 
the democratic revolution. Whether the peasantry 
will have time enough or will understand how to 
create a party of its own, whether this party 
will be the specific . gravity of the representatives of the 
proletariat in the revolutionary government all these 
questions permit of no generally valid reply. "Experience 
will show!" Even though the formula of the democratic 
dictatorship left open the question of the political mecha- 
nics of the alliance of the workers and peasants, it never- 
theless remained, up to a certain period, without being 
converted into a naked abstraction like Radek's, an 
algebraic formula which allowed of greatly divergent 
political constructions for the future. 

Lenin himself was in no way of the opinion that the 
question would be exhausted by the class basis of the 
dictatorship and its objective historical aim. The signi- 
ficance of the subj'ective factors : of the aim, the conscious 
method, the party Lenin well understood and taught all 
this to us. And that is why Lenin, in his commentaries 
to his slogan, did not renounce even a hypothetical reply 
to the question : what political forms might be assumed 
by the first independent alliance of workers and peasants 
in history. However, Lenin took up the question different- 
ly at different times. Lenin's ideas must not be regarded 
dogmatically. Lenin brought no finished comments 
from Sinai, but forged ideas and slogans in the furnace of 
the class struggle. He adapted these slogans to reality, 
making them concrete and precise, and at different time? 
filled them with different content. But this side of the ques- 
tion, which later gained a decisive character, and brought 
the Bolshevik party right to the verge of a split at the 
beginning of 1917, has not been studied by Radek; he 
simply ignored it. 

72 



CLASSES, TASKS & POLITICAL MECHANICS 

It is, however, a fact that Lenin did not always charac- 
terize the probable party-political expression arid govern- 
mental form of the alliance of the two classes in the same 
way and that he refrained from binding the party by 
hypothetical interpretations. What are the reasons for 
such caution? The reasons are to be sought in the fact 
that one element of this algebraic formula is represented by 
a quantity, gigantic in significance, but politically 
extremely indefinite : the peasantry. 

I want to quote only a few examples of Lenin's interpre- 
tation of the democratic dictatorship, observing, however, 
that a cohesive characterization of the evolution of Lenin *sf 
idea in this question would require a separate work. 

Developing the thought that the proletariat and the 
peasantry would be the basis of the dictatorship, Lenin 
wrote in March 1905 : 

"And this composition of the social basis of the probable 
and desirable revolutionary dictatorship will naturally 
also be expressed in the composition of the revolutionary 
government, it will render inevitable the participation of 
the most varied representatives of the revolutionary demo- 
cracy in this government and even their predominance." 
(Volume VI, Russian edition, page 132. My emphasis.) 

In these words, Lenin shows not only the class basis 
but also a definite governmental form of the dictatorship 
with a possible predominance of the representatives of the 
pretty bourgeois democracy. 

In 1907, Lenin wrote : 

"The peasant agrarian revolution of which you speak, 
gentlemen, must, in order to triumph as such, as a peasant 
revolution, become the central power of the whole state." 
(Volume IX, page 539.) 

This formula goes even further. It can be understood 
in the sense that the revolutionary power must be directly 
concentrated in the hands of the peasantry. This 
formula, however, also embraces, in the more far- 
reaching interpretation accorded it by the passage 

78 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

of developments, the October revolution which 
brought the proletariat to power as the "agent" 
of the peasant revolution. These are the extreme poles of 
the permissible interpretations of the formula of the demo* 
cratic dictatorship of the proletariat and the peasantry. 
It is probable that up to a certain point its strength lay 
in this algebraic instability, but its dangers also lay there, 
manifested themselves among us crassly enough in Febru- 
ary and led to the catastrophe in China. 

In July 1905, Lenin wrote : 

"Nobody speaks of the seizure of power by the party 
we speak only of participation, as leading a participation 
in the revolution as possible. . . ." (Volume VI, page 228.) 

In December 1906, Lenin considered it possible to agree 
with Kautsky in the question of the seizure of power by 
the party : 

"Kautsky considers it not only 'as very probable' that 
Victory will fall to the social democratic party in the 
course of the revolution,' but declares it the duty of the 
social democrats 'to suggest the certainty of victory to 
their adherents, for one cannot fight successfully if victory 
is renounced beforehand.' " (Volume VIII, page 58.) 

The distance between these two interpretations given by 
Lenin himself is no smaller than between Lenin's formula- 
tions and mine. We will see this even more plainly later 
on. Here we want to raise the question : What is the 
meaning of these contradictions in Lenin ? They reflect the 
same great unknown in the political formula of the revolu- 
tion : the peasantry. Not for nothing did the radicals once 
<call the peasant the Sphinx of Russian history. The ques- 
tion of the nature of the revolutionary dictatorship whether 
Radek wills it or not is inseparable from the question of 
the possibility of a revolutionary peasant party hostile to 
the liberal bourgeoisie and independent of the proletariat. 
Were the peasantry capable of creating an independent 
party in the epoch of the democratic revolution then the 
democratic revolution could be realized in its truest and 

74 



CLASSES, TASKS & POLITICAL MECHANICS 

most direct sense, and the question of the participation of 
the proletarian minority would obtain an important, it is 
true, but subordinated significance. The matter presents 
itself quite differently if one proceeds from the fact that 
the peasantry, because of its hybrid class character and the 
lack of uniformity of its social composition, can have 
neither an independent policy nor an independent party, 
and is compelled, in the revolutionary epoch, to choose 
between the policy of the bourgeoisie and the policy of the 
proletariat. Only this evaluation of the political nature 
of the peasantry produces the perspective of the 
dictatorship of the proletariat which grows directly 
out of the democratic revolution. In this, naturally, there 
lies no "denial", "ignoring" or "underestimation" of the 
peasantry. Without the decisive significance of the agra- 
rian question for the life of all society and without the 
deep and gigantic impulsion of the peasant revolution there 
could in general be no talk about the proletarian dictator- 
ship in Russia. But the fact that the agrarian revolution 
created the conditions for the dictatorship of the proletariat 
grew out of the inability of the peasantry to solve its own 
historical problem with its own resources and under its own 
leadership. Under present conditions in bourgeois coun- 
tries, even in the backward ones, in so far as they have 
already entered the epoch of capitalist industry and are 
bound into a unit by railroads and telegraphs this refers 
not only to Russia, but to China and India as well the 
peasantry is still less capable of a leading or even only an 
independent political role than in the epoch of the old 
bourgeois revolutions. Because I constantly and persist- 
ently underlined this idea, which forms one of the most 
important constituents of the theory of the permanent 
revolution, was a completely insufficient and, in essence, 
quite unfounded reason for accusing me of an underestima- 
tion of the peasantry. 

How does Lenin stand on the question of a peasant party ? 
To reply to this question, a special article would have to 

75 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

be devoted to the transformation of Lenin's views on the 
Russian revolution in the period of 1905-1917. Let us con- 
fine ourselves here to two quotations. 

In 1907, Lenin wrote : 

"It is possible. . . that the objective difficulties of 
a unification of the petty bourgeoisie will check the forma- 
tion of such a party and leave the peasant democracy for 
a long time in the present state of a spongy, shapeless, 
pulpy, Trudovik-like "mass." (Volume VIII, page 494.) 
In 1909, Lenin expressed himself on the same theme 
as follows : 

"There is not the slightest doubt that a revolution which 
reaches so high a degree of development as the revolu- 
tionary dictatorship, will create a more firmly formed and 
more powerful revolutionary peasant party. To judge the 
matter otherwise would mean to assume that in a grown- 
up man, the size, form and degree of development of cer- 
tain essential organs could remain in an embryonic state." 
(Volume X7, Part 1, page 230). 

Was this assumption confirmed ? No, it was not. But 
that is just what induced Lenin, up to the moment 
of the complete historical verification, to give only a con- 
ditioned reply to the question of the revolutionary power. 
It is self-understood that Lenin did not put his hypotheti- 
cal formula above the reality. The struggle for the inde- 
pendent political party of the proletariat constituted the 
main content of his life. The woeful epigones, however, 
in the hunt after a peasants' party, landed at the subordi- 
nation of the Chinese workers to the Kuo Min Tang, at 
the strangulation of Communism in India in the name of 
the "Workers' and Peasants' Party", at the dangerous 
fiction of the Peasant's International, at the masquerade of 
the Anti-Imperialist League, and so on. 

Prevailing thought at present makes no effort to dwell 
on the contradictions in Lenin adduced above, which exist 
in part externally and in appearance, in part also in 
Reality, but which always result from the problem itself. 

76 



CLASSES, TASKS & POLITICAL MECHANICS 

Ever since we have had a special species of "Red" profes- 
sors, who are frequently distinguished from the old reac- 
tionary professors not by a firmer backbone but by a 
profounder illiteracy, Lenin is now professorially trimmed 
and purged of all contradictions, that is, of the dynamics 
of his thought; standard quotations are threaded on a 
few thin strings, and then, according to the requirements 
of the "given moment", set in circulation serially. 

It must not be forgotten for a moment that the problems 
of the revolution in a politically "virgin" country became 
acute after a great historical interval, after a lengthy re- 
actionary epoch in Europe and in the whole world, and by 
that alone already brought with them much that was 
obscure. In the formula "democratic dictatorship of the 
workers and peasants", Lenin gave expression to the spe- 
cific social relationships in Russia. He put different con- 
structions upon this formula, but never rejected it without 
having exhaustively measured the peculiarity in the condi- 
tions of the Russian revolution. Wherein lay this 
peculiarity ? 

The gigantic role of the agrarian question and the 
peasant question in general, as the basis or substructure 
of all other problems, and the great number of the peasant 
intelligenzia and those who sympathized with the peasant, 
with their populist ideology, the "anti-capitalist" traditions 
and the revolutionary tempering all this in its entirety 
signified that if an anti-bourgeois revolutionary peasant 
party was at all possible anywhere, then it was precisely 
and primarily in Russia. 

And as a matter of fact, out of the endeavor to create 
a peasant, or a worker and peasant in distinction from 
a liberal and proletarian party, every possible variation 
was attempted, illegal and parliamentary as 
combination : Zemlia i Volia (Land and 
naia Volia (People's Will), Tchorny 
construction), the legal Narodnitc 
^'People's Socialists", Trudoviks, 






PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

" Left Social Revolutionists ", etc., etc. For half a cen- 
tury, we had, as it were, a huge laboratory for the creation 
of an " anti-capitalist " peasant party with an indepen- 
dent position towards the proletarian part. The largest 
size, as is known, was attained by the experiment of the 
S. R. party, which, for a time in 1917, actually constituted 
the party of the overwhelming majority of the peasantry. 
And then ? It used its position only to betray the peasants 
completely to the liberal bourgeoisie. The S. R.s entered 
a coalition with the imperialists of the Entente and together 
with them conducted an armed struggle against the Russian 
proletariat. 

This truly classic example shows that petty bourgeois 
parties on a peasant basis, even in everyday history, can 
maintain the appearance of an independent policy when 
secondary questions are on the agenda, but that when 
the revolutionary crisis of society puts the fundamental 
questions of property on the order of the day, the petty 
bourgeois " peasant " party automatically becomes an 
instrument of the bourgeoisie against the proletariat. 

If my old differences of opinion with Lenin are consi- 
dered not from the cross-section of quotations torn out 
of this and that year, month and day, but in their correct 
historical perspective, then it becomes quite clear that the 
dispute, at least on my part, was not over whether democ- 
ratic tasks stand before Russia which require a revolu- 
tionary solution; not over whether an alliance of the pro- 
letariat with the peasants is required for the solution of 
these tasks, but over what party-political and state form 
the revolutionary cooperation of the proletariat and the 
peasantry could assume, and what consequences result from 
it for the further development of the revolution. I speak 
of course of my position in this dispute, not of the position 
of Bucharin-Radek of that time, for which they themselves 
must answer. 

How close the formula of the " permanent revolution '* 
approached Lenin's formula is graphically illustrated by 

78 



CLASSES, TASKS & POLITICAL MECHANICS 

the following comparison. In 1905, that is, before the 
October strike and before the December uprising in Moscow, 
I wrote in the foreword to one of Lassalle's speeches : 

"It is self-understood that the proletariat, as in its 
time the bourgeoisie, fulfills its mission supported upon 
the peasantry and the petty bourgeoisie. The proletariat 
leads the village, draws it into the movement, interests it 
in the success of its plans. The proletariat, however, 
absolutely remains the leader. This is not the ' dictator- 
ship of the ' peasantry and proletariat' but the dictator- 
ship of the proletariat supported by the peasantry* " 
(L. Trotsky, 1905, page 281.) 

Now compare these words, written in 1905, and quoted 
by me in the Polish article of 1909, with the following 
words of Lenin, written in 1909, right after the party 
conference, under the pressure of Rosa Luxemburg, had 
adopted the formula " dictatorship of the proletariat 
supported by the peasantry" instead of the old Bolshevik 
formula. To the Mensheviks, who spoke of the radical 
change of Lenin's position, he replied : 

"... The formula which the Bolsheviks have chosen 
for themselves here reads : * the proletariat which leads the 
peasantry 9 . 

" . . . Is it not obvious that the idea of all these formu- 
lations is the same? That this idea expresses precisely 
the dictatorship of the proletariat and peasantry, that the 
6 formula ' proletariat supported by the peasantry 
remains entirely within the bounds of that very dictatorship 
of the proletariat and peasantry}" 9 (Volume XI, Part 1, 
pages 219 and #. My emphasis.) 

Thus Lenin puts a construction on the " algebraic " 
formula here which excludes the idea of an independent 
peasant party and even more of its dominant r61e in the 
revolutionary government : the proletariat leads the 
peasantry, the proletariat is supported by the peasantry, 
consequently the revolutionary power is concentrated into 
the hands of the party of the proletariat. But that; is 

79 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

just what the central point of the permanent revolution 
consisted of* 

The utmost that can be said today, that is, after the 
historical verification of the old differences of opinion on 
the question of the dictatorship, is the following: while 
Lenin, always proceeding from the leading r&le of the 
proletariat, emphasizes in every way, clears up and teaches 
us the necessity of the revolutionary collaboration of the 
workers and peasants, I, likewise always proceeding from 
this collaboration, emphasize in every way the necessity 
of proletarian leadership, not only in the bloc but also in 
the government which will be assembled to incorporate this 
bloc. No other difference can be read into the matter. 



In connection with what has been adduced above, we 
would like to examine two quotations : one out of Results 
and Perspectives, which Stalin and Zinoviev utilized to 
prove the antagonism between my views and Lenin's, the 
other out of a polemical article by Lenin against ne, 
which Radek employs for the same purpose. 

Here is the first question : 

" The participation of the proletariat in the government 
is objectively most probable and admissible in principle 
only as a dominant and leading participation. Naturally, 
this government can be called the dictatorship of the 
proletariat and peasantry, dictatorship of the proletariat, 
peasantry and intelligenzia, or finally, coalition govern- 
ment of the working class and the petty bourgeoisie. But 
the question still remains : to whom does the hegemony 
belong in the government, and through it, in the country ? 
If we speak of a labor government, then by that alone we 
already answer that the hegemony will belong to the work- 
ing class." (Our Revolution, 1906 , page 250.) 

Zinoviev (in 1925) beat the drums mightily because (in 
1905!) I had juxtaposed the peasantry and the intelli- 

80 



CLASSES, TASKS & POLITICAL MECHANICS 

genzia; the Mensheviks, as I wrote at that time, clutched 
at the heels of every radical intellectual in order to prove 
over and over again the blossoming of bourgeois democ- 
racy. I expressed myself hundreds of times in those days 
on the impotence of the intellectuals as an "independent " 
social group and on the decisive significance of the revolu- 
tionary peasantry. Moreover, it is certainly not a ques- 
tion of a single polemical sentence which I have no 
intention at all of defending. The heart of the quotation 
consists of the fact that I completely accept the Leninist 
content of the democratic dictatorship and only demand 
a more precise definition of its political mechanism, that is, 
the rejection of a coalition in which the proletariat would 
only be a hostage under a petty bourgeois majority. 

Now let us examine Lenin's 1906 article which, as Radek 
himself remarks, was directed " formally against Trotsky, 
but in reality against Bucharin, Piatakov, the writer of 
these lines (that is, Radek) and a number of other com- 
rades." This is a very valuable affirmation which entirely 
confirms my impression of that time that Lenin was 
directing the polemic against me only in appearance, for 
the contents, as I shall demonstrate forthwith, did not 
in reality at all refer to me. The article contains (in two 
lines) that very accusation concerning my alleged " nega- 
tion of the peasantry " which later became the main ser- 
mon of the epigones and their disciples. The " nail" of 
this article as Radek expresses it is the following 
passage : 

" Trotsky has not taken into consideration," says 
Lenin, quoting my words, " that this is just what the 
completion of the * national bourgeois revolution ' in 
Russia will be when the proletariat pulls along the non- 
proletarian masses of the village to the confiscation of the 
manorial land, and overthrows the monarchy, that this is 
just what the revolutionary democratic dictatorship of the 
proletariat and the peasantry will be." (Lenin, Volume 
-Y777, page J.) 

81 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

That Lenin did not turn to the "right address" with 
the accusation of the "negation" of the peasantry, but 
really meant Bucharin and Radek, who actually wanted to 
skip over the democratic stage of the revolution, is clear 
not only from everything that has been said above, but also 
from the quotation adduced by Radek himself, which he 
rightly calls the "nail" of Lenin's article. In actuality, 
Lenin refers directly to the words of my article, according 
to which only an independent and bold policy of the prole- 
tariat can pull along the "non-proletarian" masses of the 
village to the confiscation of the manorial Iand 9 to the over- 
throw of the monarchy 9 etc., and Lenin adds: "Trotsky 
has not taken into consideration that . . . this is just what 
the revolutionary democratic dictatorship will be." In 
other words, Lenin confirms here and, so to speak, certi- 
fies that Trotsky in reality accepts the whole genuine con- 
tent of the Bolshevik formula (the collaboration of the 
workers and the peasants and the democratic tasks of this 
collaboration), but does not want to acknowledge that this 
is just what the democratic dictatorship, the completion of 
the national revolution, will be. In this manner, the dis- 
pute in the apparently "sharp" polemical article is not con- 
cerned with the program of the next stage of the revolu- 
tion and its motive class forces, but precisely with the poli- 
tical relationship of these forces to each other, with the 
political and party organizational character of the dictator- 
ship. If, as a result of the unclarity of the process itself 
on the one hand, and of factional exaggeration on the 
other, polemical misunderstandings were comprehensible 
and unavoidable in those days, it is completely incompre- 
hensible how Radek was able subsequently to introduce 
such confusion into the question. 

My polemic with Lenin was concerned in essence with 
the possibility of the independence (and the degree of in- 
dependence) of the peasantry in the revolution, as well as 
with the possibility of an independent peasants' party. In 
this polemic, I accused Lenin of overestimating the inde- 

82 



CLASSES, TASKS & POLITICAL MECHANICS 

pendent r61e of the peasantry. Lenin accused me of 
underestimating the revolutionary r&le of the peasantry* 
This resulted from the logic of the polemic itself. What 
but contempt, however, does one deserve who today, two 
decades later, tears these old quotations out of the founda- 
tion of the then party relationships, endows every polemi- 
cal exaggeration and every episodic error with an absolute 
value, instead of revealing in the light of the greatest re- 
volutionary experience what the actual kernel of the diffe- 
rences of opinion was and what the relations looked like, 
not on paper, but in reality. 

Compelled to limit myself in the selection of quota- 
tions, I want to point here only to the comprehensive theses 
of Lenin on the stages of the revolution, which were written 
at the end of 1905, and only published for the first time in 
1926 in the fifth volume of his selected works (page 451). 
Let us recall the fact that all the Oppositionists, Radek in- 
cluded, regarded the publication of these theses as the 
handsomest gift to the Opposition, for Lenin shows him- 
self guilty of "Trotskyism" in it. The most important 
points of the resolution of the Seventh Plenum of the 
E. C. C. I. which condemns Trotskyism, appear, as it were, 
to be deliberately directed against the fundamental theses 
of Lenin. The Stalinists gnashed their teeth in rage at 
their publication. The editor of the Collection, Kamenev, 
admitted to me openly with the not very modest "kind- 
heartedness" that characterizes him : If the bloc between 
us were not being prepared, he would never under any 
circumstances have allowed the publication of the docu- 
ment. In an article of Kostrcheva in Bolshevik, these 
theses are mendaciously falsified precisely for the purpose 
of not bringing Lenin under the suspicion of the 
"Trotskyist" attitude towards the peasantry as a whole 
and the middle peasants in particular. 

I quote here further Lenin's evaluation of his differen- 
ces of opinion with me, which he presented in 1909 : 

"Comrade Trotsky himself, in this instance, grants 

v 88 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

*the participation of the representatives of the democratic 
population' in the 'workers' government', that is, he grants 
a government of representatives of the proletariat and thft 
peasantry. Under what conditions the participation of the 
proletariat in the government of the revolution is permis- 
sible remains a separate question, and in this question, 
the Bolsheviks will most likely not come to an agreement 
not only with Trotsky, but also with the Polish social de- 
mocracy. The question of the dictatorship of the revolu- 
tionary classes, however, is in no case reduced to the ques- 
tion of the 'majority' in any revolutionary government, but 
to the question of the conditions under which the participa- 
tion of the social democracy in any government is permis- 
sible." (Volume XI, Part 1, page 229. My emphasis. 
L. T.) 

In this quotation from Lenin, it is again confirmed that 
Trotsky accepts a government of representatives of the 
proletariat and the peasantry, that is, does not "skip over" 
the latter. Lenin emphasizes in this connection that the 
question of the dictatorship is not reduced to the question 
of the majority in the government. This is incontestable. 
It is a question, in the first place, of the common work of 
the proletariat and peasantry and consequently of the 
struggle of the proletarian vanguard against the liberal or 
* 'national" bourgeoisie for the influence over the peasants. 
But if the question of the revolutionary dictatorship of the 
workers and peasants is also not reduced to the question 
of the majority in the government, it nevertheless inevi- 
tably leads, upon the victory of the revolution, to this 
question as the decisive one. As we have seen, Lenin (in 
any case) cautiously makes the reservation : Should the 
question arise about the participation of the party in a re- 
volutionary government, then we will probably have . a 
different opinion from Trotsky as well as from the Polish 
comrades over the conditions of this participation. It was 
a matter therefore of probable differences of opinion, in 
so far as Lenin considered theoretically permissible the 

84 



CLASSES, TASKS & POLITICAL MECHANICS 

participation of the representatives of the proletariat as a 
minority in the democratic government. Events, however, 
showed that we were not of different opinions. In Nov- 
ember 1917, a struggle raged in the summits of the party 
around the question of- the coalition government with the 
Social Revolutionists and the Mensheviks. Lenin was not 
opposed in principle to a coalition on the basis of the 
Soviets, but he categorically demanded a firm safeguarding 
of the Bolshevik majority. I went along with him hand in 
hand. 



Now let us see what Radek is actually aiming at with 
the whole question of the democratic dictatorship of the 
proletariat and the peasantry : 

"Wherein", he asks, "did the old Bolshevik theory of 
1905 prove to be fundamentally correct? In the fact that 
the joint action of the Petrograd workers and peasants 
(the soldiers of the Petrograd garrison) overthrew czarism 
(in 1917. L. T.). The formula of 1905 foresees in its fun- 
damentals only the relationship of the classes, and not a 
concrete political institution.' 5 

Well, well, well ! When I designate the old Leninist 
formula as "algebraic", that is, permitting of various con- 
crete interpretations, it is in no case for the purpose of 
permitting it to be converted into an empty commonplace, 
as Radek does unhesitatingly. "The fundamental point 
was realized : the proletariat and the peasantry jointly 
overthrew czarism." But this "fundamental" was accom- 
plished without exception in every victorious or semi- 
victorious revolution. Czars, feudal lords, and priests were 
always and everywhere beaten with the fists of the proleta- 
rian, or the precursors of the proletarian, the plebeian and 
peasant. That is how it was already in the sixteenth 
century in Germany and even earlier. In China it was also 
workers and peasants who beat the militarists. What has 

85 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

this to do with the democratic dictatorship? It did not 
exist in the old revolutions, nor in China. Why not ? On 
the backs of the workers and peasants, who did the dirty 
work of the revolution, sat the bourgeoisie. Radek has' 
"strayed" so far from political institutions that he has for- 
gotten what is "most fundamental" in the revolution : who 
leads and who seizes power? A revolution, however, is a 
struggle for power. It is a political struggle which the 
classes conduct not with empty hands but with the aid of 
the "political institutions" (party, etc.). 

"People who have not thought out to the end the com- 
plexity of the method of Marxism and Leninism", Radek 
thunders against us sinners, "understand it this way : the 
affair must absolutely end with a joint government of the 
workers and peasants, yes, a few even imagined that it 
absolutely had to be a coalition government of the workers* 
and peasants' parties." 

What blockheads these "few" are! . . . And what 
does Radek himself imagine ? That a victorious revolution 
must not lead to a new government, or that this new gov- 
ernment must not reflect and insure a definite relationship 
of forces of the revolutionary classes ? Radek has deepen- 
ed the "sociological" in such a way that nothing has been 
left of it but a shell of words. 

How impermissible it is to digress from the question 
of the political forms of the collaboration of the workers 
and peasants, will best be shown to us by the words of one 
of Radek 's lectures in the Communist Academy in March 
1927: 

"A year ago, I wrote an article in Pravda on this 
(Canton) government which I named peasants 9 and 
workers 9 government. The comrades of the editorial 
board, however, assumed that it was an oversight on my 
part and corrected it : workers 9 and peasants 9 government. 
I did not protest against this and let it stand : workers' and 
peasants' government." 

Thus, in 1927 (not in 1905) Radek was of the opinion 

86 



CLASSES, TASKS & POLITICAL MECHANICS 

that there could be a peasants' and workers' government 
in distinction to a workers 9 and peasants' government. 
The editor of Pravda did not grasp this. I admit, neither 
do I. What a workers' and peasants' government is, we 
know. But what is a peasants' and workers' government, 
in distinction and in contrast to a workers' and peasants' 
government ? Perhaps you will take the time to explain to 
us this mysterious transposition of adjectives? Here we 
are approaching the heart of the question. In 1926, Radek 
believed the Canton government of Chiang Kai-Shek to be 
a peasants' and workers' government, in 1927 he repeated 
it with determination. In reality, however, it proved to 
be a bourgeois government, which only exploited for itself 
the revolutionary struggle of the workers and peasants, 
and then drowned them in blood. How is this error to be 
explained ? Did Radek simply deceive himself ? One can 
be deceived at a distance. But then one must say : I 
did not understand it, did not scrutinize it, I made a mis- 
take. But no, we have here no error in fact out of the 
lack of information, but rather, as now appears clear a 
deep mistake in principle. The peasants' and workers' 
government in contrast to the workers' and peasants' gov- 
ernment that is the Kuo Min Tang. It can mean 
nothing else. When the peasantry does not follow the pro- 
letariat, it follows the bourgeoisie. I believe the question 
has been sufficiently clarified in my criticism of the Stali- 
nist idea of "temporarily constituted workers' and peasants* 
parties" (see The Draft Program of the Comintern, A Cri- 
tictsm o/ Fundamentals). The Canton '"peasants" and 
workers' government in distinction from a workers' 
and peasants' government is, in the language of present-day 
Chinese politics, the only conceivable expression of the 
"democratic dictatorship" in contrast to the proletarian 
dictatorship, in other words, the embodiment of the Stali- 
nist Kuo Min Tang policy in contrast to the Bolshevik 
policy which the Communist International calls "Trot- 
skyist". 

87 



CHAPTER FOUR 



WHAT DID THE THEORY OF THE 

PERMANENT REVOLUTION LOOK 

LIKE IN PRACTISE? 



IN CRITICIZING the theory, Radek supplements it, 
as we have seen, by the "tactics flowing from it". 
This is a very important supplement. The official criticism 
of "Trotskyism" prudently limited itself in this question 
to the theory. For Radek, however, this does not suffice. 
He is conducting a struggle against a definite (Bolshevik) 
tactical line in China. He must discredit this fine by the 
theory of the permanent revolution, and here it is neces- 
sary to show, or to act as though somebody has already 
showed, that in the past the false tactical line flowed from 
this theory. Here Radek is directly misleading his readers. 
It is possible that he himself does not know the history 
of the revolution, in which he never took a direct part. 
Rut obviously he has also not made the slightest effort to 
investigate the question with documents at hand. The 
most important of these are contained in the second 
volume* of my Collected Works : an investigation is thus 
possible for anybody who can read. 

Let us therefore reveal to Radek : in almost all the 
stages of the first revolution there existed between Lenin 
and me a complete agreement in the estimation of the 
forces of the revolution and its actual tasks, in spite of the 
fact that I spent the whole of 1905 illegally in Russia and 
1906 in prison. I am compelled to confine myself here to 
a minimum number of proofs and illustrations. 

88 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION IN PRACTISE 

In an article written in February and printed in March, 
that is two or three months before the first Bolsheivk con- 
vention (which passed into history as the third convention), 
I said : 

"The bitterest struggle between the people and the 
czar, which knows no other thought than victory; the 
popular insurrection as the culminating point of this 
struggle; the provisional government as the revolutionary 
culmination of. the victory of the people over the centuries 
old foe ; the disarming of the czarist reaction and the arm- 
ing of the people by the provisional government; the con- 
vocation of the constituent assembly on the basis of 
general, equal, direct and secret suffrage these are the ob- 
jectively prescribed stages of the revolution." (Volume II, 
Part I page 232.) 

It is enough to compare these words with the resolu- 
tions of the Bolshevik convention of May 1905 in order to 
recognize in the posing of the fundamental tactical pro- 
blems my complete solidarity with the Bolsheviks. 

Even more, in the spirit of this article, I formulated 
in Petersburg, in agreement with Krassin, the theses on 
the provisional government which appeared illegally at 
that time. Krassin defended them at the Bolshevik con- 
vention. Lenin consented to them in the following form : 

"By and large, I share the opinion of comrade Krassin. 
It is natural that, as a writer, I took into account the 
literary side of the question. The importance of the aim 
of the struggle is very correctly presented by comrade 
Krassin and I am with him completely. One cannot en- 
gage in struggle without reckoning on capturing the posi- 
tion for which one is fighting. ..." (Volume VI, 
page 180.) 

The largest part of the extensive Krassin amendments, 
to which I refer the reader, was adopted in the resolution 
of the convention. That these amendments are derived 
from me, is proved by a note from Krassin which I still 
possess. This whole party episode is well known to 

89 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

Kamenev and others. 

The problems of the peasantry, their attraction to the 
workers' Soviets, the question of the co-operation with the 
peasants 9 league, engaged the attention of the Peterburg 
Soviet more and more every day. Perhaps Radek still 
knows that the direction of the Soviets devolved upon me. 
Here is one of the hundreds of formulations written by me 
at that time on the tactical tasks of the revolution : 

"The proletariat creates city "Soviets' which direct the 
fighting actions of the urban masses, and puts upon the 
order of the day the fighting alliance with the army and 
the peasantry." (Natchalo, No. |, 17-30, November 
1905.) 

It is wearisome and, I must admit, painful, to adduce 
quotations which are to prove that there was no question 
with me of a "leap" out of autocracy to socialism. But T 
am compelled to do it. I wrote the following, for 
example, in February 1906 on the tasks of the constituent 
assembly, in no case, however, counterposing it at the very 
outset to the Soviets, as Radek, following Stalin, now 
hastens to do in regard to China in order to wipe out the 
opportunist traces of yesterday with an ultra-Leftist 
broom: 

"The constituent assembly will be convoked by the 
liberated people by its own power. The tasks of the cons- 
tituent assembly will be gigantic. It will have to recons- 
truct the state upon a democratic foundation, that is, 
upon the foundation of the sovereign people's power. It 
will establish a people's militia, carry out an enormous land 
reform, and introduce the eight-hour day and a progressive 
income tax." (Volume //, Part /, page 3J^9.) 

And now, especially on the question of the "imme- 
diate" introduction of socialism, from the popular leaflet 
written by me in 1905 : 

"Is it possible to introduce socialism in Russia im- 
mediately? No, our village is still too dark and too un- 
enlightened. There are too few real socialists among the 

90 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION IN PRACTISE 

peasants. First and foremost, the autocracy, which keeps 
the masses of the people in darkness, must be overthrown. 
The village poor must be freed of all taxation ; the progres- 
sive income tax, universal compulsory education must be 
introduced; finally, the land proletariat and semi-proleta- 
riat must be united with the city proletariat into a social 
democratic army. Only such an army will be in a position 
to carry through the great socialist revolution." (Volume 
11, Part 7, page 828.) 

This almost sounds as though I did indeed differentiate 
between the democratic and socialist stages of the revolu- 
tion, long before even Stalin and Thalmann, and now 
Radek too, began to teach me this. 
Twenty-two years ago, I wrote : 

"When the idea of the uninterrupted revolution was 
formulated in the socialist press, a revolution which 
through growing social clashes, uprisings of ever new sec- 
tions of the people, incessant attacks of the proletariat 
upon the political and economic privileges of the ruling 
classes combines the liquidation of absolutism and serfdom 
with the socialist revolution, our 'progressive' pres$ unani- 
mously raised a furious howl." (Our Revolution, 1906, 
page 258.) 

First of all, I should like to call attention to the defini- 
tion of the uninterrupted revolution contained in these 
words : it combines the liquidation 'of the Middle Ages with 
the socialist revolution through a series of growing social 
clashes. Where is the leap here ? Where is the ignoring of 
the democratic stage ? And isn't this what actually hap- 
pened in 1917? 

Let us establish in passing that the howling of the "pro- 
gressive" press of 1905 over the uninterrupted revolution 
can stand no comparison with the in no way progressive 
howling of the present-day writers who have intervened in 
the affair after a brief delay of a quarter of a century. 

What was the attitude of the then leading organ of the 
Bolshevik faction, Novaia Zhizn, which appeared under 

91 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

the vigilant editorship of Lenin, to the question of the 
permanent revolution raised by me in the press? Surely, 
the question is not devoid of interest. To the article of 
the "radical" bourgeois journal, Nasha Zhizn, which had 
endeavored to set up the "more rational" views of Lenin 
against the "permanent revolution" of Trotsky, the Bol- 
shevik Novaia Zhizn replied (on November 27, 1905) : 

"This gratuitous report is of course sheer nonsense. Com- 
rade Trotsky said that the proletarian revolution, without 
standing still at the first stage, by pressing hard upon the 
exploiters, can continue on its road, .while Lenin pointed 
out that the political revolution is only the first step. The 
publicist of Nasha Zhizn would like to perceive a contra- 
diction there... The whole misunderstanding comes, first, 
from the fear with which the name alone of the social re- 
volution fills Nasha Zhizn, secondly, out of the desire of 
this paper to discover some sort of a sharp and piquant 
difference of opinion among the social democrats, and 
thirdly, in the metaphorical expression of comrade Trotsky : 
'at one fell swoop 9 . In No. 10 of Nathshalo, com- 
rade Trotsky explains his ideas quite unequivocally : 

" 'The complete victory of the revolution signifies the 
victory of the proletariat', writes comrade Trotsky. 'But 
this victory in turn signifies, the further uninterruptedness 
of the revolution. The proletariat realizes the fundamen- 
tal tasks of democracy and the logic of its immediate 
struggle for the safeguarding of political domination cau- 
ses purely socialist problems to arise at the given moment. 
Between the minimum and the maximum program of the 
social democracy, a revolutionary continuity is establish- 
ed. This is not one "blow", it is not one day and not a 
month, it is a whole historical epoch. It would be absurd 
to want to determine its duration in advance.' " 

This reference alone exhatists, to a certain degree, the 
theme of this brochure. Could all the subsequent criticism 
of the epigones be pushed aside in advance more clearly, 
more surely than was done in those of my newspaper arti- 

92 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION IN PRACTISE 

cles which Lenin's Novaia Zhizn quoted so approvingly ? 
My article set forth that the victorious proletariat, in the 
process of the realization of the democratic tasks, would 
inevitably be confronted at a certain stage, by the logic 
of its position, by purely socialist problems. That is Just 
where the continuity lies between the minimum and maxi- 
mum programs, which grows inevitably out of the dictator- 
ship of the proletariat. This is not a blow, it is not a 
leap I explained to my critics in the camp of the petty 
bourgeoisie of that time it is a whole historical epoch. 
And Lenin's Novaia Zhizn associated itself completely 
with this perspective. Even more important, I hope, is the 
fact that the actual course of development tested it and in 
1917 finally confirmed it as correct. 

Outside of the petty bourgeois democrats of Nasfea 
Zhizn, it was mainly the Mensheviks who, in 1905 and 
particularly in 1906, after the defeat of the revolution had 
begun, spoke of the fantastic "leap" over democracy to 
socialism. Among the Mensheviks, it was especially Mar- 
tinov and the deceased Jordansky who distinguished 
themselves in this field. Both of them, be it said in pas- 
sing, later became stalwart Stalinists. To the Menshevik 
writers who sought to hang the "leap to socialism" on 
me, I expounded, in a special article written in 1906, in 
detail and popularly, not only the error but also the 
stupidity of such a contention, which I could reprint to- 
day, almost unabridged, against the criticism of the epi- 
gones. But it will perhaps suffice to say that the resume 
of the article reached its culminating point in the follow- 
ing words : 

"I understand quite well as I must needs assure my 
reviewer (Jordansky) that a publicistic leap over a poli- 
tical obstacle is far from signifying its practical surmoun- 
ting." (Volume //, Part /, page 454.) 

Perhaps this will suffice? In case it does not I can 
continue so that my critics, like Radek, will not be able 
to refer to the fact that they did not have "at hand" 

98 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

that over which they pass judgment so cavalierly. 

Our Tactic, the brochure written by me in prison in 
1906 and published immediately by Lenin, is characteriz- 
ed by the following conclusion : 

"The proletariat will be able to support itself upon the 
uprising of the village and, in the cities, the centers of 
political life, it will be in a position to complete the affair 
it was able to begin. Supported by the peasant element 
and leading it, the proletariat will not only deal reaction 
the final triumphant blow, but it will also understand how 
to secure the victory of the revolution." (Volume II, Part 
I, page U8.) 

Does this look like an ignoring of the peasantry? 

In the same brochure, moreover, the following thought 
also is developed : 

"Our tactic, calculated upon the irresistible develop- 
ment of the revolution, must of course not ignore the in- 
evitable or the possible or even only the probable phases 
and stages of the revolutionary movement." (Volume II, 
Part I, page 436.) 

Does this look like a fantastic leap ? 

In the article The Lessons of the First Soviets (1906), 
I depict the perspective of the further development of 
the revolution (or, as happened in reality, of the new re- 
volution) in the following manner: 

"History does not repeat itself and the new Soviet will 
not have to go through once more the events of the fifty 
days (October to December 1905) ; but for that it will be 
able to borrow its program of action completely from 
this period. This program is completely clear. Revolutio- 
nary cooperation with the army, the peasantry, and the 
lowest strata of the city petty bourgeoisie. 'Abolition of 
absolutism. Destruction of its material organization : par- 
tial rebuilding of its formations, partial dissolution of the 
army, destruction of the bureaucratic police apparatus, 
eight-hour day, arming of the population, above all of the 
proletariat. Transformation of the Soviets into organs of 

94 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION IN PRACTISE 

the revolutionary city self-administration. Creation of 
Soviets of peasants' deputies (peasant committees) on the 
land, as organs of the agrarian revolution, organization of 
the elections to the constituent assembly and electoral 
struggle on the basis of a definite labor program of the 
people's representatives." (Volume II, Part II, page 206.) 

Does this look like a skipping of the agrarian revolution, 
or an underestimation of the peasant question as a 
whole? Does this look as though I did not see the demo- 
cratic tasks of the revolution? No, it does not. But what 
then does the political daubing of Radek look like? No- 
thing at all. 

Graciously, but very ambiguously, Radek draws a line 
between my position of 1905, which he distorts, and the 
position of the Mensheviks, without it occurring to him 
that he is himself repeating three-fourths of the Menshe- 
Vik criticism : Even though Trotsky ^employed the same 
method as the Mensheviks, Radek explains jesuitically, 
his aim was nevertheless different. By this subjective des- 
cription, Radek completely discredits his own attitude on 
the question. Lassalle already knew that the aim depends 
upon the method and in the final analysis is conditioned 
by it. He even wrote a drama, as is known, on this theme 
(Franz von Sickingen). But in what lay the similarity of 
my method with that of the Mensheviks ? In the attitude 
towards the peasantry. As evidence, Radek adduces three 
polemical lines out of the 1916 article by Lenin which I 
have already quoted, observing himself, however, in 
passing that here Lenin, although he names Trotsky, was 
in reality polemicizing against Bucharin and against him- 
self, that is, Radek, Besides this quotation from Radek 
which, as we have already seen, is refuted by the whole 
content of Lenin's article, Radek makes reference to 
Trotsky himself. Exposing the emptiness of the Menshevik 
conception, I asked in 1916 in an article : If it is not the 
liberal bourgeoisie that will lead, then who? You, Mens- 
heviks, do not at any rate believe in the independent 

95 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

political role of the peasantry. The Mensheviks had the 
view that it is "impermissible" to "repulse" the liberal bour- 
geoisie for the sake of a dubious and unreliable alliance 
with the peasantry. Thifc was the "method" of the Men- 
sheviks. While mine consisted of pushing the liberal bour- 
geoisie aside and fighting for the leadership of the revolu- 
tionary peasantry. In this fundamental question I had no 
differences with Lenin. 'And when I said to the Menshe- 
viks in the course of the struggle against them: "You 
least of all are prepared to assign a leading role to the 
peasantry", then this was no agreement with the method 
of the Mensheviks, as Radek seeks to insinuate, but rather 
a clear alternative : either the dictatorship of the liberal 
plutocracy or the dictatorship of the proletariat. 

The same, completely correct argument that I made in 
1916 against the Mensheviks, which Radek disloyally tries 
to utilize against me, also, was used by me nine years b- 
fore that, at the London Congress of 1907, when I defend- 
ed the theses of the Bolsheviks on the attitude towards 
the non-proletarian parties. I present here the fundamen- 
tal part of my London speech which, in the first years 
of the revolution, was often reprinted in anthologies and 
textbooks as the expression of the Bolshevik attitude to- 
wards the classes and the parties in the revolution : 

"To the comrades of the Menshevik ranks, their own 
views appear unusually complicated. I have repeatedly 
heard accusations from them that I have over-simplified the 
description of the course of the Russian revolution. Despite 
the external amorphousness, which invests it with that 
complex appearance indeed just because of this amor- 
phousness the views of the Mensheviks may be reduced 
to a very simple schema which should be accessible even 
to the understanding of Mr. Miliukov. 
,. "In the postcript to the recently published book, Ho? 
Did the Elections to the Second State Duma Turn Out 
the ideological leader of the Cadet party writes: 'As to 
the Left groups in the narrower sense of the word, that 

96 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION IN PRACTISE 

is, the socialist and revolutionary groups, an agreement 
with them will be more difficult. But even here, again, 
there are, if not decidedly positive, then at least very 
weighty negative reasons which, up to a certain point, can 
facilitate an approach. Their aim is to criticize and to 
discredit us ; for that alone it is necessary that we be pre- 
sent and act. As we know, to the socialists, not only in 
Russia, but throughout the world, the revolution now tak- 
ing place signifies a bourgeois and not a socialist revolu- 
tion : a revolution which is to be accomplished by the 
bourgeois democracy. To capture the place of this democ- 
racy ... for this the socialists of the whole world have not 
prepared, and if the country has sent them into the Duma 
in such great numbers, tnen it was certainly not for the 
purpose of realizing- socialism now or in order to carry 
through the necessary "bourgeois" reforms with their own 
hands ... It will consequently be more profitable for them 
to criticize the role of the parliamentarians .rather than 
to compromise themselves in the same role.' 

"As we see, Miliukov leads us to the very heart of the 
question. The quotation cited gives all the most important 
elements of the Menshevik attitude towards the revolution 
and the relationship between bourgeois and socialist de- 
mocracy/' 

" 'The revolution that is taking place is a bourgeois and 
not a socialist revolution' that's the first thing. The 
bourgeois revolution 'must be realized by the bourgeois 
democracy' that's the second point. The socialist demo- 
cracy cannot carry through bourgeois reforms with its 
own hands, its role is a purely oppositional one : 'Criticize 
and discredit'. And finally as the fourth point in order 
for the socialists to obtain the possibility of remaining in 
the opposition, 'it is necessary that we (that 
geois democracy) be present and act'." 

"And if 'we' are not present? And if 
geois democracy capable of marching 
bourgeois revolution ? Then it must be 




PERMANENT BE VOLUTION 

just the conclusion to which Menshevism arrives. It builds 
up the bourgeois democracy, and its attributes and his- 
tory, out of its own imagination." 

"As materialists, we must in the first place pose the 
question of the social bases of the bourgeois democracy : 
upon what strata and classes can it support itself ?" 

"It is needless to speak about the bourgeoisie as a 
revolutionary power on this we are all united. Lyons in- 
dustrialists, even in the great French revolution, which 
was a national revolution in the broadest sense of the 
term, played a counter-revolutionary role. But we are 
told about the middle bourgeoisie, and particularly of the 
petty bourgeoisie, as the leading force of the bourgeois 
revolution. But what does this petty bourgeoisie represent ?" 

"The Jacobins supported themselves upon the city de- 
mocracy, which grew up out of the guilds, small masters, 
assistants, and the city population closely bound up with 
them, constituted the army of the revolutionary sanscu- 
lottes, the prop of the leading party of the Montagnards. 
It was precisely this compact mass of the city population, 
which had gone through the long historical school of the 
guild, that bore upon its shoulders the whole burden of 
the revolutionary overturn. The objective result of the re- 
volution was the creation of 'normal' conditions of capi- 
talist exploitation. The social mechanics of the historical 
process, however, led to the point where the conditions 
were created for the domination of the bourgeoisie by the 
plebs, the- democracy of the streets, the sansculottes. 
Their terrorist dictatorship purged bourgeois society of the 
old rubbish and then, after it had overthrown the dicta- 
torship of the petty bourgeois democracy, the bourgeoisie 
came to rule." 

"Now I ask over and over again: What social class in 
our country will elevate revolutionary bourgeois democra- 
cy, put it in power raid give it the possibility of carrying 
out the gigantic work, if the proletariat remains in oppo- 
sition ? I have again and again asked the Mensheviks for a 

98 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION IN PRACTISE 

reply to this central question. It is true, we have enor- 
mous masses of the revolutionary peasantry. But the 
comrades of the minority know just as well as I do that 
the peasantry, regardless of how revolutionary it may be, is 
incapable of playing an independent, much less a leading, 
political role. The peasantry can undoubtedly prove to be 
an enormous power in the service of the revolution; but 
it would be unworthy of "a Marxist to believe that a pea- 
sant party is capable of placing itself at the head of a 
bourgeois revolution and, upon its own initiative, liberate 
the productive forces of the country from the archaic 
fetters. The city has the hegemony in modern society and 
the hegemony in the bourgeois revolution can belong to 
it alone. 55 

"Now where have we the city democracy that is capa- 
ble of leading the people ? Comrade Martinov has already 
sought it repeatedly, magnifying glass in hand. He found 
Saratov teachers, Petersburg lawyers, and Moscow statis- 
ticians. Like all his colleagues, he too would take no no- 
tice at all of the fact that in the Russian revolution the 
industrial proletariat will occupy the ground upon which 
the semi-proletarian artisan's democracy of the sanscu- 
lottes stood at the end of the eighteenth century. I call 
your attention, comrades, to this fundamental principle 
fact." 

"Our big industry did not develop naturally out of 
handicrafts. The economic history of our towns does not 
know the period of guilds. Capitalist industry with us 
arose under the direct and immediate pressure of Euro- 
pean capital. It really conquered a virginal primitive soil, 
without encountering the resistance of handicraft culture. 
Foreign capital flowed into our country through the chan- 
nels of state loans and through the pipes of private initia- 
tive. It gathered around itself the army of the industrial 
proletariat and prevented the rise and development of 
handicrafts. As a result of this process there appeared 
among us as the main power of the city, at the moment 

99 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

of the bourgeois revolution, an industrial proletariat of 
the highest social type. This is a fact that cannot be dis- 
puted and which must be taken as the basis of our revo- 
lutionary tactical conclusions." 

"If the comrades of minority (the Mensheviks) believe 
in the victory of the revolution, or even only recognize 
the possibility of such a victory, they cannot dispute the 
fact that in our country threre is no other historical clai- 
mant to revolutionary power than the proletariat. Just as 
the petty bourgeois city democracy in the great revolution 
placed itself at the head of the revolutionary nation, so 
the proletariat, the only revolutionary democracy of our 
cities, must find a support in the peasant masses and 
place itself in power if the revolution has any prospect 
of victory at all." 

"A government supported directly upon the proletariat, 
and through it upon the revolutionary peasantry , does not 
yet signify the socialist dictatorship. I do not touch upon 
the further perspectives of a proletarian government now. 
Perhaps the proletariat is condemned to collapse, as the 
Jacobin democracy collapsed in order to give way to the 
rule of the bourgeoisie. I want to establish only one point : 
If the revolutionary movement in our country, as Plecha- 
nov foretold, triumphs as a workers' movement, then the 
victory of the revolution is possible only as the revolutio- 
nary victory of the proletariat otherwise it is altogether 
impossible." 

"I insist upon this conclusion with all determination. U 
it is assumed that the social antagonisms between the pro- 
letariat and the peasant masses will prevent the pro 
letariat from placing itself at the head of the movement 
that; further, the proletariat is not strong enough for i 
victory then one must arrive at the conslusion that nc 
victory is destined for our revolution. Under such circums 
tances, an agreement between the liberal bourgeoisie anc 
the old power would have to be the natural finale of th< 
revolution. This is a conclusion, the possibility of whicl 

100 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION IN PRACTISE 

ean in no case be contested. But it is clear that it is 
based upon the line of the defeat of the revolution, con- 
ditioned by its internal weakness. The entire analysis of 
the Mensheviks above all their evaluation of the prole- 
tariat and its possible relationship to the peasantry leads 
them inexorably to the path of revolutionary pessimism." 

"But they persistently deviate from this path and 
develop a revolutionary optimism on the credit ... of 
the bourgeois democracy." 

"Thence results its relationship to the Cadets. The 
Cadets are for them the symbol of bourgeois democracy, 
and bourgeois democracy the natural claimant to revo- 
lutionary power. ..." 



"Upon what do you base your belief that the Cadet will 
still rise and stand erect ? Upon facts of political develop- 
ment? No, upon your schema. In order 'to carry the 
revolution through to the end' you need the city bourgeois 
democracy, you search after it eagerly, and find nothing 
but Cadets. And you develop at their expense a rare 
optimism, you dress them up, you force them to play a 
creative r61e, a role which they do not want to play, can- 
not play and will not play. To my central question 1 
have put it repeatedly I have heard no response. You 
have no prognosis of the revolution. Your policy is desti- 
tute of any great perspectives whatsoever. " 

"And in connection with this, your relationship to the 
bourgeois parties is formulated in words which the conven- 
tion should bear firmly in mind : 'as the occasion requires*. 
The proletariat does not carry on the systematic struggle 
for influence over the masses of the people, it does not 
check up its tactical steps from the angle of the single lead- 
ing thought : to gather around it the weary and the heavy- 
laden and to become their herald and leader. " (Minutes 
and Resolutions of the Fifth Convention. Pages 180-1S5.)" 

101 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

This speech, which sums up briefly all my articles, 
speeches and acts of 1905 and 1906, was completely ap- 
proved by the Bolsheviks, not to speak of Rosa Luxem- 
burg and Tyschko (on the basis of this speech, we entered 
upon more intimate relations which led to my collaboration 
in their Polish journal). Lenin, who could not forgive 
me my conciliatory conduct toward the Mensheviks 
'and he was right expressed himself on my speech with 
a deliberately underlined reserve. He said : 

"I merely wish to observe that Trotsky, in his book. 
On the Defense of the Party emphatically expressed his 
solidarity with Kautsky, who wrote of the economic com- 
munity of interests of the proletariat and the peasantry in 
the present revolution in Russia. Trotsky recognized the 
admissibility and expediency of a Left bloc [with the 
peasants. L. T.I against the liberal bourgeoisie. These 
facts are enough for me to establish Trotsky's approach to 
our conception. Independent of the question of the 'un- 
interrupted revolution 9 , we have here before our eyes a 
solidarity in the fundamental points of the question con- 
cerning the relationship to the bourgeois parties." (Lenin, 
Volume Fill, page 400.) 

Lenin occupied himself in his speech all the less with a 
rounded evaluation of the theory of the permanent revolu- 
tion since I too, in my speech, had not developed the fur- 
ther perspectives of the dictatorship of the proletariat. He 
had obviously not read my fundamental work on this ques- 
tion, otherwise he would not have spoken of my "approach" 
to the conception of the Bolsheviks as of something -new, 
for my London speech was only a condensed reproduction 
of my works of 1905-1906. He expressed himself very re- 
servedly, because I did stand outside the Bolshevik fac- 
tion. In spite of that, or more correctly, perhaps pre- 
cisely! because of that, his words allow no room for false 
interpretations. Lenin established the "solidarity in the 
fundamental points of the question" of the relationship 
to the peasantry and to the liberal bourgeoisie. 

102 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION IK PRACTISE 

solidarity does not relate to my aims, as Radek pre- 
posterously represents it, but precisely to the method. 
As to the perspective of the democratic revolution grow- 
ing into the socialist revolution, it is right here that Lenin 
makes the reservation, "independent of the question of 
the uninterrupted revolution". What is the meaning of 
this reservation ? It is clear that Lenin in no way identi- 
fied the permanent revolution with the ignoring of the 
peasantry or with skipping over the agrarian revolution, 
as has been done by the ignorant and unscrupulous 
epigones, who have made a rule of it. This is Lenin's 
idea : How f$r our revolution will go, whether the pro- 
letariat can come to power in our country sooner than in 
Europe and what perspectives this opens up for socialism 
these questions I do not touch upon; however, in the 
fundamental question of the relationship of the proletariat 
to the peasantry and to the liberal bourgeoisie the "soli- 
darity is before our eyes". 

We have seen above the echo which the theory of the 
permanent revolution produced almost immediately after 
its origination, that is, already in 1905, in the Bolshevik 
Novaia Zhizn. We want to refer further to how the 
editors of Lenin's Collected Works expressed themselves 
on this theory after 1917. In the annotations to Volume 
XIV, Part 2, page 481, it says: 

"Already before the 1905 revolution he (Trotsky) 
advanced the original and now especially noteworthy 
theory of the permanent revolution, in which he contended 
that the bourgeois revolution of 1905 would pass directly 
over into a socialist revolution, and then constitute the first 
of a series of national revolutions." 

I admit that this is no acknowledgment of the correct- 
ness of all that I have written on the permanent revolu- 
tion. But in any case it is an acknowledgment of the 
incorrectness of what Radek writes about it. "The 
bourgeois revolution will pass directly over into a socialist 
revolution" but this is precisely the theory of the grow- 

108 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

ing into and not of skipping over; from that comes a 
realistic, and not an adventuristic, tactic. And what is 
the meaning of the words: "now especially noteworthy 
theory of the permanent revolution"? They mean that 
the October overthrow showed in a new light those sides 
of the theory which had formerly remained in obscurity 
foy many or had simply appeared "improbable". The 
second part of Volume XIV of Lenin's Collected Works 
appeared while their author was alive. Thousands upon 
thousands of party members read this annotation. And 
nobody declared it to be false until the year 1924. It 
occurred to Radek, however, to do this in the year 1928. 

But in so far as Radek speaks not only of the theory 
but also of the tactic, the most important argument 
against him still remains the character of my practical 
participation in the revolutions of 1905 and 1917. My 
work in the Petersburg Soviet of 1905 coincided with the 
elaboration of those of my views on the nature of the 
revolution which the epigones now expose to an uninter- 
rupted fire. How could such allegedly erroneous views 
fail to be reflected in my political activity, which was 
carried on before the eyes of the whole world and regis- 
tered every day in the press ? But if it is assumed that 
such an absurd theory was expressed in my policy, then 
why did the present Consuls remain silent at that time? 
And what is to a certain extent even more important, 
why did Lenin at that time most energetically defend the 
line of the Petrograd Soviets, at the high point of the 
revolution as well as after its defeat? 

The same questions, only perhaps more sharply for- 
mulated, relate to the revolution of 1917. In New York, 
I wrote a series of articles on the February revolution 
from the point of view of the theory of the permanent 
revolution. All these articles are today reprinted. My 
tactical conclusions coincided entirely with the conclusions 
which Lenin drew at the same time in Geneva, and con- 
sequently, were in the same irreconcilable contradiction 

104 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION IN PRACTISE 

to the conclusions of Kamenev, Stalin and the other 
epigones. When I arrived in Petrograd, nobody asked 
me if I renounced my "errors" of the permanent revolu- 
tion. Nor was there anybody to ask. Stalin slunk around 
in embarrassment from one corner to another and had only 
the one desire that the party should forget as quickly as 
possible the policy which he had advocated up to Lenin's 
arrival. Yaroslavksy was not yet the chairman of the 
Control Commission : together with the Mensheviks, with 
Ordjonikidze and others, he was publishing a banal semi- 
liberal sheet in Yakutsk. Kamenev accused Lenin of 
Trotskyism and declared when he met me : "Now the 
celebration is on your street." On the eve of the October, 
I wrote in the central organ of the Bolsheviks on the 
perspectives of the permanent revolution. It never 
occurred to anybody to come out against me. My soli- 
darity with Lenin turned out to be a complete and uncon- 
ditional one. What can my critics, among them Radek 
too, say now? That I myself had completely misunder- 
stood the theory which I advocated, and that in the 
responsible historical periods, contrary to this theory, I 
acted entirely right? Is it not simpler to assume that 
my critics did not understand the permanent revolution, 
like so many other things ? For if it is assumed that these 
tardy critics are well acquainted not only with their own 
ideas, but with those of others, then how is it to be 
explained that all of them, without exception, adopted 
such a miserable position in the revolution of 1917 and 
forever covered themselves with shame in the Chinese 
revolution ? 



But after all, many readers will suddenly recall, What 
about your most important tactical slogan : "Without 
the czar, but a labor government"? 

This serves as a decisive argument in certain articles. 

105 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

Trotsky's frightful slogan: "Without the czar!" runs 
through all the "writings of the various critics of the per- 
manent revolution; with some it emerges as the final, 
most important and decisive argument; with others, as 
the ready harbor of weary thought. 

This criticism naturally reaches its greatest profundity 
in the "Master" 10 of ignorance and disloyalty, when he says 
in his incomparable Problems of Leninism : 

"We do not want to expatiate further (now thenf 
L. T.) on the position of comrade Trotsky in 1905, where 
he 'simply' forgot the peasantry as a revolutionary force 
and raised the slogan : * Without the czar but a labor 
government', that is, the slogan for a revolution without 
the peasantry." (Stalin. Problems of Leninism. Pages 



Despite my positively hopeless position before this 
annihilating criticism, which does not want to "expatiate", 
I should nevertheless like to refer to some mitigating 
circumstances. There are some. I beseech a hearing. 

Even if, in 1905, I had formulated an ambiguous or 
unhappy slogan in some article or other, which was open 
to misunderstanding, then today, twenty-three years later, 
it should not be considered in an isolated manner, but in 
connection with my other works on this theme, mainly, 
however, in connection with my political participation 
in the events. It simply does not do for me to call the 
reader's attention to the bare name of a work unknown 
to him (in the same way as to the critics) and to attribute 
a meaning to this name which stands in complete contra- 
diction to everything I wrote and did. 

Perhaps, too, it is not superfluous to add O my 
critics ! that the slogan : "Without the czar but a 
labor government" was never written, nor expressed, nor 
proposed by me ! At the basis of the main argument of 
my judges there lies, aside from everything else, a shame- 
ful factual error. The fact of the matter is that a procla- 
mation entitled "Without the czar but a labor govern- 

106 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION IN PRACTISE 

ment v was written and published abroad in 1905 by 
Parvus. I had been Irving illegally for a long time in 
Petersburg in those days, and had no connections at all 
with this leaflet dither in ideas or in fact. I learned of it 
much later from polemical articles. I never had the 
occasion or opportunity to express myself on it. 'As for 
the proclamation I (as, moreover, all my critics) neither 
saw it nor read it. This is the factual side of this fanciful 
affair. I am sorry that I must deprive all the Thalmanns 
and Semards of this easily transportable and convincing 
argument. But facts are stronger than my humane 
feelings. 

Still more. The incident providently added one 
thing to the other : at the same time that Parvus pub- 
lished abroad the proclamation unknown to me "Without 
the czar but a labor government", a leaflet written by 
me appeared illegally in Petersburg with the title: 
"Neither czar nor Zemtsi 11 , but the people". This title, 
which is frequently repeated in the text of the leaflet as 
a slogan embracing the workers and the peasants, is so to 
speak, invented in order to refute in a popular form the 
later contentions about skipping the democratic stage of 
the revolution. The appeal is reprinted in my Works 
(Volume 77, Part 1, page 256). There also are my pro- 
clamations, published by the Bolshevik Central Commitee, 
to that peasantry which, in the ingenious expression of 
Stalin, I "simply forgot". 

But even this is not yet all. Only a short time ago, 
the meritorious Rajes, a theoretician and leader of the 
Chinese revolution, wrote in the theoretical organ of the 
Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet 
Union of the same frightful slogan which Trotsky raised 
in the year 1917. Not 1905, but 1917! For the Men- 
shevik Rafes, at any rate, there is some excuse : almost 
up till 1920 he was a "minister" of Petlura, and how 
could he, weighed down by the cares of state of the 
struggle against the Bolsheviks, pay any heed there to 

107 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

what was going on in the camp of the October revolution ? 
Well, and the editorial board of the organ of the Central 
Committee? What of it! one idiocy more or less . . . 

"But how is that possible?" a conscientious reader 
raised on the trash of recent years might call out. 
"Weren't we taught in hundreds and thousands of books 
and articles ..." 

"Yes, friends, taught; and that is just why we will 
have to learn anew. These are the losses incurred through 
the period of reaction. Nothing can be done about it. 
History does not proceed in a straight line. It has tem- 
porarily run into the blind alleys of Stalin." 



108 



CHAPTER FIVE 



WAS THE "DEMOCRATIC DICTATOR- 
SHI P"REALIZEDBYUS?ANDWHEN? 



APPEALING TO Lenin, Radek contends that the demo- 
cratic dictatorship was realized in the dual power 
of the Kerensky period. Yes, many times, and con- 
ditionally, Lenin put the question this way that I 
admit. "Many times?" Radek becomes indignant and 
accuses me of assailing the most fundamental ideas of 
Lenin. But Radek is angry only because he is wrong. 
In The Lessons of October, which Radek likewise submits 
to criticism after a protracted delay of about four years, 
I interpreted Lenin's words on the "realization" of the 
democratic dictatorship in the following manner : 

"The democratic workers' and peasants' coalitioa 
could make its appearance only as an immature product, 
which did not attain real power only as a tendency, but 
not as a fact." (Volume 111, Part 1, page XXI.) 

With regard to this interpretation, Radek writes: 
"This reproduction of one of the most outstanding theore- 
tical chapters in the work of Lenin is worth absolutely 
nothing." These words are followed by a pathetic appeal 
to the traditions of Bolshevism, and finally, the conclu- 
sion : "These questions are too important to be able to 
reply to them with a reference to what Lenin many times 
said." 

By this, Radek wants to evoke the image of my care- 
less conduct against "one of the most outstanding " of 

109 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

Lenin's ideas. But Radek is wasting indignation and 
pathos for nothing. A bit of understanding would be 
more in place here. My presentation, even though very 
condensed, in The Lessons of October, does not rest upon 
a sudden inspiration on the basis of quotations taken at 
second hand, but upon a genuine thorough study of Lenin's 
writings. It reproduces the essence of the Leninist idea 
on this question, while the verbose presentation of Radek, 
despite the superfluity of quotations, does not leave 
behind it a single living passage of Lenin's thoughts. 

Why did I make use of the restrictive words "many 
times" ? Because that is how it really stood. References 
to the fact that the democratic dictatorship was "realized" 
in the dual power" ("in certain forms and up to a certain 
point"), were made by Lenin only in the period between 
April and October 1917, that is, before the genuine reali- 
zation of the democratic revolution had been completed. 
Radek neither noticed, grasped, nor understood how to 
evaluate this. In the struggle against the present 
epigones, Lenin spoke extremely conditionally of the 
"realization" of the democratic dictatorship, not as of a 
historical characteristic of the period of the dual power 
in this form it' would be plain nonsense but by this he 
argued against those who expected a second, improved 
edition of the independent democratic dictatorship. 
Lenin's words only meant that there is not and will not be 
any democratic dictatorship outside of the miserable mis- 
carriage of the dual power, and that new weapons there- 
fore had to be provided, that is, the slogan had to be 
changed. To contend that the coalition of the Mensheviks 
and the Social Revolutionists with the bourgeoisie, which 
refused the peasants the land and hounded the Bolsheviks 
-constituted the "realization" of the Bolshevik slogan, 
either means deliberately to pass off black as white or else 
to have lost one's head entirely. 

With regard to the Mensheviks, an argument could 
be presented which would be analogous to a certain point 

110 



"DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP" 

to Lenin's argument against Kamenev: "You are wgit- 
ing for the bourgeoisie to fulfil, a 'progressive' mission in 
the revolution? This mission has already been realized: 
the political r61e of the Rodziankos, the Gutchkovs and 
Miliukovs is the maximum that the bourgeoisie is able 
to give, just as the Kerenskiad is the maximum of democ- 
ratic revolution that could be realized as an independent 
stage." 

Unmistakable anatomical features rudiments show 
that our ancestors had a tail. These features suffice to 
confirm the genetic unity of animate being. But to put 
it quite candidly, man has no tail. Lenin demonstrated 
to Kamenev the rudiments of the democratic dictatorship 
in the regime of the dual power, warning him that no new 
organ should be hoped for out of these rudiments. And 
we did not have an independent democratic dictatorship, 
even though we completed the democratic revolution 
more deeply, more resolutely, more purely than had ever 
been done anywhere else. 

Radek should reflect upon the fact that if, in Feb- 
ruary to April, the democratic dictatorship had actually 
been realized, even Molotov would have recognized it. 
The party and the class understood the democratic dicta- 
torship as a regime which mercilessly destroys the old 
state apparatus of the monarchy and completely liquidates 
manorial landed property. But there was not a trace of 
this in the Kerensky period. For the Bolshevik party, 
however, it was a question of the actual realization of the 
Revolutionary tasfcs, and not in the revelation of certain 
sociological and historical "rudiments". Lenin, in order 
to enlighten his adversaries theoretically demonstrated 
splendidly this symptom which had not attained any 
development. But still, nothing more than that. Radek, 
however, endeavors in all seriousness to convince us that 
in the period of the dual power, that is, of powerlessness, 
the "dictatorship" did exist and the democratic revolution 
was realized. Only, it was allegedly such a "democratic 

111 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

revolution", that Lenin's genius was required to recognize 
it. But this is just the thing that signifies that it was not 
realized. The real democratic revolution, namely, is a 
thing that every illiterate peasant in Russia or in China 
easily recognizes. The morphological features are surety 
in a worse plight. Despite the Russian lesson t<? Kamenev 
there has been no success, for example, in having Radet 
finally perceive that in China, the democratic dictatorshij 
(through the Kuo Min Tang), in Lenin's sense, was like 
wise "realized" more thoroughly and more completely 
than with us in the dual power, and that only hopeles; 
simpletons can wait for an improved edition of "democ 
racy" in China. 

If the democratic dictatorship had only been real 
ized with us in the form of the Kerenskiad, which playe< 
the role of an errand-boy to Lloyd George and Clemen 
ceau, then we would have to say that history indulgec 
in cruel mockery with the strategic slogans of the Bol 
sheviks. Fortunately, it is not so. The Bolshevik sloga 
was realized in fact not as a morphological illusion bu 
as the greatest historical reality. Only, it was realize 
wot before the October but after the October. Th 
peasant war, in the words of Marx, supported the dictf 
torship of the proletariat. The collaboration of the tw 
classes was realized through the October on a giganti 
scale. Now every ignorant peasant grasped and felt, eve 
without Lenin's commentaries, that the Bolshevik sloga 
had been carried through in life. And Lenin himself est 
mated the October revolution its first stage as the in 
realization of the democratic revolution, and by that ab 
as the true, even if changed, realization of the strateg 
slogan of the Bolsheviks. The whole Lenin must be coi 
sidered. And before all, the Lenin after the Octobe 
when he surveyed and evaluated events from a lofti 
watch-tower. Finally, Lenin must be considered in tl 
Leninist way, and not in that of the epigones. 

The question of the class character of the revoluti< 



"DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP" 

and its "growing into" is submitted by Lenin (after the 
October) to an analysis in his book against Kautsky. 
Here is a passagie over which Radek should reflect a bit. 

"Yes, our revolution (the October revolution, L. T.) 
is a bourgeois revolution so long as we march together 
with the peasantry as a whole. We were more than 
clearly conscious of this, and said hundreds and thousands 
of times since 1905 that this necessary stage of the histori- 
cal process cannot be skipped over or abolished by decree." 

And further on : 

"It happened Just as we had foretold. The course of 
the revolution confirmed the correctness of our considera- 
tion. At the beginning, together with the 'whole* 
peasantry against the monarchy, against the landowners, 
against the Middle Ages (and to that extent it remains a 
bourgeois, a bourgeois-democratic revolution). And then, 
together with the poorest peasantry, with the semi-pro- 
letarian, with all the exploited against capitalism, includ- 
ing the rich and the speculators of the village, and to that 
exent the revolution becomes a socialist revolution." 
(Volume XV, page 508.) 

That is how Lenin spoke, not "many times" but 
always, or, more correctly, giving the course of the revo- 
lution, including the October, a conclusive, a generalizing, 
thorough appreciation forever. "It happened just as 
we had foretold." THe bourgeois democratic revolution 
was realized as a coalition of the workers and peasants. 
In the Kerenskiad? No, in the first period after the 
October. Is that right ? It is. But, as we now know, 
it was not realized in the form of the democratic dictator- 
ship, but in the form of the dictatorship of the proletariat. 
With that there also disappeared the necessity for the old 
algebraic formula. 

If the conditional argument of Lenin against Kamenev 
in 1917 and the rounded-out Leninist characterization of 
the October revolution in the subsequent years are uncri- 
tically juxtaposed, then it follows that two democratic 

118 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

revolutions were "realized" in Russia. This is too much, 
all the more since the second is separated from the first 
by an armed uprising of the proletariat. 

Now contrast the quotation just made from Lenin's 
book, Kautsky the Renegade, with the passage from my 
Results and Perspectives where, in the chapter on The 
Proletarian Regime, the first stage of the dictatorship and 
the perspective of its further development is outlined : 

"The abolition of class serfdom will find the support 
of the whole peasantry, as a subjugated estate. The 
progressive income tax will find the support of the 
immense majority of the peasantry. But legislative 
measures for the protection of the land proletariat will not 
only find no active sympathy among the majority, but 
they will clash with the active resistance of a minority. 

"The proletariat will be compelled to carry the class 
struggle into the village, and in this way violate that com- 
munity of interests which indubitably exists among the 
peasantry as a whole, even if within relatively narrow 
boundaries. In the earliest moments of its domination, 
the proletariat will have to seek a support in the conflict 
of interests of the village poor and the village rich of the 
land proletariat and the agricultural bourgeoisie." (Our 
Revolution 9 1906, page 255.) 

How all this resembles an "ignoring" of the peasantry 
and the complete "antagonism" of the two lines, Lenin's 
and mine ! 

The quotation from Lenin adduced above does not 
stand alone in his works. On the contrary, as is always 
the case with Lenin, the new formula, which events illu- 
minate more penetratingly, becomes for him the axis of 
his speeches and his articles for a whole period of time. 
In March 1919, Lenin said : 

"In October 1917, we seized power together with the 
peasantry as a whole. That was a bourgeois revolution, 
to the extent that the class struggle in the village had 
not yet developed." (Volume XVI, page US.) 

114 



"DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP" 

The following was said by Lenin at the party conven- 
tion in March 1919 : 

"In a country where the proletariat was compelled 
to take power with the aid of the peasantry, and where 
the role of agent of the petty bourgeois revolution fell to 
the proletariat our revolution, up to the formation of the 
Committees of the Poor, that is, up to the summer and 
even the fall of 1918, was in large measure a bourgeois 
revolution." (Volume XVI, page 105.) 

These words were frequently repeated by Lenin in 
different variations and on divers occasions. Radek, how- 
ever, simply avoids this capital thought which decides the 
disputed question. 

The proletariat took power together with the peasantry 
in October, says Lenin. By that alone, the revolution was 
a bourgeois revolution. Is that right? In a certain 
sense, yes. But this means that the true democratic dicta- 
torship of the proletariat and the peasantry, that is, the one 
which actually destroyed the regime of autocracy and 
serfdom, and snatched the land from the feudalists, was 
accomplished not before the October but only after the 
October; accomplished, to put it as Marx did, as the 
dictatorship of the proletariat supported by the peasant 
war, to begin only a few months later with the growing into 
a socialist dictatorship. Is this incomprehensible? Can 
differences of opinion prevail on this point today ? 

'According to Radek, the "permanent" theory sins 
by mixing up the bourgeois stage with the socialist. In 
reality, however, the class dynamics so thoroughly "mixed 
up", that is, united these two stages that our unfortunate 
metaphysician is no longer in a position to keep the ends 
asunder. 

Certainly, many gaps and many incorrect contentions 
can be found in Results and Perspectives. But this work 
was written not in 1928, but considerably before the 
October . . before the 1905 October. The question of the 
gaps in the theory of the permanent revolution, or more 

115 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

correctly, in my motivations of this theory at that time, is 
not even touched upon by Radek, for, following his 
teachers the epigones he attacks not the gaps but the 
strong sides of the theory, those which the course of histori- 
cal development confirmed, attacks them in the name of 
the essentially false conclusions which he traces from 
Lenin's attitude not thoroughly studied and not thought 
out to the very end by Radek. 

The juggling with obsolete quotations is practised in 
general by the whole school of epigones entirely upon a 
specific plane, which nowhere intersects the real historical 
process. But when the opponents of "Trotskyism" have 
to occupy themselves with the analysis of the real develop- 
ment of the October revolution, and occupy themselves with 
it seriously and consistently which happens to many of 
them from time to time then they inevitably arrive at 
formulations in the spirit of the theory which they reject. 
We find the crassest proof of this in the works of A. Yak- 
ovlev, which are devoted to the history of the October re- 
volution. The class relationships of old Russia are formu- 
lated by this author, today a prop of the ruling faction 12 
and undoubtedly more educated than the other Stalinists, 
and particularly than Stalin himself, as follows : 

"... We see a twofold limitedness of the peasants' 
uprising (March to October 1917). Raising itself to the 
level of a peasant war, the uprising did not overcome its 
limitedness, did not burst asunder the confines of its im- 
mediate task : to destroy the neighboring landowner ; did 
not transform itself into an organized revolutionary move- 
ment ; did not surmount the character of an elementary re- 
bellion that distinguishes the peasant movement. 

"The peasant uprising taken by itself an elementary 
act, limited in its aim to the extermination of the 
neighbouring landowner could not triumph, could not 
destroy the state power hostile to the peasantry, which 
supported the landowner. That is why the agrarian 
movement was capable of winning only because it was led 

116 



"DEMOCRATIC DICTA TX> R s H i P" 

by the corresponding city class .... This is the reason 
why the fate of the agrarian revolution, in the final 
analysis, was decided not in the tens of thousands of 
villages, but in the hundreds of cities. Only the working 
class, which was dealing the bourgeoisie a mortal blow 
m the centers of the country, could turn the peasant up- 
rising into victory; only the victory of the working class 
in the city could tear the peasant movement out of the 
confines of an elemental clash of a few tens of millions of 
peasants with a few tens of thousands of landowners; 
only the victory of the working class, finally, could lay 
the foundation stone of a new type of peasant organization, 
which united the poor and middle peasantry not with the 
bourgeoisie but with the working class. The problem of 
the victory of the peasant uprising was a problem of the 
victory of the working class in the city. 

"When the workers dealt the government of the 
bourgeoisie a decisive blow in October, by the same 
token they simultaneously solved the problem of the 
victory of the peasant uprising." 

And further on : 

"... that is just why it happened that, by virtue of 
the historically given conditions in 1917, bourgeois 
Russia came forward in alliance with the landowners. 
Even the most Left factions of the bourgeoisie, like the 
Mensheviks and the Social Revolutionists, did not go 
beyond the conclusion of an agreement favorable to the 
landowners. Therein lies the most important difference 
between the conditions of the Russian revolution 
and the French revolution which took place more than 
a hundred years ago . . . The peasant revolution could 
not triumph as a bourgeois revolution in 1917 (now 
then! L.T.) Two roads were open to it. Either defeat 
under the blows of the united forces of the bourgeoisie 

and the landowners or victory, as a movement that 

marches together with the proletarian revolution and 
assists it to triumph. By taking over the mission of the 

117 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

bourgeoisie in the great French revolution, by taking 
over the task of leading the agrarian democratic revo- 
lution, the working class of Russia obtained the possibi- 
lity of a victorious proletarian revolution." (The Pea- 
sant Movement in 1917, State Publishing House, 1927, 
pages x-xi, xi-xii.) 

What are the fundamental elements of Yakovlev 's 
arguments? The incapacity of the peasantry to play an 
independent political role; the resultant inevitability of 
the hegemony of the city class; the inadequacy of the 
Russian bourgeoisie for the role of leader in the agrarian 
revolution; the resultant inevitably of the leading r61e 
o the proletariat; its seizure of power as leader of the 
agrarian revolution; finally, the dictatorship of the pro- 
letariat which supports itself upon the peasant war and 
opens up an epoch of socialist revolutions. This destroys 
to the roots the metaphysical posing of the question 
concerning the "bourgeois" or the "socialist" character 
of the revolution. The kernel of the matter lay in the fact 
that the agrarian question, which constituted the basis 
of the bourgeois revolution, could not be solved under 
the rule of the bourgeoisie. The dictatorship of the pro- 
letariat appeared on the scene not after the completion 
of the agrarian democratic revolution but as the neces- 
sary prerequisite for its accomplishment. In a word, in 
this retrospective schema of Yakovlev, we have all the 
fundamental elements of the theory of the permanent 
revolution as formulated by me in 1905. With me, it was 
a question of a historical prognosis; Yakovlev, relying 
upon the preliminary studies of a whole staff of young 
research workers, draws conclusions from the lessons of 
the three revolutions twenty-two years after the first re- 
volution and ten years after the October revolution. And 
then? Yakovlev repeats almost literally my formulation 
of 1905. 

What is Yakovlev's attitude, however, to the theory 
of the permanent revolution ? Such as befits a Stalinist 

118 



DICTATORSHIP" 

official who wants to retain his post and even to climb 
to a higher one. But how does Yakovlev, in this case, 
reconcile his analysis of the driving forces of the October 
revolution with the struggle against "Trotskyism" ? Very 
simply : he does not give a thought to such a reconcilia- 
tion. Like many liberal czarist officials, who acknowledg- 
ed Darwin's theory, but at the same time appeared 
punctually at communion, Yakovlev too pays for the 
right to express Marxian ideas from time to time with the 
price of participating in the ritual of baiting the perma- 
nent revolution. Such examples could be instanced by 
the dozen. 

There still remains to add that Yakovlev did not 
execute the above-quoted work on the history of the 
October revolution on his own initiative, but on the 
basis of a decision of the Central Committee, which at 
the same time charged me with the editing of Yakovlev's 
work 1 ". At that time, Lenin's recovery was still expected, 
and it never occurred to any of the epigones to kindle 
an. artificial dispute around the theory of the permanent 
revolution. At any rate, as the former, or more correctly, 
as the contemplated editor of the official history of the 
October revolution, I can establish with complete satisfac- 
tion that the author, in all the disputed questions, cons- 
ciously or unconsciously employed the literal formulations 
of my persecuted and heretical work on the theory of the 
permanent revolution (Results and Perspectives). 

The rounded-out evaluation of the historical fate of 
the Bolshevik slogan which Lenin himself gave, shows with 
certainty that the difference of the two lines, the "perma- 
nent 5 ' and Lenin's had an incidental and subordinated 
significance ; what united them, however, was the principle. 
And this principle of both lines, which were completely 
fused by the October, is in irreconcilable antagonism not 
only to the February-March line of Stalin and the April- 
October line of Kamenev, Rykov and Zinoviev, not only 
to the whole China policy of Stalin, Bucharin and 

119 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

Martinov, but also to the present "Chinese" line of Radek. 

And when Radek, who changed his judgment of values 
so radically between 1925 and the second half of 1928, 
seeks to convict me of not understanding "the complexity 
of Marxism and Leninism", then I can reply : The funda- 
mental train of thought which I developed twenty-five 
years ago in Results and Perspectives, I consider confirm- 
ed by events as completely correct, and precisely because 
of that in agreement with the strategical line of 
Bolshevism. 

Especially do I fail to see the slightest cause to with- 
draw anything from what I said in 1922 on the permanent 
revolution in the foreword to my book 1905, which the 
whole party read and studied in innumerable editions and 
reprints while Lenin was alive, and which "disturbed" 
Kamenev only in the autumn of 1924 and Radek, for the 
first time, in the autumn of 1928. 

"Right in the period between January 9 and the 
October 1905 strike (it says in the foreword) the author 
formed those opinions on the character of the revolutionary 
development of Russia which later received the name 
'theory of the permanent revolution'. This somewhat un- 
usual name expressed the idea that the Russian revolution, 
standing before directly bourgeois aims, could in no case 
remain standing there. The revolution will not be able to 
solve its immediate bourgeois tasks except by putting the 
proletariat in power. . . . 

"This view, even if after a lapse of twelve years, was 
confirmed as completely correct. The Russian revolution 
could not terminate with the bourgeois democratic regime. 
It had to transfer power to the working class. // the 
working class was still too weak for the capture of power 
in 1905, it had to mature and grow strong not in the 
bourgeois democratic republic but in the illegality of the 
'Third of June czarism 14 ' " (L. Trotsky, 1905, foreword, 
page 45.) 

T want to quote one more of the sharpest polemical 

120 



"DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP"' 

judgments which I passed over the slogan of the "demo- 
cratic dictatorship". In 1909, I wrote in the Polish organ 
of Rosa Luxemburg: 

"If the Mensheviks, proceeding from the abstraction 
that 'our revolution is bourgeois 5 , arrive at the idea of 
adapting the whole tactic of the proletariat to the conduct 
of the liberal bourgeoisie, inclusive of their capture of 
state power, the Bolsheviks, proceeding from the same 
naked abstraction : 'democratic, not socialist dictatorship', 
arrive at the idea of the bourgeois democratic self-limita- 
tion of the proletariat in whose hands lies the state power. 
The difference between them in this question is certainly 
quite important : while the anti-revolutionary sides of Men- 
shevism are already expressed in full force today, the anti- 
revolutionary features of Bolshevism threaten to be a 
great danger only in the event of the revolutionary 
victory." 

To this passage in the article, which is reprinted in the 
Russian edition of my book 1905, I made the following 
annotation : 

"As is known, this did not take place, for Bolshevism, 
under the leadership of Lenin (though not without inter- 
nal struggle), accomplished its ideological re-armament in 
this most important question in the spring of 1917, that 
is, before the seizure of power." 

These two quotations have been subjected since 1924 to 
an onslaught of criticism. Now, after a delay of fotir 
years, Radek has also joined in with this criticism. Yet, 
if one reflects conscientiously upon the quoted lines, it 
must be admitted that they contained an important pro- 
gnosis and a no less important warning. The fact does 
remain that at the moment of the February revolution the 
whole so called "old guard" of the Bolsheviks stood on the 
ground of the stark contrasting of the democratic and so- 
cialist dictatorships. Out of Lenin's "algebraic" for- 
mula (allowing of many "arithmetical" interpretations), 
his closest disciples made a purely metaphysical construe- 

121 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

tion and directed it against the real development of the 
revolution. At the most important historical turning 
point, the leadership of the Bolsheviks in Russia adopted 
a reactionary position, and had Lenin not arrived so op- 
portunely, they would have been in a position to strangle 
the October revolution in the name of the struggle against 
Trotskyism, as they later strangled the Chinese revolution,. 
With a pious air Radek describes the false position of the 
whole leading party stratum as a sort of "accident". 
But that has little value as a Marxian explanation of the 
vulgar democratic position of Kamenev, Zinoviev, Stalin, 
Molotov, Rykov, Kalinin, Nogin, Miliutin, Krestinsky,. 
Frunze, Yaroslavsky, Ordjonikidze, Preobrazhensky, 
Smilga, and a dozen other "old Bolsheviks". Would it 
not be more correct to acknowledge that the old algebraic 
Bolshevik formula contained certain dangers within it : 
political development might have, as always used to hap- 
pen with revolutionary formulae not carried out to the 
end, filled it with a content hostile to the proletarian 
revolution. It is self-understood that if Lenin had lived 
in Russia and had observed the development of the party, 
day in and day out, especially during the war, he would 
have given the necessary correctives and interpretations 
in time. Luckily for the revolution, he arrived soon 
enough, even though after a delay, to undertake the neces- 
sary ideological re-armament. The class instinct of the 
proletariat and the revolutionary pressure of the lower 
party strata, prepared by the preceding work of Bolshe- 
vism, made it possible for Lenin, in struggle with the 
leading heads and against them, to switch the policy of 
the party on to a new track in the shortest period of time. 
Does it follow from this that today also we accept for 
China, India and the other countries Lenin's formula of 
1905 in its algebraic inarticulateness, and that we must 
leave it to the Chinese and Indian Stalins and Rykovs 
(Tang Pin Shan, Roy and others) to fill the formula with 
a petty bourgeois national democratic content in order 

122 



"DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP" 

thereupon to wait for the timely appearance of a Lenin 
who will undertake the necessary correctives of April 4? 
Is such a corrective perhaps assured for China and India? 
Or is it not more correct to make the formula right now 
as concrete as historical experience, in China as well as 
in Russia, has taught us ? 

Is what has been stated to be understopd as though the 
slogan of the democratic dictatorship of the proletariat 
and peasantry was simply a "mistake"? Nowadays, as is 
known, all ideas and actions of man are divided into two 
categories : absolutely correct ones, that is, such as fit into 
the "general line", and absolutely false ones, that is, de- 
viations from this line. This naturally does not prevent 
what is absolutely correct today from being declared 
absolutely false to-morrow. But the real development of 
ideas also knew, before the emergence of the "general 
line", the method of successive approaches to the truth. 
Even a simple arithmetical division forces the experi- 
mental selection of figures, in which one begins either with 
the large ones or the small ones, in order to reject them 
at the revision. In shooting at an object, artillery calls 
the method of successive approximations, "Bracket". 
The method of approximation, in politics too, is entirely 
unavoidable. The whole question lies only in perceiving 
in time that a shot fallen short is a shot fallen short and 
in undertaking the necessary corrective without loss of 
time. 

The greatest historical significance of Lenin's formula 
lay in the fact that, under the conditions of a new historical 
epoch, it exhausted one of the most important theoretical 
and political questions of the day, and that was the 
question of the attainable level of political independence 
of the various petty bourgeois groupings, above all, the 
peasantry. Thanks to its completeness, the Bolshevik 
experience of 1905-1917 firmly bolted the door against the 
"democratic dictatorship". With his own hand, Lenin 
wrote the inscription over this door : Neither entrance nor 

123 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

exit. He formulated it in these words : The peasant goes 
either with the bourgeois or with the worker. The epi- 
gones, however, completely ignore this conclusion to 
which the old formula of Bolshevism led, and contrary 
to this conclusion they canonize a provisional hypothesis 
by inserting it into the program. For it is really in this, 
generally speaking, that the essence of epigonism lies. 



124 



CHAPTER SIX 



ON THE SKIPPING OF HISTORICAL 

STAGES 



RADEK DOES not merely repeat a few official critical 
writing exercises of recent years, but he over- 
simplifies them, in so far as that is possible. From his 
words, it follows that I made no distinction at all between 
the bourgeois and the socialist revolutions, between the 
East and the West, neither in 1905 nor today. Following: 
Stalin, Radek too enlightens me on the inadmissibility of 
skipping historical stages. 

Well, then, the question must first of all be put : If in 
1905 it was for me simply a matter of the "socialist revo- 
lution", then why did I then believe that it could begin 
in backward Russia sooner than in advanced Europe? 
Out of patriotism? In fine, out of national pride? And 
yet that is how it did happen. Does Radek grasp this : 
Could the democratic revolution have been realized by us 
as an independent stage, we would not have had today 
the dictatorship of the proletariat. If it came earlier than 
in the West, then it was precisely and only because history 
united the main content of the bourgeois revolution with 
the first stage of the proletarian revolution did not mix 
them up but united them organically. 

To distinguish between the bourgeois and the proletarian 
revolution is political ABC. But after the ABC follow 
the syllables, the combination tof the letters. History 
accomplished just such a combination of the most import- 

125 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

ant letters of the bourgeois alphabet with the first letters 
of the socialist alphabet. Radek, however, would like to 
drag us back from the first finished syllables to the alpha- 
bet. It is sad but true. 

It is nonsense to say that stages can never be skipped. 
The living historical process makes lasting leaps over single 
"stages" which follow from the theoretical division of the 
process of evolution in its entirety, that is, in its maximum 
completeness, and at critical moments demands the same 
of revolutionary policy. It may be said that the first 
distinction between a revolutionist and a vulgar evolu- 
tionist lies in the capacity to recognize and exploit this 
moment, 

Marx's division of the evolution of industry into handi- 
craft, manufacture and factory is part of the A B C of 
political economy, or more precisely, of historico-economic 
theory. In Russia, however, the factory came by skipping 
over the epoch of manufacture and of urban handicrafts. 
These are already the syllables of history. A similar pro- 
cess took place in the country in class relationships and 
politics. The recent history of Russia cannot be compre- 
hended unless the Marxian schema of the three stages is 
known : handicraft, manufacture, factory. But if one 
knows only this, he still comprehends nothing. For the 
fact is that the history of Russia Stalin should not take 
it to heart skipped over many stages. The theoretical 
distinction of the stages, however, is necessary for Russia 
too, otherwise one can comprehend neither what this leap 
consisted of nor what the consequence of it was. 

The matter can also be approached from another side 
(just as Lenin many times approached the dual power), 
and it can be said that Russia went through all three of 
Marx's stages. The first two, however, in an extremely 
concentrated form, in embryo, so to say. These "rudi- 
ments", stages of handicraft and manufacture indicated 
by points, as it were, suffice to confirm the genetic unity 
of the economic process. Here, however, the quantitative 

126 



SKIPPING OF HISTORICAL STAGES 

contraction of the two stages is so great that it engendered 
entirely new qualitative characteristics in the whole social 
structure of the nation.. The most striking expression of 
this new "quality" in politics is the October revolution. 

What is most unbearable in this discussion is the 
"theorizing" of Stalin, with the two trinkets which con- 
stitute his whole theoretical baggage : "the law of un- 
even development" and the "non-skipping of stages". 
Stalin does not understand to this day that the skipping 
of stages , (or remaining too long at one stage) is just 
what the uneven development consists of. 'Against the 
theory of the permanent revolution, Stalin, with inimitable 
seriousness, sets up ... the law of uneven development. 
Yet, the prognosis that historically backward Russia could 
arrive at the proletarian revolution sooner than advanced 
England, rests entirely upon the law of uneven develop- 
ment. Only, for this prognosis, one had to understand 
the historic unevenness in its whole dynamic concreteness, 
and not simply be a permanent repeater of a quotation 
from Lenin in 1915, which is turned upside down and 
interpreted in the manner of an illiterate. 

The dialectic of the historical "stages" is relatively 
easy to understand in periods of revolutionary ascent. 
Reactionary periods, on the contrary, naturally and 
necessarily become epochs of the cheapest evolutionism. 
The Staliniad, this gross ideological vulgarity", the worthy 
daughter of the party reaction, has created a cult of the 
movement of stages, as a cover for its mechanical repeti- 
tion and collection of fragments. This reactionary ideology 
has now been seized upon by Radek, too. 

One stage or another of the historical process can 
prove to be inevitable under certain conditions, although 
theoretically it does not appear inevitable. And con- 
versely : theoretically "inevitable" stages can be com- 
pressed into nothing by the dynamics of development, 
especially during revolutions, which have not been called 
the locomotives of history for nothing. 

127 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

That is how the proletariat, with us, "skipped" the 
stage of democratic parliamentarism, by only granting the 
Constituent Assembly a life of hours, and even that only 
in the backyard of history. But the counter-revolutionary 
stage in China can in no way be skipped over, just as 
with us the period of the four Dumas could not be skipped 
over. The present counter-revolutionary stage in China, 
however, was historically in no sense "unavoidable". It is 
the direct result of the catastrophic policy of Stalin- 
Bucharin, who will pass into history as the organizers of 
defeats. 'And the fruits of opportunism have become an 
objective factor, which can check the revolutionary process 
for a long time. 

Every attempt to skip over real, that is, objectively 
conditioned stages in the development of the masses, 
signifies political adventurism. So long as the majority of 
the working masses have confidence in the social democrats, 
or let us say, the Kuo Min Tang or the trade unionists, 
we cannot pose the task of the immediate overthrow of 
the bourgeois power. The masses must be prepared for 
that. The preparation can prove to be a very long "stage". 
But only a chvostist 15 can believe that "together with the 
masses" we must sit, first in the Right and then in the 
Left Kuo Min Tang, or maintain a bloc with the strike- 
breaker Purcell, until "the mass is disillusioned with its 
leaders" whom we, in the meantime, supported by our 
friendship and invested with authority. 

Radek will hardly have forgotten that many "dialec- 
ticians" characterized the demand for withdrawal from the 
Kuo Min Tang and the break with the Anglo-Russian 
Committee as nothing but a skipping over of stages, and 
besides that, as a separation from the peasantry (in China) 
and from the working masses (in England). Radek ought 
to remember this all the better since he himself belonged 
to the "dialecticians" of this sorry type. At the moment, 
he is only deepening and generalizing his opportunist, 
errors. 

128 



SKIPPING OF HISTORICAL STAGES 

In April 1919, Lenin wrote in a programmatic article* 
The Third International and Its Place in History : 

"We will hardly go wrong when we say that it was 
precisely the contradiction between the backwardness of 
Russia and its 'leap 9 over bourgeois democracy to the 
highest form of democratism to proletarian or Soviet 
democracy, that precisely this contradiction was one of the 
reasons . . . which in the West made especially difficult or 
retarded the understanding of the role of the Soviets." 
(Lenin. Volume XVI, page 183.) 

Lenin says here directly that Russia made a "leap over 
bourgeois democracy". To be sure, Lenin, even if 
indirectly, supplemented this contention with all the 
necessary limitations : the dialectic does not consist of 
always repeating all the concrete conditions; writers take 
it for granted that the reader himself also has something 
in his head. The leap over bourgeois democracy remains 
in spite of that, and makes difficult, according to the 
correct observation of Lenin, the understanding of the role 
of the Soviets for all dogmaticians and schematicists not 
only in the West, but also in the East. 

And in that foreword to the book 1905, which now 
suddenly gives Radek so many headaches, it says : 

"Already in 1905, the Petersburg workers called their 
Soviet a proletarian government. This designation passed 
into the everyday language of that time and completely 
coincided with the program of the struggle of the work- 
ing class for power. At the same time, however, we set 
up against czarism the elaborated program of political 
democracy (universal suffrage, republic, militia, etc.). We 
could act in no other way. Political democracy is a 
necessary stage in the development o/ ( the working masses 
with the highly important reservation that in one case this 
stage lasts for decades, while in the other, the revolu- 
tionary situation permits the masses to emancipate them- 
selves from the prejudices of political democracy even 
before its institutions have been converted into reality. " 

129 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

(Trotsky. 1905, foreword, page 7.) 

These words, which, by the by, are in complete accord 
with the ideas of Lenin quoted ;by me, sufficiently ex- 
plain, it seems to me, the necessity of setting up against the 
dictatorship of the Kuo Min Tang the "elaborated 
program of political democracy". But it is precisely at 
this point that Badek attacks from the Left. In the epoch 
of the revolutionary ascent he resisted the withdrawal of 
the Chinese Communist Party from the Kuo Min Tang. 
In the epoch of the counter-revolutionary dictatorship, he 
resists the mobilization of the Chinese workers under the 
slogan of democracy. This amounts to wearing furs in 
summer and going naked in winter. 



ISO 



CHAPTER SEVEN 



WHAT DOES THE SLOGAN OF THE 

DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP MEAN 

TODAY FOR THE EAST? 



STUMBLING into the Stalinist evolutionary philis- 
tine, but not revolutionary conception of the 
historical "stages", Radek too now endeavours to canonize 
the slogan of the democratic dictatorship of the proletariat 
and the peasantry for the whole East. Out of the working 
hypothesis of Bolshevism, which Lenin adapted to the 
course of development of a definite country, which he 
changed, concretized and at a certain stage rejected, Radek 
makes a supra-historical schema. On this point he per- 
sistently repeats the following in his articles : 

"This theory, as well as the tactic flowing from it, is 
applicable to all countries with a young capitalist develop- 
ment, in which the bourgeoisie has not solved the problems 
which the preceding social-political formations have left 
behind as a heritage." 

Just reflect upon this formula : is it not a solemn 
justification of Kamenev's position in 1917? Did the 
Russian bourgeoisie liquidate the problems of the demo- 
cratic revolution by the February revolution? No, they 
remained unsolved, including the most important of them, 
the agrarian problem. How could Lenin fail to compre- 
hend that the old formula was still "applicable 55 ? Why 
did he withdraw it? 

' Radek answered us on this point before : because it 
had already "been realized 55 . We have examined this 

181 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

answer. It is completely untenable, doubly untenable in 
the mouth of Radek, who holds the view that the essence 
of the old Leninist formula does not at all lie in the forms 
of power but in the actual liquidation of serfdom by the 
collaboration of the proletariat and the peasantry. But 
this is precisely what the Kerenskiad did not produce. 
From this it follows that Radek's excursion into our past 
for the purpose of solving the most timely question of the 
day, the Chinese question, is altogether absurd. It is not 
what, Trotsky understood or failed to understand in 1905 
that should have been investigated, but rather what Stalin, 
Molotov and especially Rykov and Kamenev did not grasp 
in February-March 1917 (what Radek's position was in 
those days, I do not know). For if one believes that the 
democratic dictatorship was "realized" to such an extent 
in the dual power as to require a change of the central 
slogan, then one must recognize that the "democratic 
dictatorship" in China was realized still more completely 
and more fundamentally through the regime of the Kuo 
Min Tang, that is, through the rule of Chiang Kai-Shek 
and Wang Chin Wei, with Tang Pin Shan as appendage. 16 
It was all the more necessary, therefore, to change the 
slogan of China. 

Is then the "heritage of the preceding social-political 
formations" liquidated in China? No, it is not yet 
liquidated. But was it liquidated by us on April 4, 1917, 
when Lenin declared war upon the whole upper stratum oi 
the "old Bolsheviks" ? Radek contradicts himself hope- 
lessly, blunders and reels from side to side. Let us remark 
in this connection that it is not entirely accidental that 
he uses so complicated and circumlocutory an expressior 
as "heritage of the formations", varied at different passages 
and obviously avoids the clearer term : "remnants o 
feudalism, or of serfdom". Why? Because Radek onh 
yesterday denied these remnants most decisively am 
thereby tore away any basis for the slogan of the demo 
cratic dictatorship. In his report in the Communis 

182 



MEANING OF DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP 

Academy, Radek said: 

"The resources of the Chinese revolution are no less 
deep than were the resources of our revolution in 1905. 
One can assert with certainty that the alliance of the 
working class with the peasantry will be stronger there 
than it was with us in 1905, for the simple reason that it 
will not be directed against two classes 9 but only against 
one, the bourgeoisie." 

Yes, "for the simple reason". Now, when the pro- 
letariat, together with the peasantry, directs itself against 
one class, the bourgeoisie not against the remnants of 
feudalism, but against the bourgeoisie what if you 
please is such a revolution called ? Perhaps a democratic 
revolution? Just notice that Radek said this not in 1905, 
and not even in 1909, but in March 1927. How is this to 
be understood ? Very simply. In March 1927, Radek also 
deviated from the right road, only in another direction. 
In its theses on the Chinese question, the Opposition 
inserted a most important correction to Radek's onesided- 
ness of, that time. But in the words just quoted there was 
nevertheless a kernel of truth : there is almost no class of 
landowners in China, the landowners are much more 
intimately bound up with the capitalists than in czarist 
Russia, the specific weight of the agrarian question in 
China is therefore much lighter than in czarist Russia ; but 
for that, the question of national liberation occupies a 
large place. Accordingly, the capacity of the Chinese 
peasantry for independent revolutionary political struggle 
for the democratic renovation of the country can in no 
case be greater than was the Russian peasantry's. This 
found its expression, among other things, in the fact that 
neither before 1925 nor during the three years of the 
revolution in China, did a people's party arise which 
inscribed the agrarian revolution upon its banner. All this 
taken together demonstrates that for China, which has 
already left behind it the experience of 1925-1927, the 
formula of the democratic dictatorship presents a much 

188 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

more dangerous reactionary snare than in Russia after the 
February revolution. 

Still another excursion by Radek in an even further 
distant past, turns just as mercilessly against him. In this 
case, it is concerned with the slogan of the permanent 
revolution which Marx raised in 1850 : 

"With Marx," writes Radek, "there was no slogan of 
a democratic dictatorship, while with Lenin, from 1905 to 
1917, it was the political axis, and formed a component 
part of his conception of the revolution in all (? !) 
countries of a beginning (?) capitalist development." 

Basing himself upon a few lines from Lenin, Radek 
explains this difference of positions by the fact that the 
central task of the German revolution was national 
unification, while with us it was the agrarian question. 
If this contrast is not mechanized, and due regard is had 
for proportion, then it is correct up to a certain point. 
But then what is to happen with China? The specific 
weight of the national problem in China, a semi-colonial 
country, is immeasurably greater in comparison with the 
agrarian problem than it was even in Germany in 1848- 
1850; for in China it is simultaneously a question of 
unification as well as of liberation. Marx formulated his 
perspectives of the permanent revolution when, in Germany, 
all the thrones still stood firm, the Junkers held the land, 
and the leaders of the bourgeoisie were tolerated only in 
the antechamber of the government. In China, there has 
been no monarchy since 1911, there is no independent 
landowning class, the national bourgeois Kuo Min Tang 
is in power, the relationships of serfdom are, so to speak, 
chemically fused with bourgeois exploitation. The con- 
trast of the positions of Marx and Lenin undertaken by 
Radek thereby speaks entirely against the slogan of the 
democratic dictatorship in China. 

But Radek does not even take up the position of Marx 
seriously, only ill passing, episodically, confining himself to 
the -circular of 1850, where Marx still considered the 

184 



MEANING OF DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP 

peasantry the natural allies of the petty bourgeois city 
democracy. Marx at that time expected the independent 
stage of the democratic revolution in Germany, that is, the 
temporary assumption of power by the city petty bour- 
geois radicals, supported by the peasantry. There's the 
rub! That, however, is just what did not happen. And 
not accidentally. Already in the middle of the past 
century, the petty bourgeois democracy showed itself to 
be powerless to carry out its revolution independently. 
And Marx took up this lesson in his calculations. On 
April 16, 1856 that is, six years after the circular men- 
tioned Marx wrote to Engels : 

"The whole matter in Germany will depend upon the 
possibility of supporting the proletarian revolution with a 
sort of second edition of the peasant war. Then the thing 
will be excellent." 

These splendid words, completely forgotten by Radek, 
constitute a truly invaluable key to the October revolution 
as well as to the whole problem that occupies us here. 
Did Marx skip over the agrarian revolution? No, as we 
see, he did not skip over it. Did he consider the colla- 
boration of the proletariat and the peasantry necessary in 
the next revolution? Yes, he did. Did he grant the 
possibility of the leading, or even only the independent 
role of the peasantry in the revolution? No, he did not 
grant this possibility. He proceeded from the fact that 
the peasantry, which had not succeeded in supporting the 
bourgeois democracy in the independent democratic revo- 
lution (through the fault of the bourgeois democracy, not 
the peasantry), would be in a position to support the pro- 
letariat in the proletarian revolution. "Then the thing 
will be excellent." Radek, however, does not want to see 
that this is what happened in October, 
happen badly at that. 

With regard to China, the conclusion 
this are quite clear. The dispute is nolj 
r61e of the peasantry as an ally, and 

135 




PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

significance of the agrarian revolution, but over whether 
an independent agrarian democratic revolution is possible 
in China or whether "a second edition of the peasant war" 
will give support to the proletarian revolution. That is 
the only way the question stands. Whoever puts it 
differently, has learned nothing and understood nothing, 
only confuses the Chinese Communist Party and drives it 
off the right track. 

In order for the proletariat of the Eastern countries 
to open the road to victory, the pedantic reactionary theory 
of Stalin-Martinov on "stages" and " steps" must be 
eliminated at the very outset, must be cast aside, demo- 
lished and swept away with a broom. Bolshevism grew in 
the struggle against this vulgar evolutionism. It is not to 
a line of march marked out a priori that we must adapt 
ourselves, but to the real course of the class struggle. 
Away with the Stalin-Kuusinen idea: to prescribe a suc- 
cession for the countries of various degrees of development, 
to apportion them in advance with revolutionary rations 
by card. One must adapt oneself to the real course of 
the class struggle. An inestimable guide for this is Lenin ; 
only, the whole Lenin must be taken into consideration. 

When in 1919, Lenin, especially in connection with the 
organization of the Communist International, combined 
into a unit the conclusions out of the period gone by, and 
gave it an ever more rounded-out theoretical formulation, 
he interpreted the experience of the Kerenskiad and the 
October as follows : In a bourgeois society with already 
developed class antagonisms there can only be either an 
open or disguised dictatorship of the bourgeoisie, or the 
dictatorship of the proletariat. There cannot be any talk 
of a transitional regime. Every democracy, every "dic- 
tatorship of democracy" (the ironical quotation marks are 
Lenin's) is only a veil for the rule of the bourgeoisie, as 
the experience of the most backward European country, 
Russia, showed in the epoch of the bourgeois revolution, 
that is, in an epoch favourable to the "dictatorship of 

136 



MEANING OF DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP 

democracy 55 . This conclusion was taken by Lenin as the 
basis for his theses on democracy, which arose only as the 
sum of the experiences of the February and October 
revolutions. 

Like many others, Radek also separates mechanically 
the question of democracy from the question of the demo- 
cratic dictatorship in general. The "democratic dictator- 
ship", however, can only be the masked rule of the bour- 
geoisie in the revolution. This is taught us by the 
experience of our "dual power " of .1917 as well as by the 
experience of the Chinese Kuo Min Tang. 

The hopelessness of the epigones is most crassly 
expressed in the fact that even now they still attempt to 
contrast the democratic dictatorship to the dictatorship of 
the bourgeoisie, as well as to the dictatorship of the pro- 
letariat. But this means that the democratic dictatorship 
must have a transitional character, that is, a petty bour- 
geois content. The participation of the proletariat in it 
does not change the situation, for there is no arithmetical 
average in nature of the various class lines. If it is 
neither the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie nor the dictator- 
ship of the proletariat, then it means that the petty 
bourgeoisie must play the determining and decisive role. 
But this brings us back to the question to which the three 
Russian and the two Chinese revolutions have answered in 
practise : Is the petty bourgeoisie today, under the condi- 
tions of the world domination of imperialism, capable of 
playing a leading revolutionary role in the capitalist 
countries, which are still confronted with the solution of 
their democratic tasks ? 

There have been epochs in which the lower strata of 
the petty bourgeoisie were able to set up their revolu- 
tionary dictatorship. That we know. But they were 
epochs in which the proletariat or prescursors of the pro- 
letariat of the time was not distinguished from the petty 
bourgeoisie, but on the contrary constituted in its un- 
developed condition its fighting core. Quite different 

187 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

today. We cannot speak of the ability of the petty bour- 
geoisie to direct the life of present-day, even if backward, 
bourgeois society, in so far as the proletariat has separated 
itself from the petty bourgeoisie and is pitted antagonistic- 
ally against the big bourgeoisie on the basis of capitalist 
development, which condemns the petty bourgeoisie to 
vegetation and puts the peasantry before the political 
choice between the bourgeoisie and the proletariat. Every 
time the peasantry seemingly decides for a petty bourgeois 
party, it actually supports on its back finance capital. If, 
in the period of the first Russian revolution, or in the 
period between the first two revolutions, there could still 
exist differences of opinion over the degree of independence 
(but only the degree!) of the peasantry and the petty 
bourgeoisie in the democratic revolution, now this question 
has been decided by the whole course of the events of the 
last twelve years, and decided irrevocably. 

It was raised anew in practise after the October in 
various countries, and in various forms and combinations, 
and everywhere it was settled the same way. The most 
fundamental experience after the Kerenskiad is, as already 
mentioned, the Kuo Min Tang. But no lesser importance 
is to be attached to the experiment of Fascism in Italy, 
where the petty bourgeoisie with arms in hand, snatched 
the power from the old bourgeois parties in order to 
surrender immediately, through its leaders, to the financial 
oligarchy. The same question arose in Poland, where the 
Pilsudski movement was aimed directly against the 
reactionary bourgeois landowning government and mirrored 
the hopes of the petty bourgeois masses and even a wide 
circle of the proletariat. It is no accident that the old 
Polish social democrat, Warski, out of fear of "under- 
estimating the peasantry", identified the Pilsudski over- 
throw with the "democratic dictatorship of the workers 
and peasants' 5 ; It would lead us too far afield if I were 
to analyse here the Bulgarian experiences, that is, the dis- 
graceful policy of confusion of the Kolarovs and Kabakt- 

138 



MEANING OF DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP 

chievs towards the party of Stambuliski, or the shameful 
experiment with the Farmer-Labor party in the United 
States, or Zinoviev's romance with Raditch, or the experi- 
ments of the Communist Party of Rumania, and so on 
and so forth without end. Some of these questions are ana- 
lyzed in their essential parts in my Criticism of the Pro- 
gram of the Comintern. The fundamental conclusion con- 
firms and strengthens completely the lesson of October: 
The petty bourgeoisie, together with the peasantry, is in- 
capable of the r61e of leader in modern, even if backward, 
bourgeois society, in revolutionary as well as in re- 
actionary epochs. The peasantry can either support the 
dictatorship of the bourgeoisie, or serve to prop up the 
dictatorship of the proletariat. Transitional forms are 
only a disguise of the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie 
which has begun to totter or, after a shock, has come to 
its feet again (Kerenskiad, Fascism, Pilsudski regime). 

The peasantry can go either with the bourgeoisie or 
with the proletariat. But when the proletariat attempts 
to march at all costs with the peasantry, which does not 
yet follow it, the proletariat proves inevitably to be in 
tow of finance capital : workers as defenders of the father- 
land in Russia in 1917; workers, including the Commu- 
nists as well, in the Kuo Min Tang in China ; workers, 
among them the Communists in part as well, in the Polish 
Socialist Party in Poland in 1926, etc. 

Whoever does not think this out to the end, and who 
has not understood the events from the fresh trail they 
have left behind, had better not delve into revolutionary 
politics. 

The most fundamental conclusion which Lenin drew 
from the lessons of the February and the October revolu- 
tions, and drew exhaustively and comprehensively, 
thoroughly rejects the idea of the "democratic dictator- 
ship". The following was repeated by Lenin since 1918 
more than once : 

"'All political economy if one has learned anything 

189 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

at all from it the whole history of the revolution, the 
whole history of political development during the nine- 
teenth century, teaches us that the peasant goes either 
with the worker or with the bourgeois. If you do not 
know this, I would like to say to such citizens . . just 
reflect upon the development of any one of the great re- 
volutions of the eighteenth or the nineteenth centuries, 
.upon the political history of any country in the nineteenth 
century. It will tell you why. The economy of capita- 
list society is such that the ruling power can only be either 
capital or the proletariat which overthrows it. Other 
forces there are none in the economics of this society." 
(Volume XVI, page 217.) 

It is not a matter here of modern England or Ger- 
many. On the basis of the lessons of any one of the 
great revolutions of the eighteenth or the nineteenth 
centuries, that is, of the bourgeois revolutions in the 
backward countries, Lenin comes to the conclusion that 
only the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie or the dictator- 
ship of the proletariat is possible. There cannot be a 
"democratic", that is, an intermediate dictatorship. 



His theoretical and historical excursion is summed up 
by Radek, as we see, in the rather poor aphorism that 
the bourgeois revolution must be distinguished from the 
socialist. Sinking down to this "level", Radek straight- 
way stretches out a finger to Kuusinen who, proceeding 
from his one lone resource, that is, "healthy common 
sense", considers it improbable that the slogan of the 
proletarian dictatorship can be raised in the advanced as 
well as in the backward countries. With the candor of 
a man who understands nothing, Kuusinen convicts 
Trotsky of having "learned nothing" since 1905. Follow- 
ing Kuusinen, Radek also becomes ironical : for Trotsky 
"the peculiarity of the Chinese and Indian revolutions 

140 



MEANING ,OF DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP 

consists precisely of the fact that they are in no way 
distinguished from the western European revolutions and 
must therefore, in the first steps ( ? !) lead to the dictator- 
ship of the proletariat". 

Radek forgets one trifle in this connection: The dic- 
tatorship of the proletariat was not realized in a western 
European country, but precisely in a backward eastern 
European country. Is it Trotsky's fault that the histori- 
cal process overlooked the "peculiarity" of Russia? Radek 
forgets further that the bourgeoisie, that is, more precisely 
expressed, finance capital, rules in all the capitalist coun- 
tries, with all the multiplicity of the degrees of develop- 
ment of the social structures, traditions, etc., that it, with 
all their "peculiarity". Here again, the lock of respect 
for this peculiarity proceeds from the historical develop- 
ment but in no case from Trotsky. 

Then wherein lies the distinction between the advanced 
and the backward countries? The distinction is great, 
but it still remains within the confines of the domination 
of capitalist relationships. The forms and methods of the 
rule of the bourgeoisie differ greatly in different countries. 
!At one pole, the domination bears a stark and absolute 
character : the United States. At the other pole, finance 
capital adapts itself to the outlived institutions of the 
Asiatic Middle Ages, by subjecting them to it and imposing 
its methods upon them : India. But the bourgeoisie rules 
in both places. From this it follows that the dictatorship 
of the proletariat also will have a highly varied character 
with regard to the social basis, the political forms, the 
immediate tasks and the tempo of the work in the various 
capitalist countries. But to lead the masses of the people 
to victory over the bloc of the imperialists, the feudal find 
the national bourgeoisie, can be done only by the revolu- 
tionary hegemony of the proletariat, which transforms 
itself after the seizure of power into the dictatorship of 
the proletariat. 

Radek fancies that when he has divided humanity into 

141 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

two groups : into one which has "matured" for the socialist 
dictatorship, and into another which has "matured" only 
for the democratic dictatorship, he has by this alone, in 
contrast to me, taken into consideration the imaginary 
"peculiarity" of the individual countries. In reality, he 
has turned out a lifeless blueprint which can only divert 
the Communists from a genuine study of the peculiarity 
of every country. Yet, the correct system of the tasks and 
actions of a reliable program of struggle for influence 
upon the masses of workers and peasants can arise only 
out of the most minute study of the real peculiarity of a 
given country, that is, of the living texture of the levels 
and stages of historical development. 

The peculiarities of a country which has not accom- 
plished or completed its democratic revolution are of such 
great significance that they must be taken as the basis for 
the program of the proletarian vanguard. Only upon 
the basis of such a national program can a Communist 
party develop its real and successful struggle for the 
majority of the working class and the toilers in general 
against the bourgeoisie and their democratic agents. 

The possibility of success in this struggle is of course 
determined to a/ large extent by the role of the proletariat 
in the economy of the country, that is, by the degree of 
its capitalist development. This, however, is by no means 
the only criterion. No less important is the question 
whether so far-reaching and burning a "problem of the 
people" exists in the country, in the solution of which' the 
majority of the nation is interested, and which demands 
for its solution the boldest revolutionary measures. To 
problems of this kind are counted the agrarian question 
and the national question, in their most varied combina- 
tions. With the accentuated agrarian problems and with 
the insupportability of the national subjugation in the 
colonial countries, the young and relatively not numerous 
proletariat can come to power, on the basis of a national 
democratic revolution, sooner than the proletariat of an 

142 



MEANINQ OF DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP 

advanced country on the basis of a purely socialist revo- 
lution. It would seem that after the October it would not 
be necessary to prove this any more. But through the 
years of ideological reaction and through the theoretical 
depravity of the epigones, the elementary conceptions of 
the revolution have become so rank, so putrid and so ... 
Kuusinified, that one is compelled each time to begin all 
over again. 

Does it follow from what has been said that all the 
countries of the world, in one way or another, are already 
to-day ripe for the socialist revolution ? No, this is a false, 
a dead, scholastic, Stalinist-Bucharinist way of putting the 
question. World economy in its entirety is indubitably ripe 
for socialism. But this does not mean that every country in- 
dividually is ripe. Then what is to happen with the dictator- 
ship of the proletariat in the various backward countries, in 
China, India, etc, ? To this we answer : History is not 
made to order. A country can become "ripe" for the dic- 
tatorship of the proletariat not only before it is ripe for the 
independent construction of socialism, v but even before it is 
ripe for far-reaching socialization measures. One must not 
proceed from a preconceived harmony of social evolution. 
The law of uneven development still lives, despite the tender 
theoretical embraces of Stalin. The force of this law 
operates not only in the relations of countries to each 
other, but also in the mutual relationships of the various 
processes within a country. A reconciliation of the uneven 
processes of economics and politics can be attained only 
on a world scale. Especially does this mean that the ques- 
tion of the dictatorship of the proletariat in China cannot 
be considered exclusively within the limits of Chinese eco- 
nomics a"nd Chinese politics. 

Here we run right up against the two mutually ex- 
clusive standpoints : the international revolutionary 
theory of the permanent revolution and the national 
reformist theory of socialism in one country. Not 
only backward China, but in general, no country in the 

143 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

world can build up socialism within its own national limits : 
the highly developed productive forces, which have grown 
out beyond the national boundaries, resist this just as do 
the forces insufficiently developed for nationalization. The 
dictatorship of the proletariat in England, for example, 
would encounter difficulties and contradictions, different 
in character, it is true, but not slighter ones than those that 
will offer opposition to the dictatorship of the proletariat 
in China. To surmount these contradictions is possible in 
both cases only by way of the international revolution. 
This standpoint leaves no room for the question of the 
"maturity" or "immaturity" of China for the socialist 
transformation. What remains indisputable here is that 
the backwardness of China makes the tasks of the prole- 
tarian dictatorship extremely difficult. But we repeat: 
history is not made to order, and nobody has placed the 
Chinese proletariat before a choice. 

Does this at least mean that every country, including 
the most backward colonial country, is ripe, if not for 
socialism, then for the dictatorship of the proletariat ? No, 
this is not what it means. Then what is to happen with 
the democratic revolution in general and in the colonies 
in particular ? Where is it written I answer the question 
with another question that every colonial country is ripe 
for the immediate and thoroughgoing solution of its na- 
tional democratic problems ? The question must be 
approached from the other end. Under the conditions of 
the imperialist age, the national democratic revolution can 
be carried through to a victorious end only when the social 
and political relationships of the country are mature for 
putting the proletariat in power as the leader of the masses 
of the people. 'And if this is not yet the case ? Then the 
struggle for national liberation will produce only very partial 
results, results directed against the toiling masses. In 1905, 
the proletariat of Russia did not prove to be strong enough 
to unite the peasant masses around it and to conquer power. 
For this reason, the revolution remained standing half way 

144 



MEANING OF DEMOCEATIC DICTATORSHIP 

along the road, and sank deeper and deeper. In China., 
where, in spite of the exceptional favorable situation, the 
leadership of the Communist International prevented the 
Chinese proletariat from fighting for power, the national 
problems found a miserable, vacillating, shabby solution in 
the regime of the Kuo Min Tang. 

When and under what conditions a colonial country 
becomes ripe for the real revolutionary solution of its agra- 
rian and its national problems, cannot be foretold. But 
in any case, we can assert today with full certainty that 
not only China, but also India, will attain genuine popular 
democracy, only through the dictatorship of the proletariat. 
On that road, many stages, steps and phases can still arise. 
Under the pressure of the masses of the people, the bour- 
geoisise will still take various steps to the Left, in order then 
to turn all the more mercilessly against the people. Periods 
of dual power are possible and probable. But what there 
will not be, what there cannot be, is a genuine 
democratic dictatorship that is not the dictatorship 
of the proletariat. An "independent" democratic dictator- 
ship can only be of the type of the Kuo Min Tang, that is, 
directed entirely against the workers and the peasants. We 
must understand this at the outset and teach it to the 
masses, without hiding the class realities behind abstract 
formulae. 

Stalin and Bucharin preached that, thanks to the 
yoke of imperialism, the bourgeoisie could carry out the 
national revolution in China. The attempt was made. 
With what results ? The proletariat was put to the sword. 
Then it was said : the democratic dictatorship is next. 
The petty bourgeois dictatorship proved to be a masked 
dictatorship of capital. By accident ? No. "The peasant 
goes either with the worker or with the bourgeois. " In 
the first case, the dictatorship of the proletariat arises, in 
the other, the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie. It would 
seem that the Chinese lesson is clear enough, even if studied 
from afar. "No," we are answered, "that was only an 

145 
10 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

abortive attempt, we want to begin everything all over 
again and this time set up the 'genuine' democratic 
dictatorship." "In what way?" "On the social basis of 
the collaboration of the proletariat and the peasantry." 
It is Radek who presents us with this latest discovery. 
But, if you will permit, the Kuo Min Tang arose on that 
very same basis: workers and peasants "together" hauled 
the chestnuts out of the fire for the bourgeoisie. Tell us 
what the political mechanics of this collaboration will look 
like. How do you want to replace the Kuo Min Tang? 
What parties will be in power? Name them at least 
approximately, hint at them ! To this Radek answers 
(in 1928!) that only people who are all done for, who are 
incapable of understanding the complexity of Marxism, can 
be interested in the incidental technical question of which 
class will be the horse and which the rider. A Bolshevik 
must "divert" attention from the political superstructure 
in favour of the class basis. Come, you will have your 
little joke ! There has been enough "diversion" ! More 
than enough ! In China, they diverted attention from the 
question of the party expression of the collaboration of the 
classes, they led the proletariat into the Kuo Min Tang, 
they were enraptured by the Kuo Min Tang to the point 
of self-oblivion, they furiously resisted the withdrawal 
from the Kuo Min Tang, they cringed from political ques- 
tion of struggle by the repetition of abstract formulae ; 
and after the bourgeoisie had very concretely broken the 
skull of the proletariat, they recommend to us : Let us try 
all over again. And as a beginning, we once more want 
to "divert" attention from the question of the parties and 
the revolutionary power. No, These are very poor jokes. 
We will not allow ourselves to be pulled back again ! 

All these acrobatics, as we have perceived, are pre- 
sented in the interest of an alliance of the workers and 
peasants. Radek warns the Opposition against an 
underestimation of the peasantry and recalls the struggle of 
Lenin against the Mensheviks. If one considers all the 

146 



MEANING OF DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP 

things that are contrived with Lenin's quotations, it is often 
enough to make one sick. Yes, Lenin said more than once 
that the denial of the revolutionary role of the peasantry 
is characteristic of the Mensheviks. And that was right. 
But besides these quotations, there nevertheless did come 
the year 1917, in which the Mensheviks spent the eight 
months which separated the Ferbuary from the October 
revolution, in a firm bloc with the Social Revolutionists. 
In that period, however, the Social Revolutionists re- 
presented the overwhelming majority of the peasantry 
awakened by the revolution. Together with the S. R.s, the 
Mensheviks called themselves the revolutionary democracy 
and remonstrated with us that they were the very ones who 
based themselves upon the alliance of the workers with the 
peasants (soldiers). Accordingly, the Mensheviks, so to 
speak, expropriated the Bolshevik formula of the alliance 
of the workers and peasants after the February revolution. 
The Bolsheviks were accused by them of wanting to split 
the proletarian vanguard from the peasantry and thereby 
to destroy the revolution. In other words, the Mensheviks 
accused Lenin of ignoring, or at least, of underestimating 
the peasantry. 

The criticism of Kamenev, Zinoviev and others against 
Lenin was only an echo of the criticism of the Mensheviks. 
The present criticism of Radek in turn is only a belated 
echo of the criticism of Kamenev. 

The policy of the epigones in China, including the 
policy of Radek, is the continuation and the further 
development of the Menshevik masquerade of 1917, The 
fact that the Communist party remained in the Kuo Min 
Tang was defended not only by Stalin, but also by Radek, 
with the same reference to the necessity of the alliance of 
the workers and peasants. But when it was "accidentally" 
shown that the Kuo Min Tang was a bourgeois party, the 
attempt was repeated with the "Left" Kuo Min Tang. The 
results were the same. Thereupon, the abstraction of the 
democratic dictatorship, in distinction from the dictator- 

147 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

ship of the proletariat, was elevated above this sorry reality 
which had not fulfilled the high hopes. A new repetition 
of what we already had. In 1917, we heard a hundred times 
from Tseretelli, Dan and the others : "We have the dic- 
tatorship of the revolutionary democracy, but you are 
driving towards the dictatorship of the proletariat, that is, 
towards destruction." In truth, people have short memo- 
ries. The "revolutionary democratic dictatorship" of 
Stalin and Radek is in no way distinguished from the 
"dictatorship of the revolutionary democracy" of Tseretelli 
and Dan. And in spite of that, this formula not only runs 
through all the resolutions of the Comintern, but it has 
also penetrated into its program. It is hard to conceive a 
more cunning masquerade and at the same time a more bitter 
revenge of Menshevism for the affronts which Bolshevism 
heaped upon it in 1917. 

The revolutionists of the East, however, still have the 
right to demand a concrete answer to the question of the 
character of the "democratic dictatorship", based not upon 
old, a priori quotations, but upon facts and upon political 
experience. To the question : What is a "democratic 
dictatorship" ? Stalin has repeatedly given the truly classic 
reply : For the East, for example, it is the same as "Lenin 
conceived it with regard to the 1905 revolution". This has 
become the official formula to a certain extent. It can be 
found in the books and resolutions devoted to China, India 
or Polynesia. Revolutionists are referred to Lenin 's "con- 
ceptions" concerning future events, which in the meantime 
have long ago become past events, and in addition, the 
hypothetical "conceptions" of Lenin are one-sidedly and 
crookedly interpreted, at all events, not in the way that 
Lenin himself construed them after the events. 

"All right," says the Communist of the East, hanging 
his head, "we will try to conceive of it exactly as Lenin, 
according to your words, conceived of it before the revolu- 
tion. But won't you please tell us what this slogan looks 
Jike in actuality ? How was it realized with you ?" 

148 



MEANING OF DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP 

"With us, it was realized as the Kerenskiad in the 
epoch of the dual power." 

"Can we tell our workers that the s!6gan of the 
democratic dictatorship will be realized by us as a national 
Kerenskiad?" 

"Come, come ! Not at all ! No worker will adopt such 
a slogan : the Kerenskiad is lackeydom before the bour- 
geoisie and a betrayal of the toilers." 

"But how, then, must we say it to our workers ?" the 
Communist of the East asks sadly. 

"You must say," impatiently answers the sentinel 
Kuusinen, "that the democratic dictatorship is the one 
that Lenin conceived of with regard to the future demo- 
cratic revolution." 

If the Communist of the East is not lacking in a certain 
thoughtfulness, he will seek to rejoin : 

"But didn't Lenin declare in 1918 that the democratic 
dictatorship first found its genuine and true realization in 
the October revolution through the setting up of the dic- 
tatorship of the proletariat ? Would it not be better to 
orientate the party and the working class towards this 
perspective?" 

"Under no circumstances. Do not even dare to think 
about it. Why, that is the per-r-r-manent r-r-r-evolution ! 
That's Tr-r-r-otskyism ! " 

After this harsh reprimand the Communist of the East 
turns paler than the snow on the highest peaks of the 
Himalayas and abandons any further craving for know- 
ledge. Let come what may ! 

And the consequences ? We know them well : either 
contemptible grovelling before Chiang Kai-Shek, or heroic 
adventures. 



149 



CHAPTER EIGHT 



FROM MARXISM TO PACIFISM 



WHAT is perhaps most disquieting, symptomatically, 
is a passage in Radek's article which, as it were, 
stands apart from the central theme that interests us, but 
which is intimately bound up with this theme by the uni- 
formity of Radek's shift towards the present theoreticians 
of Centrism. It is a question of the somewhat disguised 
advances towards the theory of socialism in one country. 
One must dwell on this, for this "sideline" of Radek's 
errors can surpass all the other differences of opinion in its 
further development, and it may transpire that its quantity 
has in the end turned into quality. 

It is a question of the dangers that threaten the revolu- 
tion from without. Radek writes that Lenin "... was 
conscious of the fact that with the degree of the economic 
development of Russia in 1905 this (the proletarian) dic- 
tatorship can maintain itself only if the western European 
proletariat comes to its aid". (My emphasis. L. T.) 

One mistake after another, above all, a very crude 
violation of the historical perspective. In reality Lenin said 
and that more than once, that the democratic dictatorship 
(but not the proletarian) in Russia would be unable to 
maintain itself without the socialist revolution in Europe. 
This thought runs like a thread through all the articles and 
speeches of Lenin in the days of the Stockholm party con- 
vention in 1906 (polemic against Plechanov, questions of 

150 



FROM MARXISM TO PACIFISM 

the nationalization of the land, dangers of the restoration, 
etc.). In that period, Lenin did not even raise the question 
of a proletarian dictatorship in Russia before the socialist 
revolution in western Europe. But it is not there that the 
most important thing lies for the moment. What is the 
meaning of "with the degree of the economic development 
of Russia in 1905" ? And how do matters stand with the 
degree in 1917 ? It is on this difference in degree that the 
theory of socialism in one country is erected* The program 
of the Comintern has divided the whole globe into squares 
which are " adapted " to the independent construction of 
socialism and those which are "not adapted", and has 
thereby created the revolutionary strategy of a series of 
hopeless blind alleys. The difference in economic degree 
can undoubtedly be of decisive significance for the political 
power of the working class. In 1905, we could not raise 
ourselves to the dictatorship of the proletariat, just as for 
that matter, we were unable to rise to the democratic dic- 
tatorship. In 1917, we set up the dictatorship of the pro- 
letariat which embraced the democratic dictatorship. -But 
with the economic degree of development of 1917, as well 
as with the economic degree of 1905, the dictatorship can 
maintain itself and develop to socialism only when the 
western European proletariat comes opportunely to its 
assistance. It is obvious that this "opportuneness" cannot 
be calculated in advance : it is determined by the course 
of development and the struggle. 'As against this funda- 
mental question, determined by the international relation 
of forces which have the last and decisive word, the differ- 
ence in degree of development of Russia in 1905 and in 1917, 
however important it is in itself, is a factor of secondary 
order. 

But Radek does not content himself with the ambigu- 
ous reference to this difference of degree. After he has 
referred to the fact that Lenin saw the connection of the 
inner problems of the revolution with its world problems 
(Indeed!), Radek adds: 

151 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

"Lenin did not sharpen the conception of this connec- 
tion between the maintenance of tfye socialist dictatorship 
in Russia and the aid of the western European proletariat 
through the excessively accentuated formulation of Trotsky, 
namely, that it must be a state aid, that is, the aid of the 
already victorious western European proletariat." (My 
emphasis. L. T.) 

Frankly, I did not trust my eyes when I read these 
lines. To what end did Radek require this worthless weapon 
from the arsenal of the epigones? This is really nothing 
more than a stale reproduction of the Stalinist banalities, 
which we always used to make such thorough game of. 
Outside of everything else, the quotation shows that Radek 
has a very bad notion of the fundamental landmarks of 
the Leninist path. Lenin, unlike Stalin, never contrasted 
the pressure of the European proletariat upon the bourgeois 
power to the capture of power by the proletariat; on the 
contrary, he formulated the question of revolutionary aid 
from without much more sharply than I. In the epoch of 
the first revolution, he repeated tirelessly that we would 
not retain the democracy (even the democracy!) without 
the socialist revolution in Europe. In 1917-1918 and the 
years that followed, Lenin did not consider and estimate 
the fate of our 'revolution in general in any way other than 
in connection with the socialist revolution that had begun 
in Europe. He asserted openly, for example : "Without 
the victory of the revolution in Germany, we are doomed." 
He said this in 1918, that is, not with the "economic degree 
of development" of 1905, and he did not mean future de- 
cades, but the shortest periods, which were to be measured 
by a few years if not by months. 

Lenin declared dozens of times : if we have held out, 
"then only because a special combination of circumstances 
has protected us from international imperialism for a brief 
moment (for a brief moment ! L. T.)". And further : 
"International imperialism . . . can in no way and under 
no circumstances come to terms with a Soviet republic 

152 



FROM MARXISM TO PACIFISM 

existing by its side ... A conflict becomes inevitable." 
And the conclusion? Is it anything like the pacifist hope 
in the "pressure" of the proletariat or in the "neutraliza- 
tion" of the bourgeoisie? No, the conclusion reads: 
"Here lies the greatest difficulty of the Russian revolu- 
tion . . . the need of bringing about the international 
revolution." (Volume XV, page 126.) When was this said 
and written? Not in 1905, when Nicholas II negotiated 
with Wilhelm II on the suppression of the revolution, and 
when I advanced my "accentuated" formula, but in 1918, 
1919 and later. 

The following is what Lenin said in retrospect at the 
Third Congress of the Comintern : 

"It was clear to us that the victory of the proletarian 
revolution (in Russia. L. T.) is impossible without the 
support of the international revolution, the world revolu- 
tion. Even before the revolution, and also after it, we 
believed : the revolution will begin immediately, or at least 
very soon, in the other capitalistically advanced countries, 
otherwise we are lost. And although we were aware of 
this, we did everything to maintain the Soviet system un- 
der all circumstances and at any price, for we knew that we 
are working not only for ourselves but also for the inter- 
national revolution. We knew it, and repeatedly expressed 
this conviction of ours before the October revolution as well 
as immediately afterward and during the conclusion of the 
Brest-Litovsk peace. And generally speaking this was 
right. In reality, the movement did not go in such a 
straight line as we had expected." (Minutes of the Third 
Congress of the Comintern, page 35^. Russian edition.) 

Since 1921, the movement began to proceed in a line 
that was not so straight as we had expected in 1917-1919 
(and not only in 1905). But it nevertheless did develop 
along the line of the irreconcilable antagonism between the 
workers' state and the bourgeois world. One of the two 
must perish 1 To preserve the workers' state from the 
deadly dangers, not only military but also economic, can 

153 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

be done only by the victorious development of the prole- 
tarian revolution in the West. The attempt to discover 
two positions in this question, Lenin's and mine, is the 
height of theoretical slovenliness. 'At least read over Lenin, 
do not calumniate him, do not feed us with stale Stalinist 
pap ! 

But the decline does not come to a halt here. After 
Radek has invented the story that Lenin considered the 
"simple" (in essence, reformist, Purcellian) aid of the world 
proletariat sufficient, while Trotsky " exaggeratedly" de- 
manded the state, that is, revolutionary aid, Radek con- 
tinues : 

"Experience showed in this point too that Lenin 
remained right. The European proletariat was not yet able 
to capture power, but it was strong enough, during the 
intervention, to prevent the world bourgeoisie from throw- 
ing strong forces against us. By that it helped us to main- 
tain the Soviet power. Fear of the labour movement, next 
to the antagonisms in the capitalist world itself, was the 
main force that guaranteed the maintenance of peace during 
the eight years after the termination of the intervention." 

This passage, while it does not sparkle with originality 
on the background of the writing exercises of the present- 
day literary officialdom, is nevertheless noteworthy for its 
combination of historical anachronism, political confusion 
and the grossest errors in principle. 

From Radek 's words it would follow that Lenin in 1905 
foretold in his brochure Two Tactics (this is the only work 
to which Radek refers) that the relationship of forces be- 
tween states and classes after 1917 would be such as to 
exclude for a long time the possibility of a great military 
intervention against us. In contrast to this, Trotsky in 
1905 did not foresee the situation that would necessarily 
arise after the imperialist war, but only reckoned with the 
realities of that time, such as the mighty Hohenzollern 
army, the very strong Hapsburg military power, the 
almighty Paris Bourse, etc. This is a truly monstrous 

154 



FROM MARXISM TO PACIFISM 

anachronism, which becomes evfen more complicated by its 
ridiculous inner contradictions. For according to Radek, 
my principal mistake consisted precisely of the fact that I 
did advance the perspective of the dictatorship of the pro- 
letariat "with the degree of development of 1905". Now 
the second "mistake" becomes plain : I did not consider 
the perspective of the dictatorship of the proletariat put 
forward by me on the eve of the 1905 revolution in the light 
of the international situation as it arose after 1917. When 
the usual arguments of Stalin look like this, we don't won- 
der about it, for we know well enough his "degree of de- 
velopment" in 1917 as well as in 1928. But how did Radek 
fall into such company? , 

Yet even this is not yet the worst. The worst lies in 
the fact that Radek has skipped over the boundary that 
separates Marxism from opportunism, the revolutionary 
from the pacifist position. It is a question of nothing less 
than the struggle against war, that is, of how and with 
what methods war can be averted or an end be put to it : 
by the pressure of the proletariat iwpon the bourgeoisie or 
by the civil war to overthrow the bourgeoisie ? Radek has 
accidentally introduced the essential question of proletarian 
policy into this contested field. 

Would Radek say that I "ignore" not only the peas- 
antry but also the pressure of the proletariat upon the 
bourgeoisie, and have taken into consideration the prole- 
tarian revolution exclusively ? It is hardly to be assumed 
that he will defend such an absurdity, worthy of a Thai- 
mann, Semard or a Monmousseau. At the Third Congress 
of the Comintern, the ultra-Lefts of that time (Zinoviev, 
Thalheimer, Thalmann, Bela Kun, etc.) advocated the tac- 
tic of putschism in the West as the way to save the U.S.S.R. 
Together with Lenin, I explained to them as popularly as 
possible that it would be the besti aid on their part if they 
would planfully and systematically secure their positions, 
and prepare themselves for the capture of power, instead 
of improvising revolutionary adventures for us. At that 

155 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

time, regrettably enough, Radek was not on the side of 
Lenin and Trotsky, but on the side of Zinoviev and 
Bucharin. But Radek surely recollects at any rate, the 
minutes of the Third Congress recollect it that the essence 
of the argumentation of Lenin and myself consisted pre- 
cisely of assailing the irrationally "accentuated for- 
mulation" of the ultra-Lefts. After we explained to them 
that the strengthening of the party and the growing pres- 
sure of the proletariat is a very serious factor in internal 
and international relations, we Marxists added that "pres- 
sure" is a function of ; the revolutionary struggle for power 
and depends entirely upon the development of the latter. 
For this reason, Lenin delivered a speech at the end of the 
Third Congress, at an enlarged intimate conference of the 
delegates, which was directed against the tendencies of 
passivity and temporizing, and closed with approximately 
the following moral : No adventures, but, dear friends, just 
the same, hasten a little, for by "pressure" alone we cannot 
last long. 

Radek refers to the fact that the European proletariat 
was not in a position to assume power after the war, but 
that it prevented the bourgeoisie from beating us down. 
We, too, took the occasion more than once to speak of 
this; nevertheless, the European proletariat succeeded in 
preventing our demolition only because the pressure of the 
proletariat coincided with the heaviest objective conse- 
quences of the imperialist war and the world antagonisms 
accentuated by them. Which of these elements was of 
more decisive significance : the struggle within the imperi- 
alist camp, the economic collapse, or the pressure of the 
proletariat, is hard to say, but the question cannot be posed 
that way, either. That peaceful pressure alone is inade- 
quate was demonstrated too clearly by the imperialist war, 
which came in spite of all "pressure". And finally, and 
this is most important, if the pressure of the proletariat in 
the first critical years for the Soviet republic, proved to be 
effective enough, then it was only because it was not a 

156 



FROM MARXISM TO PACIFISM 

question at that time for the workers of Europe of pressure, 
but tof the struggle for power, in which this struggle re- 
peatedly assumed the form of civil war. 

In 1905, there was neither a war nor an economic 
collapse in Europe, and capitalism and militarism were 
distinguished by a raging blood-thirstiness. The "pressure* ' 
of the social democracy of that time did not have the power 
to prevent Wilhelm II or Franz Josef from marching into 
the kingdom of Poland with their troops, or, in general, to 
come to the aid of the Czar. But even in 1918, the pressure 
of the German proletariat did not prevent the Hohenzol- 
lerns from occupying the Baltic provinces and the Ukraine* 
and if they did not get as far as Moscow then it was only 
because their military forces were not adequate. Other- 
wise why did we conclude the Brest peace? How lightly 
the yesterdays are forgotten! Without confining himself 
to the hope in the " pressure" of the proletariat, Lenin re- 
peatedly asserted that without the German revolution we 
would certainly be destroyed. This was correct in essence,, 
although the intervals were shifted. We need no illusions : 
we have received an undated moratorium. We live, as 
before, under the conditions of a "breathing space". 

A condition in which the proletariat has not yet seized 
power, but can prevent the bourgeoisie from utilizing its 
power for a war, is a condition of a shaky class equilibrium 
in its sharpest expression. It is just the kind of condition 
that cannot last long. The scales must dip towards one 
side or the other. Either the proletariat comes to power, 
or else the bourgeoisie, by a series of successive blows, 
weakens the revolutionary pressure in such a way that it 
once more gains freedom of action, above all in the ques- 
tion of war and peace. . 

Only a reformist can picture the pressure of the prole- 
tariat upon the bourgeois state as a permanently increas- 
ing factor and as a guarantee against intervention. It is 
precisely out of this conception that arose the theory of 
the construction of socialism in one country by means of 

157 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

the neutralization of the world bourgeoisie (Stalin). Just 
as the owl takes flight at twilight, so also did the Stalin- 
ist theory of the neutralization of the bourgeoisie by the 
pressure of the proletariat arise only when the conditions 
whioh engendered this theory began to disappear. 

While the falsely interpreted experience of the post- 
war period led to the deceptive hope we can manage to 
live without the revolution of the European proletariat, 
and substitute for it "support in general" the world situa- 
tion has in the meantime undergone abrupt changes. The 
defeats of the proletariat opened up roads for capitalist 
stabilization. The collapse of capitalism after the war 
was checked. New generations grew up who had not 
tasted the horrors of the imperialist slaughter. The result 
is that the bourgeoisie is now able to dispose more freely 
of its war machine than it was five or eight years ago. 

The Leftward radicalization of the working masses will 
undoubtedly, in its further development, once more 
sharpen the pressure upon the bourgeois state. But this is 
a two-edged sword. It is precisely the growing danger 
from the side of the working class that can, at a later 
stage, drive the bourgeoisie to decisive steps in order to 
show that it is master at home, and to attempt to des- 
troy the great center of contagion, the Soviet republic. 
The struggle against war is decided not by pressure upon 
the government but by the revolutionary struggle for 
power. The "pacifist" effects of the proletarian class 
struggle, like its reformist effects, are only by-products of 
the revolutionary struggle for power, they have only a 
relative strength and can easily turn into the opposite, 
that is, they can drive the bourgeoisie on to the road of 
war. The bourgeoisie's fear of the labor movement, to 
which Radek refers so one-sidedly, is the most substantial 
hope of all social pacifists. But "fear" of the revolution 
alone decides nothing. The revolution decides. For this 
reason, Lenin said in 1905 that the only guarantee against 
the monarchist restoration, and, in 1918, against the res- 

158 



FROM MARXISM TO PACIFISM 

toration of capitalism, is not the pressure of the proletariat 
but its revolutionary victory in Europe. This is the only 
correct way of posing the question. In spite of the lengthy 
character of this "breathing space", it still remains fully 
in force today. I too put the question in the very same 
way. I wrote in Results and Perspectives in 1906: 

"It is precisely the fear of the uprising of the proletariat 
that compels the bourgeois parties, which vote fabulous 
sums for war purposes, to demonstrate solemnly for peace, 
to dream of international peace institutions, even of the 
creation of the United States of Europe a pitiful decla- 
mation which, naturally, can prevent neither the antago- 
nism between the states nor armed conflicts." (Our Re- 
volution, Results and Perspectives, page 283.) 

The basic mistake of the Sixth Congress consists of 
the fact that, in order to save the pacifist and national 
reformist perspectives of Stalin-Bucharin, it embarked upon 
revolutionary-technical recipes against the war danger in 
which it separates the struggle against war from the 
struggle for power. 

The inspirers of the Sixth Congress, by their very 
nature frightened pacifists, terrified constructors of social- 
ism in one country, made the attempt to perpetuate the 
"neutralization" of the bourgeosie with the aid of the 
strengthened methods of "pressure". But since they were 
aware that their leadership up to now in a series of 
countries led to the defeat of the revolution, and threw 
the international vanguard of the proletariat far back, they 
endeavoured first of all to square their accounts with the 
"accentuated formulation" of Marxism, which ties up the 
problem of war into an inseparable knot with the problem 
of the revolution. They have made the struggle against 
the war an independent task. In order that the national 
parties shall not oversleep the decisive hour, they pro- 
claimed the war danger as permanent, unpostponable and 
immediate. Everything that happens in the world 
happens for the purpose of war. War is now no longer 

159 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

a means of the bourgeois regime, but the bourgeois 
regime is a means of war. As a consequence, the struggle 
of the Communist International against war is converted 
into a system of ritualistic formulae, which are repeated 
automatically at every occasion and, losing their effective- 
ness, evaporate. Stalinist national socialism has the ten- 
dency to convert the Communist International into an 
auxiliary means of "pressure" upon the bourgeoisie. It is 
just this tendency, and not Marxism, that helps Radek 
with his superficial, draggle-tailed and thoughtless criticism. 
He has lost the compass and has landed in a strange 
stream that can bring him to far different shores. 

ALMA-ATA, October 



160 



CHAPTER NINE 



EPILOGUE 



THE PROPHECY or the -apprehension which is expressed in 
the concluding lines of the previous chapter was, as is 
known, confirmed a few months later. The criticism of the 
permanent revolution only served Radek as a jumping board 
to get away from the Opposition. Our whole brochure 
proves, we hope, that Radek's passage into the camp of 
Stalin did not come to us unexpectedly. But even renegacy 
has its gradations, its levels of debasement. In his declara- 
tion of repentance, Radek completely rehabilitates Stalin's 
policy in China. This means to sink down to the level of 
betrayal. There only remains for me to quote an extract 
from my reply to the penitent declaration of Radek, Pre- 
obrazhensky and Smilga, which is a license for all political 
cynicism : 

"As was seemly for all who set some store by themselves, 
the trio could not forbear from taking cover behind the per- 
manent revolution. The most tragic experience of the whole 
recent history of the defeats of opportunism the Chinese 
revolution the trio of capitulators seeks to do away with 
by the cheap oath that it has nothing in common with the 
theory of the permanent revolution. 

"Radek and Smilga obstinately defended the sub- 
ordination of the Chinese Communist Party to tfce 
bourgeois Kuo Min Tang, not only up to the coup d'Etat of 
Chiang Kai-Shek but also afterwards. Preobrazhensky 

161 
11 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

mumbled something incomprehensible, as he always does 
in political questions. A remarkable fact : all those in the 
ranks of the Opposition who defended the subordination of 
the Communist Party to the Kuo Min Tang turned out to be 
capitulators. This outright mark of shame does not burden 
a single Oppositionist who has remained true to his banner. 
Seventy-five years after the appearance of the Communist 
Manifesto, a quarter of a century after the founding of the 
party of the Bolsheviks, these ill-starred 'Marxists' con- 
sidered it possible to defend the remaining of the Communists 
in the cage of the Kuo Min Tang! In his answer to my 
charges, Radek already then, just as in his letter of repent- 
ance today, frightened us with .the ' isolation' of the 
proletariat from the peasantry in the event that the Com- 
munist party withdrew from the bourgeois Kuo Min Tang. 
Shortly before that, Radek called the Canton government a 
peasants' and workers' government and thereby helped 
Stalin to disguise the subordination of the proletariat to the 
bourgeoisie. With what are these shameful deeds, the 
consequences of this blindness, this stupidity, this betrayal 
of Marxism to be covered ? With what ? With the 
permanent revolution ! 

"As far back as February 1928, Radek, who was already 
looking for an occasion for his capitulation, adhered promply 
to the resolution of the February Plenum of the Executive 
Committee of the Comintern in 1928 on the Chinese question. 
This resolution brands the Trotskyists as liquidators because 
thy called defeats, defeats, and were not willing to consider 
the victorious Chinese counter-revolution as the highest 
level of the Chinese revolution. In this February resolution 
the course towards the armed uprising and the Soviets was 
proclaimed. For every person not devoid of political 
instinct, sharpened by revolutionary experience, this 
resolution constitutes a model of the most revolting and 
most irresponsible adventurism. Radek adhered to it. 
Preobrazhensky approached the matter no less ingeniously 
than Radek, only from a different angle. The Chinese 

162 



EPILOGUE 

revolution, he wrote, is already defeated, and defeated for 
a long time. A new revolution will not come so soon. Does 
it pay to squabble about China with the Centrists? On 
this theme, Preobrazhensky sent out lengthy epistles. 
When I read them in Alma-Ata, I experienced a feeling of 
shame. What did these people learn in Lenin's school, I 
asked myself over and over again. Preobrazhensky's 
premises were diametrically opposed in content to Radek's 
premises, yet the conclusions were the same : both of them 
were inspired by the great desire for Yaroslavsky to embrace 
them fraternally through the medium of Menzhinsky 17 . Oh, 
of course, for the good of the revolution. These are in no 
sense careerists heaven forbid : they are simply helpless, 
ideologically desolated people. 

"Against the adventurist resolution of the February 
Plenum of the E.C.C.I. (192S) I already then put forward 
the course towards the mobilization of the Chinese workers 
under the slogan of democracy, including also the Chinese 
Constituent Assembly. But here the hapless trio threw a 
somersault to the Left : that 'was cheap and obligated them 
to nothing. Democratic slogans ? Never. "This is a gross 
mistake of Trotsky.' Chinese Soviets and not one per 
cent discount ! It is hard to conceive of any thing more 
senseless than this by your leave position. The slogan 
6 Soviets P in the epoch of the bourgeois reaction is a baby- 
rattle, a mockery of the Soviets. But even in the epoch 
of the revolution, that is, in the epoch of the direct building 
of the Soviets, we did not eliminate the slogans of demo- 
cracy. We did not eliminate them until the real Soviets, 
which had already conquered power, clashed before the 
eyes of the masses with the real institutions of the demo- 
cracy. This signifies in the language of Lenin, (and not of 
the philistine Stalin and his parrots) : not to skip over the 
democratic stage in the development of the country. 

" Outside of the democratic program constituent assem- 
bly; eight-hour day; confiscation of the land; national 
independence of China; right of self-determination for the 

168 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

peoples living within it outside of this democratic pro* 
gram, the Communist Party of China is bound hand and 
foot and is compelled to surrender the field passively to the 
Chinese social democracy which, with the aid of Stalin, 
Radek and company, would be in a position to assume the 
place of the Communist party. 

"Thus: although in the tow of the Opposition, Radek 
nevertheless overslept what was most impofrtant in the 
Chinese revolution, for he defended the subordination of 
the Communist party to the bourgeois Kuo Min Tang. 
Radek overslept the Chinese counter-revolution, by sup- 
porting the course upon the armed uprising after the Canton 
adventure. Radek today skips over the period of the 
counter-revolution and the struggle for democracy when, 
with a defensive gesture, he substitutes for the tasks of 
the transition period the abstract idea of Soviets beyond 
time and place. But for that Radek swears that he has 
nothing in common with the permanent revolution. That 
is gratifying. That is consoling. . . . 

"The anti-Marxian theory of Stalin-Radek contains for 
China, India and all the countries of the East, the altered 
but not improved repetition of the Kuo Min Tang experi- 
ment. 

"On the basis of all the experience ojf the Russian and 
Chinese revolutions, on the basis of the teachings of Marx 
and Lenin, tested in the light of these revolutions the 
Opposition contends : 

"that the new Chinese revolution can overthrow the 
existing regime and transfer the power to the masses of the 
people exclusively in the form of the dictatorship of the 
proletariat ; 

"that the 'democratic dictatorship of the proletariat and 
ther {peasantry*, in contrast to the dictatorship of the pro- 
letariat which leads the peasantry and realizes the program 
of democracy is a fiction, self-deception, or what is worse 
yet a Kerenskiad or a Kuo Min Tang adventure. 

"Between the regime of Kerensky and Chiang Kai-Shek 

164 



EPILOGUE 

on the one hand and thel dictatorship of the proletariat on 
the other, there is no revolutionary transitional regime and 
there can be none; whoever contends anything else is 
shamefully deceiving the workers of the East and is pre- 
paring new catastrophes. 

"The Opposition says to the workers of the East : through 
inner-party machinations, desolated capitulators are helping 
Stalin to sow the seeds of Centrism, to blind your eyes, to 
stop up your ears, to befuddle your heads. On the one 
hand, you are weakened in face of the naked bourgeois 
dictatorship by being forbidden to unfold the struggle for 
democracy; on the other hand, perspectives are painted 
for you of some kind of a non-proletarian dictatorship that 
will deliver you, and thereby new transformations of the 
Kuo Min Tang are supported, that is, new suppressions of 
the workers' and peasants 5 revolution. 

"Such preachers are betrayers. Learn to distrust them, 
workers of the East, learn to despise them, learn to drive 
them out of your ranks ! . . . " 



165 



CHAPTER TEN 



WHAT IS THE PERMANENT 
REVOLUTION? 



Fundamental Theses 



I HOPE THAT the reader will not object if, to end up this 
book, I attempt, without fear of repetition, to formulate 
briefly the most fundamental conclusions. 

(i) The theory of the permanent revolution now demands 
the greatest attention of every Marxist, for the course of 
the ideological and class struggle has finally and conclusively 
raised this question from the realm of reminiscences over 
the old differences of opinion among Russian Marxists and 
converted it into a question of the character, the inner 
coherence and the methods of the international revolution 
in general. 

(ii) With regard to the countries with a belated bourgeois 
development, especially the colonial and semi-colonial 
countries, the theory of the permanent revolution signifies 
that the complete and genuine solution of their tasks, 
democratic and national emancipation^ is conceivable only 
through the dictatorship of the proletariat as the leader of 
the subjugated nation, above all of its peasant masses. 

(iii) Not only the agarian, but also the national question, 
assigns to the peasantry, the overwhelming majority of the 
population of the backward countries, an important place 
in the democratic revolution. Without an alliance of the 
proletariat w^th the peasantry, the tasks of the democratic 
revolution cannot be solved, nor even seriously posed. But 
the alliance of these two classes can be realized in no other 

166 



FUNDAMENTAL THE'SES 

way than through an intransigeant struggle against the 
influence of the national liberal bourgeoisie. 

(iv) No matter how the first episodic stages of the revolu- 
tion may be in the individual countries, the realization of 
the revolutionary alliance between the proletariat and the 
peasantry is conceivable only under the political direction 
of the proletarian vanguard, organized in the Communist 
party. This in turn means that the victory of the demo- 
cratic revolution is conceivable only through the dictator- 
ship of the proletariat which bases itself upon the alliance 
with the peasantry and first solves the problems of the 
democratic revolution. 

(v) The old slogan of Bolshevism "the democratic 
dictatorship of the proletariat and peasantry" expresses 
precisely the above characterized relationship of the prole- 
tariat, the peasantry and the liberal bourgeoisie. This has 
been confirmed by the experience of October. But the old 
formula of Lenin does not settle in advance the problem 
of what the mutual relations between the proletariat and 
the peasantry inside of the revolutionary bloc will be. In 
other words, the formula has unknown algebraic quantities 
which have to make way for precise arithmetical quantities 
in the process of historical experience. The latter showed, 
and under circumstances that exclude etery other interpre- 
tation, that no matter how great the revolutionary r61e of 
the peasantry may be, it can nevertheless not be an inde- 
pendent role and even less a leading one. The peasant 
follows either the worker or the bourgeois. This means 
that the "democratic dictatorship of the proletariat and 
peasantry " is only conceivable as a dictatorship of the pro- 
letariat that leads the peasant masses behind it. 

(vi) A democratic dictatorship of the proletariat and 
peasantry, as a regime that is distinguished 
dictatorship of the proletariat by its class cc 
be realized only in case an independent revol 
could be constituted which expresses themtefp&s of the" 
peasants and in general of 




167 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

party that is capable of conquering power with this or that 
aid of the proletariat and of determining its revolutionary 
program. As modern history teaches especially the his- 
tory of Russia in the last twenty-five years an insurmount- 
able obstacle on the road to the creation of a peasants' 
party is the economic and political dependence of the petty 
bourgeoisie and its deep internal differentiation, thanks to 
which the upper sections of the petty bourgeoisie (the 
peasantry) go with the big bourgeoisie in all decisive cases, 
especially in war and in revolution, and the lower sections 
with the proletariat, while the intermediate section has 
the choice between the two extreme poles. Between the 
Kerenskiad and the Bolshevik power, between the Kuo Min 
Tang and the dictatorship of the proletariat there cannot 
and does not lie any intermediate stage, that is, no 
democratic dictatorship of the workers and peasants. 

(vii) The endeavor of the Comintern to foist upon the 
Eastern countries the slogan of the democratic dictatorship 
of the proletariat and peasantry, finally and long ago 
exhausted by history, can have only a reactionary effect. 
In so far as this slogan is counter-posed to the slogan of the 
dictatorship of the proletariat, it contributes to the dis- 
solution of the proletariat into the petty bourgeois masses 
and in this manner* creates better conditions for the hege- 
mony of the national bourgeoisie and consequently for the 
collapse of the democratic revolution. The introduction of 
this slogan into the program of the Comintern is a direct 
betrayal of Marxism and of the October traditions of Bol- 
shevism. 

(viii) The dictatorship of the proletariat which has risen 
to power as the leader of the democratic revolution is in- 
evitably and very quickly placed before tasks that are 
bound up with deep inroads into the rights of bourgeois 
property. The democratic revolution grows over immedi- 
ately into the socialist, and thereby becomes a permanent 
revolution. 

(ix) The conquest of power by the proletariat does not 

168 



FUNDAMENTAL THESES 

terminate the revolution, but only opens it. Socialist con- 
struction is conceivable only on the foundation of the class 
struggle, on a national and international scale. This 
struggle, under the ^conditions of an overwhelming pre- 
dominence of capitalist relationships on the world arena, 
will inevitably lead to explosions, that is, internally to civil 
wars, and externally to revolutionary wars. Therein lies 
the permanent character of the socialist revolution as such, 
regardless of whether it is a backward country that is in- 
volved, which only yesterday accomplished its democratic 
revolution, or an old capitalist country, which already has 
behind it a long epoch of democracy and parliamentarism. 

(x) The completion of the socialist revolution within 
national limits is unthinkable. One of the basic reasons 
for the crisis in bourgeois society is the fact that the pro- 
ductive forces created by it conflict with the framework of 
the national state. From this follow, on the one hand, 
imperialist wars, and on the other, the Utopia of the bour- 
geois United States of Europe. The socialist revolution 
commences on the national arena, is developed further on 
the inter-state and finally on the world arena. Thus, the 
socialist revolution becomes a permanent revolution in a 
newer and broader sense of the word ; it attains completion 
only in the final victory of the new society on our entire 
planet. 

(xi) The above outlined schema of the development of the 
world revolution eliminates the question of the countries 
that are "mature" or "immature" for socialism in the spirit 
of that pedantic, lifeless classification given by the present 
program of the Comintern. In so far as capitalism has 
created the world market, the division of labor and pro- 
ductive forces throughout the world, it has also prepared 
world economy for socialist transformation. 

The various countries will go through this process at 
different tempos. Backward countries, under certain con- 
ditions, can arrive at the dictatorship of the proletariat 
sooner than the advanced countries, but they come later 

169 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

than the latter to socialism. 

tA. backward colonial or semi-colonial countyry, whose 
proletariat is insufficiently prepared to unite the peasantry 
and seize power, is thereby incapable $f bringing the demo- 
cratic revolution to its conclusion. On the contrary, in a 
country where the proletariat has power in its hands as 
the result of the democratic revolution, the subsequent fate 
of the/ dictatorship and socialism is not only and not so 
much dependent in the final analysis upon the national 
productive forces, as it is upon the development of the 
international socialist revolution. 

(xii) The theory of socialism in one country which rose 
on the yeast of the reaction against October is the only 
theory that consistently, and to the very end, opposes the 
theory of the permanent revolution. 

The attempt of the epigones, under the blows of our 
criticism, to confine the application of the theory of social- 
ism in one country exclusively to Russia, because of its 
specific characteristics (its extensiveness and its natural 
resources) does not improve matters but only makes them 
worse. The break with the international position always 
leads to a national messianism, that is, to attribute special 
prerogatives and peculiarities to one's own country, which 
would permit it to play a role that other countries cannot 
attain. 

The world division of labor, the dependence of Soviet 
industry upon foreign technique, the dependence of the 
productive forces of the advanced countries of Europe upon 
Asiatic raw materials, etc., etc., make the construction of 
a socialist society in any single country impossible. 

(xiii) The theory of Stalin-Bucharin not only contrasts the 
democratic revolution quite mechanically to the socialist 
revolution, but also tears the national revolution from the 
international path. 

This theory sets the revolution in the backward countries 
the task of establishing an unrealizable regime of the demo* 
cratic dictatorship, it contrasts this regime to the dictator- 

170 



FUNDAMENTAL THESES 

ship of the proletariat, thus introducing illusion and fiction 
into politics, paralyzing the struggle for power of the pro- 
letariat in the East, and hampering the victory of the 
colonial revolution. 

The very seizure of power by the proletariat signifies, 
from the standpoint of the theory of the epigones, the 
completion of the revolution (to "nine-tenths", according 
to Stalin's formula) and the opening of the epoch of national 
reform. The theory of the kulak growing into socialism and 
the theory of the "neutralization" of the world bourgeoisie 
are consequently inseparable from the theory of socialism in 
one country. They stand and fall together. 

By the theory of national socialism, the Communist 
International is degraded to a weapon useful only for the 
struggle against military intervention. The present policy 
of the Comintern, its regime, and the selection of its lead- 
ing personnel, correspond entirely to the debasement of the 
Communist International to an auxiliary corps which is 
not destined to solve independent tasks. 

(xiv) The program of the Comintern created by Bucharin 
is thoroughly eclectic. It makes the hopeless attempt ta 
reconcile the theory of socialism in one country with 
Marxian internationalism, which is, however, inseparable 
from the permanent character of the world revolution. The 
struggle of the Communist Left Opposition for a correct 
policy and a healthy regime in the Communist International 
is inseparably combined with a struggle for a Marxian pro- 
gram. The question of the program in turn is inseparable 
from the question of the two mutually exclusive theories : 
the theory of permanent revolution and the theory of 
socialism in one country. The problem of the permanent 
revolution has long ago outgrown the episodic differences 
of opinion between Lenin and Trotsky, which were com- 
pletely exhausted by history. The struggle is between the 
basic ideas of Marx and Lenin on the one side and the 
eclectics of the Centrists on the other. 

CONSTANTINOPLE, November 80, 1929. 

171 



NOTES 



1 This speech was delivered on May 6, 1929, was first published at 
the beginning of 1980, and under such circumstances that it acquires 
a "programmatic" significance. 

2 Algebra deals with general quantities (a, b, c) in contrast to 
arithmetic which always employs definite quantities (1, 2, 8). 

3 This prophecy has in the meantime been fulfilled. 

4 In 1909, Lenin did indeed quote my Results and Perspectives, in 
an article intended as a polemic against Martov. It would not, how- 
ever, be difficult to prove that Lenin took over the quotations at 
second hand, that is, from Martov in this case. This is the only way 
that certain of his replies directed at me, which are based upon 
obvious misunderstanding^, can be explained. 

In 1919, the State Publishing House issued my Results and Perspec- 
tives as a special pamphlet. The annotation to the complete edition 
of Lenin's works, which is to the effect that the theory of the per- 
manent revolution is especially note- worthy "now", after the October 
revolution, dates back to approximately the same time. Did Lenin 
read my Results and Perspectives in 1919, or merely glance through 
it? On this I cannot say anything definite. I was then constantly 
travelling, came to Moscow only for short stays, and during my meet- 
ings with Lenin ic that period at the height of the civil war fac- 
tional theoretical reminiscences never entered our minds. But A. A. 
Joffe did have r conversation with Lenin, just at that time, on the 
theory of the permanent revolution. Joffe reported this conversation 
in the farewell letter he wrote me before his death. (See My Life, 
Scribners, New York, page 537). Can A. A. Joffe's assertions be con- 
strued that Lenin in 1919 became acquainted for the first time with 
Results and Prespectives and confirmed the correctness of the his- 
torical prognosis contained in it? On this matter I can only express 
psychological conjectures. The power of conviction of these conjec- 
tures depends upon the evaluation of the kernel of the disputed 
question its. If. A. A. Joffe's words, that Lenin had confirmed my 
prognosis as correct, must appear incomprehensible to a man who has 
been raised upon the theoretical margarine of the post-Leninist epoch. 
On the other hand, whoever reflects upon the evolution of Lenin's 
ideas in connection with the development of the revolution itself, 
will understand that Lenin, in 1919. had to deliver a new judgment 
on the theory of the permanent revolution, different from the ones he 
pronounced fleetingly, in passing, often manifestly self-contradictory* 
at various times before the October revolution, on the br*is of isola- 
ted quotations without even once examining my position a a whole. 

In order to confirm iny prognosis as correct in 1919, Lenin did not 
need to contrast my position to his. It sufficed to consider both 
positions in their historical development. It is not necessary to repeat 
here that the concrete content with which Lenin always invested his 
formula of "democratic dictatorship" and which resulted less from 
a hypothetical formula than from the analysis of the actual change 

178 * 



PERMANENT REVOLUTION 

in class relationships of forces that this tactical and organizational 
content has passed once and for all into the inventory of history as 
a classic example of revolutionary realism. In almost all the cases, 
at any rate in all the important cases, where I placed myself in con- 
tradiction to Lenin tactically or organizationally, the right was on 
his side. That is just why it did not interest me to come forward for 
my old historical prognosis, so long as it might appear that it was 
only a matter of historical reminiscences. I found myself compelled 
to return to this question only at the moment when the 
criticism of the epigones of the theory of the permanent revolu- 
tion not only began to nurture the theoretical reaction of the 
whole International, but also became converted into a means of the 
direct sabotage of the Chinese revolution. 

5 As is known, the voluminous minutes of this historic session were 
torn out of the jubilee book c,t the special command of Stalin and 
to this day are kept concealed from the party. 

I recollect that I called out to Bucharin at r fce Seventh Plenum of 
the Executive Committee of the Communist International when he 
cited the same quotations : "But there are also directly contrary 
quotations in Lenin.'* After a brief moment of perplexity, Bucharin 
retorted : "I know that, I know that, but I cm taking what I need, 
not what you need." There is the quick repartee of this theoretician 
for yon! 

It should be remembered that at that time Parvus stood at 
the extreme Left wing of international Marxism. 

7 The Trudovik were the representatives of the peasants in the four 
Dumas, constantly oscillating between the Cadets (Liberals) and the 
social democrats. 

8 This quotation, together with a hundred others, shows in passing 
that I recognized the existence of the peasantry and the significance of 
the agrarian question already on the eve of the 1905 revolution, that 
is, that I began to be aware of the significance of the peasantry 
somewhat earlier than the Maslows, Thalheimers, Thalmanns Rem- 
meles, Cachins, Monmousseaus, Bela Runs, Peppers, Kuusinens and 
other Marxian sociologists. 

9 At the 1909 conference, Lenin recommended the formula of "the 
proletariat which leads the peasantry", but then he associated himself 
with the formula of the Polish social democrats which thereby obtained 
the majority at the conference against the Mensheviks. 

10 In a speech, Stalin once called himself the "Master of the 
revolution". 

11 The local autonomous administration, the "zemstvo", consisted of 
representatives of the landowners among, the nobility ("zemtsi"). 

"Yakovlev was recently appointed People's Commissar of Agri- 
culture of the U. S. S. R. 

"Excerpt from the minutes of the session of the Organization 
Bureau of the Central Committee of May 22, 1922, under No. 21 : 

174 



NOTES 

"To commission comrade Yakoylev ... to compile a textbook on the 
history of the October revolution under the editorial supervision of 
comrade Trotsky." 

14 On June 8 (16), 1907, the coup d'etat was completed which for- 
inaugurated the period of triumphant counter-revolution. 

"Literally, "tail-endist", One who drags along in tow of events Tr. 

"Chiang Kai-Shek is the leader of the Right wing, and Wang Chin 
Wei of the Left wing of the Kuo Min Tang. Tang Ping, Shan was in 
the leadership of the Communist Party of China during the revolu- 
tionary upsurge, defended the policies of Stalin-Bucharin-Martinov in 
China, was one of the spokesmen in the international campaign 
against "Trotskyism" and became the "Communist" minister of 
agriculture in the bourgeois government of Hankow in 1927. He is 
now outside the ranks of the Communist Party of China and has 
since become an adversary of Communism. Tr. 

; 7 Menzhinsky is the head of the O. G. P. U., (the State Politic*! 
Administration); Yaroslavsky is one of the heads of the Central Control 
Commission of the party and was especially active in attacking, the 
Opposition and expelling many of its adherents from the party. Tr. 



175